Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c17.18

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c17.18

Language
English

c17.18

Of late, certain 'secular' historians have brought out compilations on the Rāma Janmabhūmi-Bābarī Mosque issue, such as the following:
1. *Babari Masjid Ram Janmabhoomi Controversy*, ed. Asghar Ali Engineer, Delhi, 1990
2. *Anatomy of a Confrontation : The Babari Masjid - Ram Janmabhumi Issue*, S. Gopal, Viking, 1991
3. Sushil Srivastava, *The Disputed Mosque: A Historical Inquiry*, New Delhi, 1991
4. R.S. Sharma, *Communal History and Rama's Ayodhya*, New Delhi, 1990. Their incredibly partisan approach has come under fire at the hands of responsible scholars thus: 'A.N. Engineer's book...is merely a collection of newspaper columns on the subject, or rather a selection, for the above mentioned pertinent critiques by dr. Harsh Narain, A.K. Chatterjee and prof. A.R. Khan.. as well as the relevant articles by Arun Shourie, Ram Swarup, Sita Ram Goel and Jay Dubashi, have been carefully omitted... The only two pro-Hindu articles which he has deigned to include, both published in the RSS paper *Organiser*, were selected for their containing a few weak arguments and poor comparisons, which he then takes on in his introduction.'¹ Further, 'Two weeks after Harsh Narain's article had been published and had disproven the "Janmabhoomi myth" concoction thesis, the *Illustrated Weekly* decided to publish the already well publicized JNU statement once more. Even after A.R. Khan's reply had exploded the objective and scientific pretence of the JNU historians, the whole secularist crowd kept on quoting the "eminent historians". More than half a year later, the leftist paper *Mainstream* still quotes them as "several eminent historians whose professional honesty nobody questions".¹ Again, 'In his *Anatomy of a Confrontation*, the JNU historians do not even mention the powerful argumentation by prof. A.R. Khan, while prof. Harsh Narain and Mr. A.K. Chatterjee's presentation of authentic testimonies...are only mentioned but not detailed and discussed, let alone refuted; but clumsy RSS pamphlets and improvised statements by BJP orators are quoted and analyzed at length.'² Further on, 'a number of the documents, facts and insights presented by people like prof. A.R. Khan, prof. Harsh Narain and Mr. A.K. Chatterjee, have been ignored in nicely published books by prestigious authors like the JNU historians, prof. R.S. Sharma and Mr. A.A. Engineer.'³