Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

A History of Hindu Political Theories from the Earliest Times to the End of the First Quarter of the Seventeenth Century A.D. c12.s1.16

A History of Hindu Political Theories from the Earliest Times to the End of the First Quarter of the Seventeenth Century A.D. c12.s1.16

Language
English

c12.s1.16

Allied to the above idea of Medhātithi—namely that the king's duty of protection extends to all classes of his subjects—is the opinion of Aparārka that the duty of punishment of the guilty is a compulsory duty. The duty of punishment, it seems, much as it is inculcated by the Hindu authors, is often supported as in the following passage from Yājñavalkya by the promise of spiritual rewards alone In accordance with the rule of interpretation applicable to such cases this would signify that the above duty was not compulsory, but optional. Aparārka meets this possible argument by quoting the canonical texts that impose penances for the king's default in the infliction of punishment. He observes with reference to a verse of Yājñavalkya requiring the king to punish the guilty,∗ " 'By these words it is not to be understood that punishment is a duty performed for some particular object (and therefore optional). Because Vaśiṣṭha prescribes penances for not carrying out this function: 'if people deserving punishment are set free, the king should fast one (day and one) night, and the purohita three (days and) nights; if those not deserving punishment are punished, the purohita should perform a krichchhra penance (and) the king should fast three days and nights.' "*

Cites (1)