Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them v2.c22: Section IV: Islamic Theology of Iconoclasm

Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them v2.c22

Language
English

Contents

Section IV: Islamic Theology of Iconoclasm

Chapter Nine: Theology of Monotheism

v2.c22.s1.2

The destruction of Hindu temples at the hands of Islamized invaders continued for more than eleven hundred years, from the middle of the seventh century to the end of the eighteenth.¹ It took place all over the cradle of Hindu culture, from Sinkiang in the North to Tamil Nadu in the South, and from Seistan in the West to Assam in the East.²

v2.c22.s1.3

All along, the iconoclasts remained convinced that they were putting into practice the highest tenets of their religion. They also saw to it that a record was kept of what they prized as a pious performance. The language of the record speaks for itself. It leaves no doubt that they took immense pride in doing what they did.

v2.c22.s1.4

It is inconceivable that a constant and consistent behaviour pattern, witnessed for a long time and over a vast area, can be explained except in terms of a settled system of belief which leaves no scope for second thoughts. Looking at the very large number of temples, big and small, destroyed or desecrated or converted into Muslim monuments, economic or political explanations can be only a futile, if not fraudulent, exercise. The explanations are not even plausible.

v2.c22.s1.5

In fact, it is not at all difficult to locate the system of belief which inspired the behaviour pattern. We have only to turn to the scriptures of Islam-the Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet-and we run straight into what we are looking for. The principles and the pious precedents which were practised and followed by the subsequent swordsmen of Islam are, all of them, there.

v2.c22.s1.6

The scriptures of Islam do not merely record what happened in the past; they also prescribe that what is recorded should be imitated by the faithful in the future, till the end of time. That is why the swordsmen of Islam who functioned in times much later than that of the Quran and the Sunnah, did what they did. It is in the very nature of scriptures, as we shall see, that they make permanent what can otherwise be dated and dismissed as temporary aberrations.

v2.c22.s1.7

Those scriptures are still being taught in hundreds of maktabs and madrasas spread over the length and breath of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. Missionaries of Islam that are turned out by these institutions, year after year, are never told by their teachers that the prescriptions regarding other peoples places of worship stand abrogated or are out of date. At the same time, the swordsmen who destroyed innumerable temples and monasteries all over the vast cradle of Hindu culture, retain their halos as the heroes of Islam. That alone can explain why Hindu temples become the first targets of attack whenever Muslim mobs are incited against India by the mullas in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Kashmir.

v2.c22.s1.8

It is, therefore, worthwhile to clarify what the word scripture stands for, before we take up the scriptures of Islam. The language of Christianity and Islam in the modern media has confused the language of religion, all along the line. Even scholars do not seem to know or care to clarify that scriptures as such are specific to the prophetic or revealed religions such as Judaism, Christianity and Islam, and that they remain unknown to the pagan³ spiritual traditions such as that of the Hindus, the Chinese, the ancient Iranians, and the pre-Christian Greeks, Romans, Germans, Slavs, Scandinavians, Celts, etc.

v2.c22.s1.9

The confusion has been further confounded by what passes for Secularism in this country. Most of our scribes in the mass media are either equally ignorant of all religions or equally indifferent to them. But they insist, with considerable vehemence, that all religions say the same things. Politicians in power are much worse. As they preside over the birthday functions or festivals related to ri Rama, sri KrishNa, Bhagavan Mahavira, Bhagavan Buddha and Guru Nanak on the one hand, and Jesus Christ and Prophet Muhammad on the other, they harangue the audience to follow the teachings in each case. It never occurs to them that Christianity and Islam have nothing in common with the Hindu spiritual traditions and that the followers of the former have tried and are trying their utmost to wipe out the latter.⁴

v2.c22.s1.10

Meaning of Scripture

v2.c22.s1.11

Etymologically, the word scripture is derived from the Latin *scribere*, to write. In the lexicons of the revealed religions, however, the word does not refer to writing down of human speech or verbalizing of human thought or recording of terrestrial events. Instead, it stands for the Word of God written in the Book.

v2.c22.s1.12

The word of God, in its turn, does not come to any and every one who seeks it, howsoever devoutly. Instead, it is revealed to some highly privileged persons known as prophets. Everyone else has to learn it second-hand, and accept it as authentic even when it runs counter to ones experience, or reason, or moral sense, or all of them taken together. No one else can have direct knowledge of it or aspire to enter into the consciousness to which it was revealed, as in the case of pagan spiritual traditions which entitle every seeker to attain the consciousness of their greatest saints and sages, and know God directly and first-hand. Belief in the word of God as spoken by *the* Prophet and as written in *the* Book is, therefore, all that is needed for qualifying as one of the faithful. At the same time, mental belief and not moral behaviour is the criterion for judging a persons character.

v2.c22.s1.13

Nor do the prophets take birth among any or every people. Etymologically, the word prophet is derived from the Greek *phanai*, to speak, which is a cognate of the Sanskrit *bhaNa*. In the lexicons of the revealed religions, however, the prophet is no ordinary spokesman. Instead, he is the spokesman of deity.⁵ And he is sent only to the Chosen People, with whom God intends to enter into a Covenant.

v2.c22.s1.14

So far there have been only three chosen people-the Jews, the Christians, and the Muslims. According to the covenants which God has entered into with them, each of them has been promised world-dominion and untold amounts of unearned wealth in exchange for making God known to all those who worship other gods and thus deny Gods Unity and Unique Majesty.

