The System of the Vedanta according to Badarayana's Brahma-Sutras and Cankara's Commentary c7.s7.t3.6
The System of the Vedânta according to Bâdarâyana's Brahma-Sûtras and Çankara's Commentary c7.s7.t3.6
- Language
- English
c7.s7.t3.6
(b) The Creator of the World as the Cause of Evil.—We have two answers to the arguments marshalled under this heading, an empirical answer, 2, 1, 23, and one which amounts to the doctrine of identity 2, 1, 22, and, remarkable to say, the former stands second. Even if these two parts were written down by the same hand, it is hardly thinkable that they were originated in the same head. We shall reverse their order, and examine the empirical answer first.—Just as, it is said, 2, 1, 23, the same earth brings forth many kinds of stones, the most costly jewels, as well as the most common stones of the fields; as the same earth produces plants which vary in leaves, flowers, fruits, smell and taste, or as in men from the same essence of food (*annarasa*) spring blood, hair, and nails, all quite different; in the same way, from the one Brahman proceeds the division into the individual and highest souls, and the variety of [good and evil] effects.—Quite another character than that of this empirical comparison is borne by the directly preceding section, 2, 1, 22. It is true that here also our author starts from the separation (only indicated by the Sûtram) of God and the soul, in order to transfer all moral guilt from the former to the latter. Brahman is omniscient and omnipotent, everlasting, pure, wise and free. Because he is free, he can do what he wills; for him, there is neither command nor prohibition, and therefore neither good nor evil.¹⁰⁷ The individual soul, on the contrary, is affected by good and evil (reading *ca* instead of *na*, p. 473, 4), and of it we do not at all maintain that it is the creator of the world.—Without committing himself to the question, unavoidable from this standpoint, "Whence then springs the individual soul, with its good and evil?" our author at once passes on to the metaphysical explanation: "But how is this? Are not God and the soul the same, according to the words: *tat tvam asi*?"—To this it is replied: "When, by the teaching of non-separateness, through sentences like *tat tvam asi*, the consciousness of non-separateness is awakened, then the wanderings of the soul and the creative function of Brahman cease; for the whole tendency of the world of division springs from false knowledge, and is removed by perfect knowledge. Whence, then, the creation? and whence the responsibility for not having brought forth good only? For *Saṃsāra*, which has as its characteristics the doing of good and evil, is an illusion produced by non-discrimination of the determinations (which, produced by Ignorance, consist in the aggregate of the instruments of activity formed by names and forms), and this illusion just as the error (*abhimāna*) of division and separation by birth and death, does not exist in the sense of the highest reality" (p. 472, 14—475, 4).
Cites (2)
- Brahmasūtra — Bādarāyaṇa, Sanskrit
- Chāndogyopaniṣad — Sanskrit