The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c18: Chap. 13: Verdict of the Sharī'ah
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c18
- Language
- English
Chap. 13: Verdict of the Sharī'ah
c18.1
What could be the verdict of the *Sharī‘ah* on the vexed question of the replacement of the Rāma temple with the mosque in question by Bābar? The following issues arise in this behalf:
c18.2
1. Can a mosque be raised on a usurped (*maghṣūb*) site?
2. If there does exist such a mosque, can prayer (*ṣalāt/namāz*) be offered therein?
3. If one does offer prayer in such a mosque, will one earn merit?
4. Can such a mosque be allowed to stand?
5. Is land conquered in *Jihād* land usurped?
6. Did Bābar conquer India in general and Ayodhya in particular in *Jihād* ?
7. Does the *Sharī‘ah* permit or envisage forcible replacement of an idol-temple with a mosque, such as in the case before us?
8. If not, should the mosque be allowed to stand?
9. Does the *Sharī‘ah* permit or envisage destruction, relocation, or restoration to the Hindus of the mosque or the mosque-site?
c18.3
Reply to the first three issues is clearly in the negative.¹ No clear verdict has come to our notice on issue No.4. Mawlānā Ashraf ‘Alī Thānawī would be inclined to think that such mosque may be kept safe and closed.² But, as will transpire as we proceed, getting rid of such a mosque alone will meet the ends of Islamic justice.
c18.4
¹ *Fatāwā-i ‘Ālamgīrī*, Urdu tr., Vol. IX, p.26
c18.5
² Mawlānā Ashraf ‘Alī Thānawī, *Da‘bu ’l-Masājid fī Ādab-i ’l-Masājid*, quoted in Mawlānā Muḥammad Zafīru ‘d-Dīn, *Islām kā Niẓām-i Masājid*, p.165
c18.6
So far as issue No.5 is concerned, there can be no two opinions about it: land conquered in Jihād is by no means land usurped. The Qur’ān declares that ‘the earth belongs to Allāh. He causes it to be inherited by whom of his servants He will.’¹ The Prophet declares that all land belongs to Allāh or to the Prohpet himself,² and, let us add, through him to the Ummah (Muslim community), which the Qur’ān adjudges to be the best community (*khayr ummah*), one raised up to guide and govern humanity³ as vicegerents (*khulafā’*) of Allāh on earth.⁴ Listen, in Iqbāl’s words, to what Ṭāriq bin Ziyād told his soldiers who felt homesick on the shores of Spain they had reached in a bid to conquer the land:
c18.7
¹ Q., Al-A ’rāf (7) 128
c18.8
² Bukhārī, II, Kitābu ’l-Jihād wa ’s-Siyar, Ḥadīth 406
c18.9
³ Q., Āl-‘Imrān (3) 110
c18.10
⁴ Q., An-Nūr (24) 55; an-Naml (27) 62; Al-Faṭir (35) 39
c18.11
*Har mulk mulk-i mā ’st ki mulk-i Khudā-i mā ’st*
c18.12
Tr.: ‘All land belongs to us, because it belongs to our God.’ This serves to vouchsafe to the Ummah the moral right to appropriate others’ land in Jihād. Indeed, as Ibn Taymiyyah, the fourteenth-century jurist-theologian, would have it, Jihād serves simply to restore lands to the Muslims, who enjoy a kind of divine right over these. Thus, Jihādically extorted land is far from tantamount to usurped land.
c18.13
Now, reply to issue No.6 has to be in the negative. Being ruled by Ibrāhīm Lodī, Indian empire was already a *Dāru ’l-Islām*. By vanquishing and killing him on the battlefield and thereby stepping into his shoes, Bābar found India a *Dāru ’l-Islām*, he did not make it so. Bābar captured Ayodhya, too, not from the Hindus but from the Afghāns. Hence, Bābar’s conquest of the Lodī empire and Afghāns’ Ayodhya cannot be said to be Jihādic.