v2.c22.s1.15

Rise of Theology

v2.c22.s1.16

In due course, as the word of God is studied, systematized and interpreted, it gives birth to a supplementary discipline named Theology. Etymologically, the word theology is a compound of two Greek words-theos⁶ meaning god, and logos meaning word. But curiously enough, the ancient Greeks from whose language the compound has been constructed were unaware of the very notion of word of God. Theology was formulated and used for the first time by the Founding Fathers of the Christian Church for presenting their peculiar creed to pagans in the Roman Empire. It had nothing whatsoever to do with any Greek religion or philosophy, of which there were quite a few before they were destroyed or subverted by Christianity. Islamic scholarship which flourished in the wake of the Prophet, fashioned another theology, more or less on the same pattern, a few hundred years later.

v2.c22.s1.17

Theology is a large and complex subject. What concerns us here is some specific features which characterise it. One of those features is that the life-style of the Prophet and his companions/apostles is proclaimed as the divine pattern of human conduct which should be copied by everyone, everywhere, in order to qualify for salvation or paradise. According to another, the doings of the chosen people as they wage wars, conquer countries and convert or kill other people, are to be seen as the unfoldment of a divine plan in human history.

v2.c22.s1.18

What is most significant, however, is that theology notices and notifies three neat and sharp divisions. Firstly, it divides human history into two periods-an age of ignorance preceding the appearance of the Prophet, and an age of illumination following that event. Secondly, it bifurcates the human family into two factions-the believers who accept *the* Prophet as the one and only mediator between God and human beings, and the unbelievers who have either not heard of *the* Prophet at all or find him unacceptable for whatever reason. Thirdly, it breaks up the inhabited world into two camps-the lands ruled by the believers, and the lands where the unbelievers live.

v2.c22.s1.19

Proceeding further, theology pronounces a permanent war, hailed as holy, between the three sets of divisions. Religions and cultures which preceded the age of ignorance have to go and yield place to the religion and culture of the age of illumination. Next, the believers must strive, ceaselessly and by every means at their disposal, to convert the unbelievers to the new creed. Finally, the lands of the believers must be made into launching pads for missions as well as military expeditions to be sent to the lands of the unbelievers, so that the latter are conquered and turned into lands of the believers.

v2.c22.s1.20

Naturally, the places where the unbelievers worship and the institutions which sustain that worship, become the first and foremost targets of holy wars. The idols⁷ of the unbelievers Gods are at least mutilated, if they cannot be smashed to pieces. The temples where those Gods are worshipped are at least desecrated, if they cannot be destroyed. The schools and monasteries where the unbelievers learn their religion are at least plundered, if they cannot be razed to the ground. The saints, sages and scholars who guide the unbelievers are at least humiliated, driven out and deprived of livelihood, if they cannot be killed outright. The literature which enshrines the unbeliever’s religion and culture is scattered to the winds, or burnt on the spot, or used as fuel in the homes of the believers. And so on, the war on the religion and culture of the unbelievers is total and unrelenting.

v2.c22.s1.21

These operations are expected to help the unbelievers lose faith in their own Gods and acquire an awe for the God of the conqueror. The God of the conqueror stands glorified when new places of worship are raised on the sites of the old, preferably with the debris of those that have been deliberately demolished. And that God is fully vindicated when the believers tread under foot the idols of the unbelievers Gods or their pieces, as they walk towards the new places of worship for offering prayers.

v2.c22.s1.22

Finally, theology enjoins that the holy wars and all that they mean should be recorded meticulously and in lustrous language. These records testify to the unfoldment of the divine plan in human history in the past, and inspire future generations of believers to unfold it further. We have three extensive versions of this unfoldment or the triumph of the true faith over false belief-the Judaic, the Christian, and the Islamic. All of them glorify the great heroes who waged holy wars and heaped defeats and humiliations on the infidels. The rich rewards which God bestowed on the believers for fulfilling their part of the covenant are also described at length. And succeeding generations of believers have, no doubt, felt inspired to follow in the footsteps of their illustrious forefathers.

v2.c22.s1.23

Role of Theology

v2.c22.s1.24

Apart from providing the right perceptions, inspiring pious performances, and establishing illustrious precedents, theology serves another and, psychologically, a very useful purpose. It prepares the believers for feeling the glow of faith as they read or listen to the unfoldment of the divine plan in human history. The accounts are spiritually satisfying-how every trace of the religion and culture of the age of ignorance was wiped out, to start with, in the Prophet's own land of birth; how one land after another was invaded and laid waste without any provocation on the part of the victims of aggression; how innocent and defenceless people were massacred in cold blood and with a clean conscience; how large numbers of noncombatant men, women and children were captured and sold into slavery and concubinage; how native populations were reduced to the status of non-citizens, drawing water and hewing wood for the conqueror, and groaning under the weight of discriminatory levies and back-breaking disabilities; how great creations of graphic arts were mutilated or broken to pieces or trampled under foot; how edifices of exquisite beauty, embodying skills accumulated over ages, were pulled down and levelled with the ground; how whole libraries containing priceless works of science and literature, were burnt down; how saints and sages and scholars who had given no offence and meant no harm, were humiliated or manhandled or killed; how vast properties, moveable and immoveable, were misappropriated. And so on, the record is invariably crowded with the darkest crimes and fiendish cruelty. Only the believers find it fulfilling. For persons with normal moral sensibilities, it is a nightmare. The only point which goes in its favour is that it provides the best commentary on the doctrines of the creed concerned.

v2.c22.s1.25

Looking at the character of the God of revealed religions, the quality of his words, the lifestyles of his prophets, and the course of his divine plans in human history, one wonders whether the revealed religions do not reveal an Orwellian world abounding in marvels of doublethink and double-speak. Here one meets the Devil masquerading as God, and gangsters strutting around as prophets. Here one discovers that the scripture does not inspire spiritual seeking or moral discipline but, on the contrary, encourages the basest in human nature to run riot without any restraint. All in all, Theology stands out as another name for Demonology, and the revealed religions reveal themselves as no more than totalitarian ideologies of imperialism, of enslavement and genocide. They turn out to be older versions of what we have known as Communism and Nazism in our own times. A Secularism which puts them on par with the spiritual traditions of Hinduism is not only foolish but also mischievous. It misses the very meaning of religion, and shelters gangsterism.

