Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them v2.c20.s2.22
Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them v2.c20.s2.22
- Language
- English
v2.c20.s2.22
It is welcome that the professors are prepared for an investigation for finding whether the KaTra mound hides the remains of a Buddhist monastery under the remains of the KeSavadeva temple. Only a thorough excavation of the site on which the Idgah stands can settle the question. But it must be pointed out that the excavation may not stop at the Buddhist monastery if it is uncovered at all. If it is true, as they say, that Hindus and Buddhists were at daggers drawn in the pre-Islamic period, they should be prepared for the possibility that the Buddhist monastery itself was built on the ruins of an earlier Hindu temple. After all, the most ancient and prolific Indian literature associates Mathura with the birth and youth of Sri KrishNa, while the Buddhist associations with Mathura do not go beyond Greek and KushaNa times. We have already quoted Romila Thapar regarding the KeSvadeva tradition going back to the Mauryan period. It is quite plausible on the hypothesis of the professors that some Greek or KushaNa patron of Buddhism destroyed a Hindu temple which stood at Sri KrishNa's place of birth before he raised a Buddhist monastery on the site. Of course, we do not subscribe to this story of Hindu-Buddhist conflict. There is no evidence that the Hindus ever destroyed a Buddhist place of worship or vice versa. We are only proposing a test for the Marxist hypothesis.