The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c17.7
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c17.7
- Language
- English
c17.7
Critics will do well to remember that demolition of the Rāma temple has never been doubted save in our own time. It is true that Bābar, Mīr Bāqī, and Tulasīdāsa mention neither the temple nor its demolition, but, had they mentioned the same, critics like Prof. ‘Irfān Ḥabīb would have dubbed them liars displaying Muslim communal bravado ! Again, if non-mention of the Rāma temple demolition by Mīr Bāqī be proof positive of its non-demolition or absolute non-existence, non-mention of the Bābarī mosque by Abu ‘l-Faḍl and William Finch would amount to proof of its disappearance after Mīr Bāqī. In fact, mere non-mention is not enough. The evidential value of the first non-mention is nullified by other evidence of the temple demolition, while the second non-mention’s evidential value is enhanced by the fact that there is no evidence of its continuance as a mosque till as late as 1707, as we have seen already. Indeed, non-mention unsupported by other circumstances is seldom a safe anchorage for such conclusions.