An Introduction to Tantric Buddhism c7.13
An Introduction to Tāntric Buddhism c7.13
- Language
- English
c7.13
The *Prajñopāya-viniścaya-siddhi* of Anaṅga-vajra begins like the *Madhyānta-vibhāga-ṭīka* with the assertion that all existence comes from the absolute wherein there is no imaginary construction of existence,⁴—and from this false mental construction come all the pangs of sufferings. False notions give rise to the cycle of birth and death which is at the bottom of all miseries. So long as there is this false mental construction none can do any good either to himself or to others. So, to attain perfect bliss either for the self or for the three worlds, the wise must first of all do away with this notion of existence. But the author warns that after destroying the notion of existence one should not go to the opposite extreme of adopting the nihilistic view. It is better to have the imagination of existence (*bhāva-kalpanā*) than that of non-existence (*abhāva-kalpanā*); for, the burning lamp can be extinguished; but if it be not burning at all how can it be extinguished?⁵ If there be the notion of *bhāva*, there remains the possibility of *nirvāṇa*,—but if there be no notion of *bhāva* or *saṁsāra*, how can there be *nirvāṇa* or final extinction? There is no possibility of annihilating the beginningless vacuity.¹ Here the contention of the author seems to be that our moral struggle for our final purification and perfection presupposes a world of objectivity and it is for this reason that for the final purification it is wiser to have even a false positive notion about the objective world than a purely negative notion which leaves no scope for morality. But we may mention here that this question did not escape the eyes of the so-called negativists, and Nāgārjuna in his *Mādhyamika-vṛtti* did answer the question definitely in his own way.²
Cites (2)
- Prajñopāyaviniścayasiddhi — Anaṅgavajra, Sanskrit
- Madhyāntavibhāgabhāṣya — Classical Tibetan