v2.c22.s1.26

Theology of Islam

v2.c22.s1.27

Islam uses the Arabic language instead of Hebrew or Greek, but says the same things as the older revealed religions. Its only point of departure is that it abrogates the earlier revelations, and subordinates the earlier prophets to the latest and the last.

v2.c22.s1.28

Islam has hijacked Allah from the pantheon of the pre-Islamic Arabs and turned him into a jealous God who tolerates no other gods. Allah of Islam is no more than a reincarnation of Jehovah, the Judaic and the Christian God in the Bible.

v2.c22.s1.29

The prophet of Islam, Muhammad, moulds himself, consciously and progressively, in the image of Moses. In fact, his very name, Nabi, has been taken from the Hebrew Lexicon.

v2.c22.s1.30

Allah now speaks only through the mouth of Muhammad. That is the Quran, or the Book (*Kitab*). Here also the word of God is borrowed, by and large, from the Bible. The only difference is that the Quran lacks the literary merit and narrative coherence of the earlier scripture. It is a loose bundle of vehement utterances, without any chronological or thematic order, and has to be understood with the help of laborious, very often speculative, commentaries.

v2.c22.s1.31

Again, Allah acts in the life-style of Muhammad. That is the Sunnah of the Prophet. This divine pattern of human conduct knows all the answers. No pious Muslim has to use his own mental faculties or devise his own individual course of action. It is all laid down for him, from birth to death, and even beyond. As the theologians of Islam say, Muslims should not use their *aql* (reason); all they need is *naql* (imitation of the Prophet).

v2.c22.s1.32

The covenant, *MiSaq*, into which Allah enters with the newly chosen people, the *Ummatu Muhammadi*, commands them to worship him alone and convert or kill or enslave those who worship other gods. Allah’s earlier covenants with the Jews or the *Ummatu Ibrahimi* and the Christians or the *Ummatu Isa*, stand cancelled. Now onwards, Muslims alone are entitled to rule over the world and appropriate its wealth. There is a slight improvement also in the new covenant. Plunder of the infidel’s properties, particularly their women and children, was not permitted to the earlier chosen people, while it has been prescribed as obligatory for the *Ummatu Muhammadi*.

v2.c22.s1.33

The doings of the *Ummatu Muhammadi* in Arabia and many other lands manifest the divine plan in human history. The annals of Islam, the Twarikh, which are an integral part of its theology, have been penned by some of its most pious scholars.

v2.c22.s1.34

The theology of Islam, *Kalam*, deals with the same old divisions of human history, the human family, and the inhabited world. The period before Muhammad started receiving revelations and proclaimed his prophethood is denounced as *Jahiliya*, the age of ignorance; the period succeeding that event is the age of *Ilm*, enlightenment. Those who recite the Kalima or confession of faith-*La Ilaha Illallahu, Mahammadun Rasulllah* (there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is the Prophet)⁸ -are *Mumins*, the believers; those who do not, are *Kafirs*, the unbelievers. The lands ruled by the *Mumins* are *Dar al-Islam*, abodes of peace, while those where the *Kafirs* live are *Dar al-Harb*, abodes of war, where the *Mumins* should ply their swords. It sounds logical that in popular Muslim parlance a *Kafir* is often called a *Harbi*, that is, one who deserves treatment of the sword.

v2.c22.s1.35

Finally, Islam enjoins a permanent war, *Jihad*, by the *Mumins* and against the *Kafirs*. We need not give the details which we have already presented elsewhere, in principle as well as practice.⁹ Suffice it to say that it is an extremely bloody affair, entailing continued wars of conquest, massacres, mass conversions by force, widespread plunder, enslavement of prisoner taken in war, collection of booty including non-combatant men and women and children, subjugation of native populations, and the rest. What concerns us here is that *Jihad* is centred round iconoclasm. In fact, the need for *Jihad* arises only because the *Kafirs* worship their own Gods instead of Muhammad’s Allah. *Jihad*, therefore, remains incomplete till all places where those Gods are worshipped get levelled with the ground, and all saints and priests who spread and sustain *Kufr* are converted or killed.

v2.c22.s1.36

Confining ourselves to India, The Mohammedan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history, according to Will Durant, the famous student of civilizations. He finds it a discouraging tale, for its evident moral is that civilization is a precious thing whose delicate complex of order and liberty, culture and peace may at any time be overthrown by barbarians.¹⁰ But the pious Muslims read or listen to this story with immense satisfaction. They go into raptures as their heroes invade Sind and Hind, massacre the accursed *Kafirs* without remorse, capture and sell into slavery large numbers of Hindu men and women and children, kill or heap humiliations on Hindu saints and scholars, desecrate or destroy idols of Hindu Gods and Goddesses, pull down Hindu temples or convert them into *masjids* and *madrasas*, reduce the Hindus to non-citizens in their own homeland, and misappropriate all properties, moveable and immoveable. And they get furious when they find the Hindus failing to admire Muhammad bin Qasim, Mahmud of Ghazni, Muhammad Ghuri, Shamsud-Din Iltutmish, Ghiyasud-Din Balban, Alaud-Din Khalji, Muhammad and Firuz Shah Tughalaq, Sikandar Lodi, Babur, Aurangzeb, and Ahmad Shah Abdali, to cite only the most notable among Muslim heroes in the history of India. The theology of Islam has thus performed to perfection the function it is intended to perform, even though the forefathers of an overwhelming majority of Muslims in India were victims of this theology.

