Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Buddhist Philosophy in India and Ceylon c16.s1.6

Buddhist Philosophy in India and Ceylon c16.s1.6

Language
English

c16.s1.6

The distrust of the value of these lucubrations is increased when we come to the elaboration of a distinction between Rūpa, material form or matter,² which is underived (*no upādā*) and which is derived (*upādā*). The topic gives us as underived Rūpa the sphere of the tangible, that is those elements which are appreciated by touch, namely the earthy or solid, the lambent or fiery, and the gaseous or aerial elements or Mahābhūta, ‘great beings’ in the traditional phraseology, and the fluid or moist elements. This simply denotes as ultimate realities, grasped save water by the sense of touch, these four elements, and is clearly simple and natural. But the dependent Rūpa includes (1) the senses, vision, hearing, smell, taste, body sensibility (replacing the skin of the Upaniṣads as regards touch); (2) sights, sounds, odours, tastes, but not the object of touch; (3) the faculties of femininity, masculinity, and vitality;¹ (4) intimation by act and by speech; (5) the element of space; (6) buoyancy, plasticity, wieldiness, three qualities of matter, and integration, maintenance, decay, impermanence,—four phases in the coming into and going out of being of matter; and (7) bodily nutriment. The simple explanation of the classification is that these various classes have all something to with matter, and in that sense are matter qua derived. The senses themselves are subtle matter, and invisible; their objects are immediately bound up with matter; the faculties bound up with life are an aspect of matter as it appears in the matter aggregate of the individual, and intimation by act and speech are introduced into the classification on the same ground of connexion with the material side of the empiric self, while bodily nutriment is explained in the same way. The inclusion of space² is interesting, and a novelty; it appears in the Canon as if it were a fifth element, and, of course, it would be absurd to imagine that it appears as derivate matter, because it was a pure form of intuition or a mental construction. But the difficulty disappears when we consider that the element of space like the following seven items is intimately connected with matter. Space is necessary for the movement of matter, and can just as well be placed under derivate matter as can the qualities of matter and the four stages of its coming into being, state of being, decay, and impermanence, which it may be noted agree with the Sautrāntika doctrine of the four, not three stages, in being.