Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c14.9

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c14.9

Language
English

c14.9

But the architectural style of the disputed structure displaying Lodī/Afghān traits does not warrant the assertion that it came into being in the Lodī/Afghān period. The just four-year long Bābar regime marks what may be called a period of transition, wherein continuance of earlier architectural forms is quite within the realms of possibility. Dr. Nath's restoration theory, too, does not appear to be impeccable. His contention is that the disputed mosque was not built anew but was only restored, by Mīr Bāqī on Bābar's orders. Restored from What? Dr. Nath replies, from ruins and dilapidation. He does not visualize the alternative that the mosque might have been restored, if restored it was, from the hands of the Hindus who had regained control of the structure from the Afghāns. We have seen that William Finch does not mention the mosque or the Muslims using it or inhabiting the mound. What he purports to say, on the other hand, is that only *Paṇḍā*-s are found in the ruins of Ramkot. It is quite possible that the disputed mosque was under the control of the Hindus and in a dilapidated condition. That is perhaps why even Abu 'l-Faḍl does not take notice of it.