v2.c22.s1.37

In our specific context, namely, the destruction of Hindu temples, it should be more than sufficient if we merely cite what the Quran says, in verse after verse and chapter after chapter, vis-a-vis the *mushriks* (polytheists) and the a*Snam* (idols) they worship. Allah of Islam leaves no one in doubt that he sanctions the destruction of false gods and the places where they receive homage. So is the case with the Sunnah of the Prophet. We have only to list the instances of iconoclasm which Muhammad undertook himself or ordered in his own lifetime, and we have more than sufficient pious precedents which the faithful are expected to follow. Anyone who says that the Quran and the Sunnah do not enjoin the destruction of other peoples places of worship has either not read the documents, or has failed to grasp the message, or is practising deliberate deception. No amount of apologetics can cover up or explain away the principle and the practice.

v2.c22.s1.38

A mere narration of principle and practice, however, is likely to leave a mistaken impression. People who are not familiar with the rise and spread of Islam have been led away by the Big Lie that the people of Arabia rallied round a prophet and did, willingly and voluntarily, whatever he asked them to do, because they knew no better. This lie has succeeded to a great extent not only in the lands which are now occupied by the believers but also in India which has battled with Islam for more than thirteen hundred years. But nothing can be farther from the truth as told in the orthodox biographies of the Prophet. The people of Arabia resisted Muhammad and his message, and fought in defence of their ancient religion and culture, till they were forced to surrender in the face of a formidable military machine forged by him at Medina. The machine was financed by plunder obtained through widespread raids, and manned by desperados recruited from all over Arabia. Neither the Quran nor the Sunnah of the Prophet can be understood or evaluated properly unless it is placed in its historical context, namely, the pre-Islamic Arab society and culture which had functioned for a long time to the satisfaction of the people concerned, till Muhammad appeared on the scene.

v2.c22.s1.39

Footnotes:

v2.c22.s1.40

¹ We are leaving for the time being the destruction that took place in Muslim princely states under British rule as also that which has continued since 1947 in Pakistan, Bangladesh and Kashmir.

v2.c22.s1.41

² We are leaving for the time being the destruction which took place and is taking place in Indonesia and Malaysia.

v2.c22.s1.42

³ The *Chambers 20th Century Dictionary* defines a pagan as a heathen, one who is not a Christian, Jew, or Muslim.

v2.c22.s1.43

⁴ The subject has been discussed in detail by Dr. Harsh Narain in his study, *Myths of Composite Culture and Equality of Religions*, published by Voice of India, New Delhi, 1991.

v2.c22.s1.44

⁵ See the *Chambers 20th Century Dictionary* for the Meaning of Prophet.

v2.c22.s1.45

⁶ It is a cognate of the Sanskrit *deva*.

v2.c22.s1.46

⁷ The word idol is derived from the Greek *idein*, to see, which is a cognate of the Sanskrit *vid*, to perceive.

v2.c22.s1.47

⁸ The first part of the *Kalima* is often translated as there is no god but God, which is not only misconceived but positively mischievous. Allah of the Quran never claims to be the God of mankind; he prides in being the God of Muslims alone.

v2.c22.s1.48

⁹ *The Calcutta Quran Petition By Chandmal Chopra*, with two prefaces by Sita Ram Goel, second the enlarged edition, New Delhi. 987, pp. 35-37.

v2.c22.s1.49

¹⁰ Will Durant, *The Story of Civilization*, Vol. I, *Our Oriental Heritage*, New York, 1972, p. 459.

Chapter Ten: The Pre-Islamic Arabs

v2.c22.s2.2

Muslim theologians and historians present a pretty dark picture of pre-Islamic Arabia. Its people, we are told, were unrepentant pagans and polytheists unware of the Unity of God and the succession of his Prophets. They believed that Allah, the one and only True God, stood in need of partners who could mediate between him and his creatures. Worse still, they gave daughters to Allah while they preferred sons for themselves. They worshipped stones (*authan*) and statues (*aSnam*) and offered sacrifices to satans. They had had no Prophet (*Rasul*) and possessed no scripture (*Kitab*) of their own. Consequently, they were ignorant of the Last Day (*Qiyamat*), as also of Heaven (*Jannat*) and Hell (*Jahannam*). They revelled in blood feuds, and buried alive their female infants. Sons married their step-mothers, and the same man two or more uterine sisters. And so on, till the conviction grows on the readers or listeners that the pre-Islamic Arabs were despicable barbarians.

v2.c22.s2.3

Christian theologians and historians follow suit. They do not endorse Muhammad as a prophet; in fact, they call him an impostor. All the same, they prefer him to the pagans and polytheists whom he fought and subdued. They do not concede that Muhammad’s message was spiritually sound or morally adequate. Yet they hail his teachings as a marked improvement on the mode of worship and morals which prevailed earlier. Thus they stand solidly, though negatively, united with their Muslim counterparts in denouncing the state of affairs in pre-Islamic Arabia.

v2.c22.s2.4

And there is no dearth of Hindu scholars, even Hindu saints, who join the chorus. Even those Hindus who are by no means enamoured of Islam and distrust or despise it as a religion, regard it none-the-less an immense improvement over what went in Arabia before its advent. They say that Islam united the Arab rabble into a nation, and gave them at least the rudiments of culture. It never occurs to these Hindus that Muslim scholars who denounce pre-Islamic Arabia view pre-Islamic India also as an area of darkness to which Islam brought illumination for the first time. Though Hindus have been victims of Islamic aggression for several centuries, few of them feel sympathy for victims of the same aggression elsewhere.