c18.14
Reply to issue No. 7 is conditional: In Jihād (process of elimination of infidels and infidelity), yes; otherwise, *not*. The Qur’ān is all for uprooting infidelity, and idol-temples are the most conspicuous symbols or rather manifestations thereof. In fact, the Qur'ān counts idol-worship (*shirk*) as the deadliest of sins (*ithm 'azīm*), which Allāh never can pardon.¹ The Prophet himself, under inspiration from on high, turned the Ka'bah into a mosque by cleansing it of all the 360 idols housed and worshipped in it.
c18.15
¹ Q., An-Nisā (4) 48, 116
c18.16
Otherwise, the *Sharī'ah* would not permit temple-destruction, much less replacement of a temple with a mosque. As hinted above, it divides the world into *Dāru 'l-Islām* (Islam-ruled domain) and *Dāru 'l-Ḥarb* (infidel-ruled domain). Usually, *Jihād* is permissible in the second domain only. Infidels inhabiting the first domain are called *Dhimī-s* (literally, 'protected' infidels), namely such infidels as earn the right to subsist and follow their religion privately in lieu of payment of *Jizyah* and allied taxes, with attendant indignities, as subjects (not citizens) of the Muslim state.² The *Dhimmī-s'* life, property, and places of worship are duly protected, though they may not be permitted to build new ones.³ According to the *Sharī'ah*, therefore, it was incumbent upon Bābar to protect the Rāma temple rather then tamper with it, such less to erect a mosque on its site, by force of arms. He was, for the same reason, a usurper and his mosque an unauthorized and illegitimate one.
c18.17
² Harsh Narain, *Jizyah and the Spread of Islam*, chapter II, passim
c18.18
³ *Loc. cit.*
c18.19
But, by the same token, was the Prophet not a usurper of the Ka'bah? The Ka'bah had been the chief idol temple of the Meccan infidels for ages. They had surrendered to the Prophet without a real fight: only a handful of extremists tried in vain to put up something like a fight.⁴ The Prophet took possession of the Ka'bah and did away with all the 360 idols worshipped in it, thereby turning it into a mosque. True, but the verse of *Jizyah*,⁵ out of which the concept of *Dhimmī*-hood and all that it implies has been derived, had not been revealed till then: Mecca was conquered by the Prophet in 8 A.H. and the verse in question was revealed in 9 A.H. Besides, the conquest of Ka'bah may well be treated as part of the conquest of Mecca, thanks to the indeterminate nature of the latter.
c18.20
⁴ Ibn Hishām, II, p.483
c18.21
⁵ Q., At-Tawbah (9) 29
c18.22
Now issue No. 8 : Should the Bābarī mosque be allowed to keep standing? The Qur'ān is there to give us guidance in the matter. Let us see what light it has to shed on the ticklish issue.
c18.23
The Qur'ān, the traditions, and the Prophet's biographies refer to a mosque built by a section of his followers at Qubā' near Medinah, who petitioned the Prophet to inaugurate it by offering prayer therein. The Prophet consented to do so on return from the impending battle of Tabūk. Meanwhile he was given to understand that the builders of the mosque were traitors out to sow the seeds of dissension among his followers. So, he set fire to and destroyed the mosque. According to Ibn Hishām,¹ the earliest or rather foremost biographer of the Prophet, the Prophet thereafter received a revelation from Allāh² to the effect that prayer must not be offered in a mosque built from an impious motive, in a mosque of evil/harm/ misfortune (masjidan ḍirāran), for it will topple with its builders into the fire of hell and that only a mosque founded on piety (taqwā) ought to be used for the purpose.³
c18.24
¹ Ibn Hishām, II, pp.635-636
c18.25
² Q., At-Tawbah (9) 107-110
c18.26
³ Ibn Hishām, II, pp. 635-636
c18.27
It is noteworthy that there was nothing wrong with that mosque *per se* – with its structure, with its site. Even then it had to come to grief at the hands of the Prophet himself. Should the Bābrī mosque built by usurping the *Dhimmi-s'* temple fare any better? This pious precedent set by the Qur'ān should settle the matter once for all. Hence, answer to issue No. 8 is bound to be in the negative.
