The Positive Background of Hindu Sociology c11.s1.t6.6
The Positive Background of Hindu Sociology c11.s1.t6.6
- Language
- English
c11.s1.t6.6
This interpretation by Smith is entirely wrong. It is the exact opposite of the views maintained by Hillebrandt and Jolly. Neither of them was convinced of the Mauryanism of the *Arthaśāstra*. Hillebrandt did not dogmatize and venture on any date; but Jolly, although favourable at the outset (1911), was positively against the Maurya origin. The words "*echt*" (genuine or authentic) and "*alt*" (old) used by them did not mean anything more than that it was not a work of any period, say, after the seventh or eighth century A.C. It is regrettable that in English-speaking countries, and especially in India, a misleading notion about the attitude of German indology in regard to the Kauṭalya question should have been propagated by Smith's work at a time when the Hillebrandt-Jacobi controversy and the Jolly-Jacobi controversy were the most characteristic features of this branch of studies in Germany relating to Hindu culture.
Cites (1)
- Kauṭilīya Arthaśāstra — Kauṭilya, Sanskrit