v2.c22.s2.5

The pre-Islamic Arabs seem to have no case simply because no one and almost nothing has survived to tell their side of the story. Unlike the Hindus who have survived the onslaught of Islam and can compare what they had with what was brought in by Islam, the pre-Islamic Arabs have passed into what is more or less a total oblivion. The Prophet of Islam and his rightlyguided Caliphs saw to it that no trace was left of the pre-Islamic religion and culture of Arabia, not even in the consciousness of the converts. Franz Babinger writes vis-a-vis the pre-Islamic Sabaean civilization of Arabia: he new creed had the greatest interest in obliterating all recollection of the pagan period, not only in stone monuments which still survived the natural weathering--these were destroyed to provide material for new buildings, or burned for lime or sometimes out of sheer vandalism--but also in literature, and even in consigning the ancient language to oblivion.¹ Whatever could not be wiped out was converted so completely as to look like a contribution of Islam. The Kabba and the Hajj ceremonies provide excellent examples. So does the Arabic language which, although it retains its old sounds and syntax, has been made to convey meanings and concepts which were foreign to it in its pristine state.

v2.c22.s2.6

The greatest blow which pre-Islamic Arabia has suffered is the perversion of its history. An overwhelming majority of the Arabs had never heard of Abraham before Muhammad started mentioning him; those few who had, had no reason to like him in view of the contempt which his people, the Jews settled in Arabia, had continued to pour on the Arabs. Moreover, it was not long before the birth of Muhammad that the king of Yemen who had converted to the creed of Abraham had massacred thousands of Christianised Arabs. Therefore, the Arabs who were extremely tolerant in matters of belief could not but have looked askance at the very name of Abraham.² Yet the Prophet proclaimed that the Arabs were the progeny of Abraham through his elder son, Ismael! He went much farther. He discovered that the foremost Arab temple, the Kabba at Mecca, had been built by Adam, renovated by his son, Seth, and rebuilt by Abraham! He accused the Arabs of having usurped, for polytheistic worship, a place which was originally meant to be a mosque! The theologians and historians who followed, abolished the real forefathers of the Arabs altogether and linked them to lineage of the Jews. Small wonder that every comprehensive history of Arabia written by pious Muslim chroniclers starts with Adam and Eve, and fills its spaces with the progeny of Abraham.³

v2.c22.s2.7

This Islamic version of Arab history would have continued to prevail if modern scholarship had not rescued the true version by means of painstaking research. Our knowledge of the history, writes F. Hommel, we owe partly to inscriptions found in the country, partly in contemporary literatures and monuments of other nations (Babylonians and Assyrians, Egyptians, Hebrews, Greeks and Romans) and partly also (for the centuries immediately preceding Muhammad) to early Islamic tradition As early as the 3rd millennium BC the old Babylonian inscriptions mention a king Manium (also in the fuller form Mannudannu) or Magan of East Arabia; there is much to be said for the view that Magan was only a Sumerian rendering of an Arabic Maan and that from this centre was founded (at a date unknown to us) the South Arabian kingdom of Maan (later vocalisation Main) or the Minaean state which perhaps in the beginning embraced the whole of South Arabia In addition a district named Melukh is mentioned as lying further off, probably covering Central and North West Arabia from which as well as from Magan the Sumerians e.g. Gudea of Sirgulla (about 2350 BC) imported a large quantity of products (wood, stone and metals) for their temples.⁴

v2.c22.s2.8

The same sources tell us about the Sabaeans who flourished in Arabia from 800 BC onwards, till they were swept away by the wave of Muhammadan conquest. They practised an ancient natural religion in which the sun, the moon and the planets figured prominently. They believed in the migration of the soul and in great world periods constantly renewed in an everlasting revolutions, which remind us of the Hindu theories of rebirth and the yugas. They built massive temples and handsome gold and silver statues of their chief gods.⁵ The Greeks and the Romans knew Saba and three other South Arabian kingdoms as the areas which produce frankincense, myrrh, cassia and cinnarnon.⁶ and praised them as brave soldiers, industrious tillers of the soil and traders and skilful sailors, who sent out colonies or at least trading settlements into foreign lands, especially India.⁷ Modern archaeology has exposed sculptures and remains of colonnades, palaces, temples, city walls, towers, public works, especially water-works etc., which confirm the brilliant picture of Sabaean culture.⁸

v2.c22.s2.9

Similar is the story of the Nabataeans who arose in North Arabia or Arabia Petraea about the same time as the Sabaeans in Arabia Flex or South Arabia, and extended their sway upto the frontiers of Hijaz. They were never completely subjected either by the Assyrians, or the Medes, Persians or the Mecedonian kings. It was the Romans who conquered for the first time a part of the Nabataean kingdom in the north in AD 106 and named it *Provincia Arabia*. The Nabataeans too were great traders who attained the position of monopolists in Near Asia.⁹ In their pantheon, which we know mainly from tombs and votive inscriptions the principal God was Dushara (Dhul-Shara), the principal goddess Allat.¹⁰

v2.c22.s2.10

None of the Minaean or Sabaean or Nabataean inscriptions mentions Abraham or Ismael or any term indicative of the Judeo-Christian belief system which Muhammad will impose on the Arabs in the form of Islam. It is only towards the end of the pagan period that a South Arabian inscription dated AD 542-543 mentions for the first time the power and grace and mercy of the Merciful (*RaHmanan*) and his Messiah and the Holy Spirit.¹¹ The inscription was set up by Abraha, the Governor of South Arabia, on behalf of the Christian king of Abyssinia. How Abraha became what he became is an interesting story which explains the repugnance felt by the pagan Arabs for both Judaism and Christianity, as also for the names and terms associated with these creeds.

