Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c14: Chap. 9: Could Bābar Not Have Replaced the Rāma Temple by the Mosque?

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c14

Language
English

Chap. 9: Could Bābar Not Have Replaced the Rāma Temple by the Mosque?

c14.1

The following three positions have come to the fore in regard to the demolition and/or construction of the Rāma temple and the Bābarī mosque respectively:
1. That Bābar was responsible for both the demolition and the construction.
2. That he was responsible for neither, apart from restoration of the mosque which was already in existence.
3. That it was built out of nothing by Mīr Bāqī on or without Bābar's orders.

c14.2

That ours is the first position, is self-evident. The second position is held by Dr. R. Nath and certain others and the third, by the so-called '*secular*' scholars and Muslim leaders. We have so far been seized of the first and third alternatives, and it is time we take up the second alternative.

c14.3

This second alternative is a broad spectrum of varying opinions. According to some, Bābar never visited Ayodhya, whence he could not have replaced the temple with the mosque or even built the mosque on a desolate site. According to some others, the inscriptions on the mosque do not mention the fact of the replacement, whence Bābar cannot be held responsible for the temple-demolition, if the demolition is a fact at all. According to still others, Mīr Bāqī himself built the mosque and yet remembers Bābar by way of expression of loyalty only. According to the '*secular*' scholars and Muslim leaders in general, Bābar was too tolerant to think of destroying a temple. And, finally, according to Dr. Nath, the so-called Bābarī mosques at Ayodhya, Sambhal, and Panipat were assignable to the Lodī period, on the basis of their architectural and art-historical features, Bābar appearing to him to be responsible for only their restoration or renovationn.

c14.4

We have disposed of the first three variations of the second alternative directly or indirectly. Here we are called upon to examine the last two theses. Let us first take up Dr. Nath's thesis.

c14.5

Dr. Nath's finding is that Ramkot 'was devastated either by the armies of Mahmūd of Ghaznin or the Delhi Sultans who captured the palace and established here their provincial seat. It is quite probable, and possible too, that a mosque was first raised during the Sultanate period (1001-30; 1192-1526) on the site of the most important temple associated with the life of Rāma, and Mīr Bāqī just restored that mosque during his occupation of Ayodhya.'¹ Dr. Nath adds : 'His hectic military activity in the region could not have allowed him enough time to build a mosque anew, least to demolish a temple and raise a mosque in its place. He could not venture to outrage the religious susceptibilities of the Hindus of the region by embarking upon such an iconoclastic programme, which he had none, while restoration of a dilapidated or ruined mosque could have certainly assuaged and placated the feelings of the Muslim inhabitants whose goodwill and help too the Mughuls needed against the Afghan rebels as compulsively as those of the Hindus.'² Again, according to Dr. Nath, an idea of his style and taste can be had from the gardens (*bāgh-s*) he founded at Kabul, Agra, and Dholpur, and above all from the Jal-Mahal at Fatehpur Sikri, which is most typical of his style.³ And the style is conspicuous by its absence in the Ayodhya temple.

c14.6

¹ R. Nath, p.38

c14.7

² *Loc. cit.*

c14.8

³ *Ibid.*, pp. 19-20

c14.9

But the architectural style of the disputed structure displaying Lodī/Afghān traits does not warrant the assertion that it came into being in the Lodī/Afghān period. The just four-year long Bābar regime marks what may be called a period of transition, wherein continuance of earlier architectural forms is quite within the realms of possibility. Dr. Nath's restoration theory, too, does not appear to be impeccable. His contention is that the disputed mosque was not built anew but was only restored, by Mīr Bāqī on Bābar's orders. Restored from What? Dr. Nath replies, from ruins and dilapidation. He does not visualize the alternative that the mosque might have been restored, if restored it was, from the hands of the Hindus who had regained control of the structure from the Afghāns. We have seen that William Finch does not mention the mosque or the Muslims using it or inhabiting the mound. What he purports to say, on the other hand, is that only *Paṇḍā*-s are found in the ruins of Ramkot. It is quite possible that the disputed mosque was under the control of the Hindus and in a dilapidated condition. That is perhaps why even Abu 'l-Faḍl does not take notice of it.

c14.10

It is true that Ramkot was devastated under the Sultanate, but the tyrants do not appear to have succeeded in rensacking the Rāma temple complex entire. How tough the fight put up by the Hindus against the Muslim onslaughts in Awadh might have been is well attested to by the example of Baratūh (Bharathū/ Bharatū?), who is reported to have put to the sword one lakh twenty thousand Muslims, though he was vanquished in 623 A.H./1226 A.D. by Prince Malik Nāṣiru 'd-Dīn Maḥmūd, governor of Awadh.¹

c14.11

¹ Minhāj Sirāj, *Ṭabaqāt-i Nāṣirī*, p.181

c14.12

As a matter of fact, there is not the faintest tradition of the destruction of the Rāma temple by some pre-Bābar ruler, although there is of the post-Bābar Auraṅgzīb. Besides, none of the inscriptions of the mosque speak of restoration of the mosque by Bābar or by Mīr Bāqī, and at least one of the inscriptions is *in situ*. Even read together, the three inscriptions of the mosque leave no doubt that the mosque was built by Mīr Bāqī on Bābar's orders or at any rate during his regime. It is true that they make no mention of the temple-demolition but, then, same is the case with the Sambhal mosque, which is admitted on all hands to have displaced a temple, as also with other Bābarī mosques as shown earlier.

c14.13

Indeed, architectural-stylistic considerations must not be allowed to outweigh all other considerations taken together. Tradition and records of all kinds are unanimous in holding Bābar responsible for replacement of the Rāma temple with the Bābarī mosque. In this connexion, instead of Bābar's, Aurangzīb's name does figure sometimes, but it is not so serious an aberration or half-truth. Aurangzīb ransacked the temples of Ayodhya in his own day and, who knows, he might have had a hand, after Bābar, in tampering with the Rāma temple in his own turn. We have seen that part of the temple complex had survived Bābar/Mīr Bāqī's vandalism in some form somehow or other.

Cites (2)