Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Purva-Mimamsa in its Sources c30.4

Pūrva-Mīmāṃsā in its Sources c30.4

Language
English

c30.4

Before expounding these, one important difference of opinion on this subject has to be noted. The *Bhaṭṭa* and the *Prābhākara* hold entirely different opinions regarding the question as to whether or not this *Order of Sequence* comes within the purview of Injunction proper. According to the *Bhaṭṭa*, Order does form an object of the Injunction (See *Nyāyamālāvistara* on 5.1.1.); while according to the *Prābhākara* it cannot do so. (*Bṛhatī*, Ms. 100-100B; *Ṛjuvimalā* Ms. P. 497 et. seq. and *Prakaraṇapañchikā* P. 220). The reasoning of these latter may be thus summed up: In the case of all Injunctive texts, apart from the enjoined Act itself, we should be justified in admitting that alone as the further object of Injunction without which the enjoining of the Act itself would remain incomplete;—as a matter of fact, the *Order* of performance does not come under this category; because whether we perform the Act at one time or the other, it is performed all the same, and the purpose of the Injunction is fulfilled. Thus then, *Order* not being an integral factor in the Act, it cannot, as a rule, be an object of Injunction by the word that enjoins the act itself. In some cases however it is the *Order* itself that is enjoined by the Injunctive Text; for instance, the drinking or the eating of the Sacrificial Remnant having been enjoined by one Injunctive text, there is another Injunctive text enjoining the *Order* in which that Drinking and Eating is to be done; this text being the one that lays down that ‘the Priest who pronounces the syllable *Vaṣaṭ* is to do the Eating, *first of all*’. Such instances however are rare; as a rule, the Injunctive Text says nothing as to the *Order* even when it does in certain cases, it does so not by means of the Injunctive Word, but by some other Word.

Cites (1)