v2.c22.s2.11

The Monophysite sect of Christianity had found refuge in Najran, a province of South Arabia, after it was expelled by the official Church from the Byzantine territory in the reign of Justinian I (AD 527-565). Some Arabs of Najran had also become converts to Christianity. Around the same time, Dhu Nuwas, king of Yemen which included Najran, had embraced Judaism. He declared war on the Christians of Najran when he found them unwilling to come into the fold of his own creed. Dhu Nuwas, writes Ibn Ishaq, came against them with his armies and invited them to accept Judaism, giving them the choice between that or death: they chose death. So he dug trenches for them; burnt some in fire, slew some with the sword, and mutilated them until he had killed nearly twenty thousand of them.¹²

v2.c22.s2.12

The Christians of Najran appealed for help to the Negus, the Christian king of Abyssinia. An Abyssinian army under Aryat descended on Yemen, defeated and killed Dhu Nuwas, and occupied the land. Under orders from the Negus, a third of the women and children of Yemen were captured, sent to Abyssinia, and sold into slavery.¹³ The Arabs who had embraced Judaism were massacred. In due course, Abraha succeeded Aryat as the Abyssinian Governor of Yemen. He set up the aforementioned Christian inscription. Later on, he swore that he would destroy the Kabba, the foremost temple of the pagan Arabs. He led an army to Mecca in AD 570, the same year in which Muhammad was born. The Kabba, however, escaped unhurt because of a miracle which turned away the Abyssinian horde and which the Arabs credited to Allah, the presiding deity of their pantheon. Meanwhile, the pagan Arabs had had a first hand experience of what Judaism and Christianity stood for.

v2.c22.s2.13

The religious strife which these alien creeds had brought to Arabia was unknown to the pre-Islamic Arabs who, like all pagans, were very liberal in matters of belief and modes of worship. They witnessed how the two exclusive creeds had combined to cause not only large-scale bloodshed but also a foreign invasion, entailing enslavement of Arab women and children and occupation of Arab territory by an alien army. The name of Abraham was associated with both the creeds, as also the word *RaHman*. Naturally, the Arabs could not be expected to be fond of either the name or the word.

v2.c22.s2.14

The historians of Islam mention Abrahas march on Mecca, as also his frustration and retreat in the face of a miracle. But they conceal the fact that the Kabba at that time was a place of pagan worship crowded with numerous idols of Gods and Goddesses. Instead, they lie and credit the miracle to the God of Abraham. That God, however, was nowhere near the Kabba during that period. Allah who presided over the pagan pantheon had not yet been hijacked by Muhammad and converted into the exclusive God of Islam. In fact, it was the pagan character of the Kabba which had invited the attack by a Christian iconoclast. And it was the God of the pagans who had performed the miracle.

v2.c22.s2.15

Character of Pre-Islamic Arabs

v2.c22.s2.16

Modern scholars have not only salvaged pre-Islamic Arab history; they have also pieced together a picture of the pagan Arabs among whom Muhammad was born. For the latter purpose they have had to depend solely on Islamic sources. They have done a creditable job in view of the fact that these sources were deliberately intended to black out or blacken whatever functioned in Arabia before the birth of Islam. They have succeeded in gleaning some good glimpses of people who stood up to Muhammad and challenged his claim of monopoly over truth. The material they have collected is meagre. Yet it does help us meet some men and women of sterling character and heroic bearing. The adversaries of Muhammad score over him and his companions hands down so far as qualities of head and heart are concerned.

v2.c22.s2.17

This is not the occasion to go into greater detail about the shape of pre-Islamic society and culture in Arabia. In the present context, we have to confine ourselves to its pre-Islamic religion which Muhammad destroyed root and branch and replaced with alien prescriptions. So far as Muhammad’s adversaries are concerned, let a professor from Pakistan speak, even though his views are coloured considerably by the historical lore of Islam:

v2.c22.s2.18

Although religion had little influence on the lives of pre-Islamic Arabs,¹⁴ we must not suppose them to be an altogether lawless people. The pagan society of ancient Arabia was built on certain moral ideas, which may be briefly described here. They had no written code, religious or legal, except the compelling force of traditional custom which was enforced by public opinion; but their moral and social ideals have been faithfully preserved in their poetry, which is the only form of literature which has come down to us from those old days.

v2.c22.s2.19

The virtues most highly prized by the ancient Arabs were bravery in battle, patience in misfortune, loyalty to ones fellow tribesmen, generosity to the needy and the poor, hospitality to the guest and the wayfarer, and persistence in revenge. Courage in battle and fortitude in warfare were particularly required in a land where might was generally right and tribes were constantly engaged in attacking one another. It is, therefore, not a mere chance that in the famous anthology of Arabian verse, called the *Hamasah*, poems relating to inter-tribal warfare occupy more than half of the book. These poems applaud the virtues most highly prized by the Arabs-bravery in battle, patience in hardship, defiance of the strong, and persistence in revenge.

v2.c22.s2.20

The tribal organization of the Arabs was then, as now, based on the principle of kinship or common blood, which served as the bond of union and social solidarity. To defend the family and the tribe, individually and collectively, was, therefore, regarded as a sacred duty; and honour required that a man should stand by his people through thick and thin. If kinsmen sought help, it was to be given promptly, without considering the merits of the case. Chivalrous devotion and disinterested self-sacrifice on behalf of their Kinsmen and friends were, therefore, held up as a high ideal of life.¹⁵

v2.c22.s2.21

The king of Persia had said to one of the pre-Islamic Arab princes that the latters people were inferior to every other people. The prince had replied, What nation could be put before the Arabs for strength or beauty or piety, courage, munificence, wisdom, pride, or fidelity? So liberal was he that he would slaughter the camel which was his sole wealth to give a meal to the stranger who came to him at night. No other nation had poetry so elaborate or a language so expressive as theirs. Theirs were the noblest horses, the chastest women, the finest raiment. For their camels no distance was too far, no desert too wild to traverse. So faithful were they to the ordinances of their religion that if a man met his father’s murderer unarmed in one of the sacred months he would not harm him. A sign or look from one of them constituted an engagement which was absolutely inviolable. If other nations obeyed a central government and a single ruler, the Arabs required no such institution, each of them being fit to be a king, and well able to protect himself, and unwilling to undergo the humiliation of paying tribute or hearing rebuke.¹⁶ One is reminded of the republican clans in north Uttar Pradesh and Bihar among whom the Buddha was born, as also of those in Punjab and Sindh who robbed Alexander of his reputation of invincibility when they blunted his sword and turned him back. The Arabs who got regimented as Muhammad's *mujahids* (holy warriors) lost this sense of honour and love of freedom. Treachery towards whomsoever the Prophet chose as his enemy, became their stock-in-trade. On the other hand, a mere frown from the Prophet made them cringe and crawl.

v2.c22.s2.22

If a society and culture is to be judged by the status of its women, the pre-Islamic Arabs come out with flying colours. The very fact that they had many Goddesses in their pantheon, made them give a place of pride to their women. Institutions of paganism, observes Margoliouth, were not unfavourable to the prominence of those women who had the requisite gifts of courage or insight. And the ensuing narrative will show examples of women acting with originality and resolution, when there was room for the display of these qualities.¹⁷ Muhammad's first wife, Khadijah, provides an excellent example of the independence which women enjoyed, and the enterprise they could display in the pre-Islamic Arab society. She was not only a wealthy merchant who managed her own business; she was also in a position to turn down proposals from powerful suitors and marry the man of her own choice. Hind, the wife of Muhammad's chief adversary, Abu Sufyan, was herself a firebrand who opposed Muhammad, tooth and nail. She followed her husband to the battlefield and sustained his morale in peace. When Abu Sufyan surrendered Mecca to Muhammad without a fight, she caught hold of him in the market-place and cried, Kill this fat greasy bladder of lard! What a rotten protector of the people!¹⁸ She was at her best when circumstances forced her to embrace Islam. The Prophet who baptised her asked her not to commit adultery. Does a free woman commit adultery, O apostle of God? she asked. Next, the Prophet advised her not to kill your children. She said, I brought them up when they were little and you killed them on the day of Badr when they were grown up, so you are the one to know about them.¹⁹ It was Islam which robbed women of their high station in society and put them behind the veil or buried them in the harem. Ever since, the language of Islam has bracketed women (*zan*) with personal property (*zar* and *zamin*) of the male. Chapters on marriage (*nikah*) and divorce (*talaq*) in orthodox collections of *Hadis*, and other standard works such as the *Hidaya* and the *Fatwa-i-Alamgiri*, tell the true story of what Islam has done to women.

v2.c22.s2.23

But the one great virtue for which the pre-Islamic Arabs put the Prophet and his companions to shame, was their catholicity in matters of religious belief and practice. The respect they showed towards other peoples persuasions was fully in keeping with their pagan spiritual tradition. Ibn Ishaq testifies, When the apostle openly displayed Islam as God ordered him, his people did not withdraw or turn against him, so far as I have heard, until he spoke disparagingly of their gods.²⁰ The Meccans made a very reasonable offer when Abu Talib, Muhammad's uncle and protector, was on his death-bed. You know, they said, the trouble that exists between us and your nephew, so call him and let us make an agreement that he will leave us alone and we will leave him alone; let him have his religion and we will have ours. It was Muhammad who remained adamant. You must say, he demanded, There is no God but Allah and you must repudiate what you worship beside him.²¹ It cannot be held against the Meccans that they refused to be bullied. Abu Talib himself stands out as an embodiment of the pagan virtue in this respect. He protected Muhammad to the end, without himself agreeing to renounce the religion of his forefathers. His only fault-and that has been the fault of all pagans-was his failure to understand that what his nephew was selling was not religion but something else.

v2.c22.s2.24

It is, therefore, nothing short of slanderous to say that the pre-Islamic Arabs were barbarians devoid of religion and culture, unless we mean by religion and culture what the Muslim theologians mean. They were nothing of the sort. The fact that they failed to understand the ways of Muhammad and could not match his mailed fist in the final round, should not be held against them. It was neither for the first nor the last time that a democratic society succumbed in the face of determined gangsterism. We know how Lenin, Hitler and Mao Tse-tung succeeded in our own times. Nor should the image of what the Arabs became after they were forced into the fold of Islam be confused with what they were before. The crimes committed by the Islmaized Arabs should not be blamed on the pagan Arabs. For it was Islam which brutalized the Arabs and turned them into bloodthirsty bandits who spread fire and sword, far and wide. In the majority of mankind, the baser drives of human nature are never far from the threshold. Islam brought them to the fore in case of the majority of Arabs.

v2.c22.s2.25

¹ *First Encyclopaedia of Islam 1913-1936*, Leiden, 1987, Vol. VII, P. 15.

v2.c22.s2.26

² See D.S. Margoliouth, *Mohammed and the Rise of Islam*, London, 1905, New Delhi Reprint. 1985, p. 73, To the Meccans, he says, he [Abraham] was not even a name.

v2.c22.s2.27

³ Converts to Islam in every other land follow the pattern. They disown their real forefathers and link themselves to this or that tribe of Jews or Arabs. Muslims of Afghanistan and Kashmir for instance regard themselves as descended from some lost tribes of Israel. Muslims of Bangladesh have produced learned treatises tracing their descent to Islamized invaders. But for the labours of Firdawsi, the Muslims of Iran would not have known that their infidel forefathers were great and glorious.

v2.c22.s2.28

⁴ *First Encyclopaedia of Islam*, op. cit., Vol. I, p. 377.

v2.c22.s2.29

⁵ *The Encyclopaedia Americana*, New York, 1952, Vol. XXIV, p. 77.

v2.c22.s2.30

⁶ *First Encyclopaedia of Islam*, op. cit., Vol. VII, p. 5.

v2.c22.s2.31

⁷ Ibid, p. 7.

v2.c22.s2.32

⁸ Ibid, p. 17.

v2.c22.s2.33

⁹ Ibid, Vol. VI, p. 801.

v2.c22.s2.34

¹⁰ Ibid, p. 802.

v2.c22.s2.35

¹¹ Ibid, Vol. I, p. 377.

v2.c22.s2.36

¹² Ibn Ishaq, *Sirat Rasul Allah*, translated into English by A. Gillaumne, OUP, Karachi, Seventh Impression, p. 17. Ibn Ishaq (d. AD 767) was the first biographer of Muhammad.

v2.c22.s2.37

¹³ Ibid, p 19.

v2.c22.s2.38

Footnotes:

v2.c22.s2.39

¹⁴ This statement has no basis, as we shall see. The pagan Arabs fought Muhammad in defence of a religion which they cherished. They had no other reason to quarrel with the Prophet.

v2.c22.s2.40

¹⁵ Shaikh Inayatullah, former Professor of Arabic in the University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pre-Islamic Arabian Thought, an article in *A History of Muslim Philosophy*, edited by M.M. Sharif, Lahore, 1961, Vol. I, pp. 133-34. The legend of Hatim Tayy, poet and knight, is still popular among Muslims. He represents the ideal type of the Pre-Muhammadan Arab because he displayed in a high degree the virtues of *Muruwa*. particularly hospitality and liberality in the practice of which he paid no regard to his own needs. His generosity has become proverbial (*First Encyclopaedia of Islam*, op. cit., Vol. III, p. 290.

v2.c22.s2.41

¹⁶ D.S. Margoliouth, op. cit, pp. 2-3.

v2.c22.s2.42

¹⁷ Ibid,p. 30.

v2.c22.s2.43

¹⁸ Ibn Ishaq, op. cit., p. 548.

v2.c22.s2.44

¹⁹ Ibid,p. 533. It is a despicable lie that the pre-Islamic Arabs killed their children. Muhammad asked the Arabs not to commit this crime simply because the Jewish prophets had spoken against it, and not because he saw the Arabs committing it. Hind gave a fitting reply.

v2.c22.s2.45

²⁰ Ibid,op. cit., p. 118. Muslim apologists may say that abusing other peoples Gods not intolerance because that is what Islam means. But that is a different proposition.

v2.c22.s2.46

²¹ Ibid,p. 191-92.

Chapter Eleven: Religion of Pagan Arabia

v2.c22.s3.2

The Islamic sources do tell us that the pre-Islamic Arabs were *mushriks* (polytheists) addicted to worshipping numerous idols. But they do not inform us as to what those idols symbolized. The Quran (2.257, 259; 4.52; 53.19; 71.21) mentions some idols but only to denounce them. We reproduce below what Ibn Ishaq writes about them:

v2.c22.s3.3

They say that the beginning of stone worship among the sons of Ishmael was when Mecca became too small for them and they wanted more room in the country. Everyone who left the town took with him a stone from the sacred area to do honour to it. Wherever they settled they set it up and walked round it as they went round the Kabba. This led them to worship what stones they pleased and those which made an impression on them. Thus as generations passed they forgot their primitive faith and adopted another religion for that of Abraham and Ishmael. They worshipped idols and adopted the same errors as the peoples before them. Yet they retained and held fast practices going back to the time of Abraham, such as honouring the temple and going round it, the great and little pilgrimage, and the standing on Arafa and Muzdalifa, sacrificing the victims, and the pilgrim cry at the great and little pilgrimage, while introducing elements which had no place in the religion of Abraham. Thus, Kinana and Quraysh used the pilgrim cry: At Thy service, O God, at Thy service! At Thy service, Thou without an associate but the, associate Thou hast. Thou ownest him and what he owns. They used to acknowledge his unity in their cry and then include their idols with God, putting the ownership of them in His hand.¹

v2.c22.s3.4

The people of Noah had images to which they were devoted. God told His apostle about them when He said: And they said, Forsake not your gods; forsake not Wudd and Suwa and Yaghuth and Yasuq and Nasr. And they had led many astray.

v2.c22.s3.5

Among those who had chosen those idols and used their names as compounds when they forsook the religion of Ishmael-both Ishmaelites and others-was Hudhayl b. Mudrika b. Ilyas b. MuDar. They adopted Suwa and they had him in RuhaT; and Kalb b. Wabra of QuDaa who adopted Wudd in Dumatul-Jandal

v2.c22.s3.6

Anum of Tayyi and the people of Jurash of MadhHij adopted Yaghuth in Jurash.

v2.c22.s3.7

Khaywan, a clan of Hamdan, adopted Yasuq in the land of Hamdan in the Yaman.

v2.c22.s3.8

Dhul-Kala of Himyar adopted Nasr in the Himyar country.

v2.c22.s3.9

Khaulan had an idol called Ammanas in the Khaulan country.²

v2.c22.s3.10

The B. Milkan b. Kinana b. Khuzayma b. Mudrika b. Ilyas b. MuDar had an image called Saed, a lofty rock in a desert plain in their country.

v2.c22.s3.11

Daus had an idol belonging to Amr b. Humama al-Dausi.

v2.c22.s3.12

Quraysh had an idol by a well in the middle of the Kaba called Hubal. And they adopted Isaf (or Asaf) and Naila by the place of Zamzam, sacrificing beside them.³

v2.c22.s3.13

Every household had an idol in their house which they used to worship. When a man was about to set out on a journey he would rub himself against it as he was about to ride off: indeed that was the last thing he used to do before his journey; and when he returned from his journey the first thing he did was to rub himself against it before he went in to his family.

v2.c22.s3.14

Now along with the Kabba the Arabs had adopted Tawaghit, which were temples which they venerated as they venerated the Kabba. They had their guardians and overseers and they used to make offerings to them as they did to the Kabba and to circumambulate them and sacrifice at them. Yet they recognized the superiority of the Kabba because it was the temple and mosque of Abraham the friend (of God).

First 106 of 815 passages. Read on

Cites (10)