c18.28
It is further noteworthy that the destruction of the *Masjidu 'ḍ-Ḍirār*, as the mosque in the above illustration has come to be known, is not known to have been followed by construction of another mosque on its site, which means that the much-publicised eternally inviolable sacrosanctity of the mosque-site *per se* even when it falls vacant has no *Sharī‘ah* legs to stand upon.
c18.29
Well, there are other precedents, too, to go upon. The Umayyād caliph ‘Umar bin ‘Abdu ’l-‘Azīz got a church restored to the Christians out of the hands of the Muslims of Banū Naṣr.¹ He created a more glaring precedent in another case. When Mu‘āwiyyah bin Abū Sufyān became caliph, he intended to include the church of John in the mosque of Damascus; but the Christians did not agree. Caliph ‘Abdu ’l-Malik bin Marwān in his own turn offered a lot of wealth for the church, but the Christians would not agree again. Finding them adamant, caliph al-Walīd bin ‘Abdu ’l-Malik threatened them with dismantling the church by force. He was also provoked by a Christian’s remark that the caliph’s attempt to dismantle it would turn him mad and involve him in trouble. Then the caliph damaged part of the church himself and got it dismantled by engaging labour. He also extended the mosque enough to cover its site in toto. When ‘Umar bin ‘Abdu ’l-‘Azīz succeeded them, the Christians petitioned him and he ordered restoration of the church-site to them. Upon this, the great theologian Sulaymān bin Ḥabību ’l-Muḥāribiyy persuaded the Christians to forgo their demand and, in lieu thereof, get back all the churches of Al-Ghūṭ conquered in a holy war (*‘anwatan*). The caliph approved of the compromise formula and action was taken accordingly.²
c18.30
¹ Al-Balādhurī, *Futūḥu ’l-Buldān*, p. 189
c18.31
² *Ibid.*, pp. 190-191.
c18.32
Yet another precedent: During the caliphate of Mahdī, ‘Alī bin Sulaymān, governor of Egypt, dismantled a number of churches including one of Mary. But, during the caliphate of Hārunu ’r-Rashīd, the new governor Mūsā bin ‘Īsā ‘Abdāsī restored them all.³ In fact, the great Arab historian Maqrīzī tells the tale of several other such churches.
c18.33
³ Maqrīzī, *Khiṭaṭ*, Vol. IV, p. 424
c18.34
The upshot of all this is that our answer to issue No. 8 must be negative. This also indicates the answer to issue No.9, the last issue. That is, destruction, relocation, and restoration to the Hindus of the Bābarī mosque would be quite in keeping with the letter and spirit of the Sharīʻah.
c18.35
As a matter of fact, demolition of Muslim shrines or their reconstruction even on new foundations is not unknown to and unrecognized by official Islam. It is said, for example, that the Kaʻbah itself, of which the Prophet holds other mosques to be daughters (*banāt*), was dismantled more than once and even in disregard of its original foundations. Five years before the anointment of Muḥammad as prophet, the Quraysh rebuilt the Kaʻbah of wood on new foundations and the Prophet participated therein. The new building was demolished by caliph ʻAbdullāh bin Zubayr in 63-64 A.H. and reconstructed on its old foundations. The newer building, too, underwent demolition at the behest of caliph ʻAbdu ʼl-Malik bin Marwān and restored to the foundations laid by the Quraysh.¹ In fact, reports Bakhārī, the Prophet had a mind to rebuild it on its original foundations but had to desist from it for fear of being misunderstood.²
c18.36
¹ Mawlānā Muḥammad ʻAbdu ʼr-Rashīd Nuʻmānī, *Lughātu ʼl-Qurʼān*, Vol. V, p.155
c18.37
² Bukhāhrī, I, Kitābu ʼl-Manāsik Hadīths 1484-1485
c18.38
Here we cannot resist the temptation of alluding to two Indian examples of restoration to the Hindus of temples turned into mosque. Firishtah reports that Akbar ordered replacement of the mosque at the Asir fort with a temple (presumably because the mosque had earlier displaced a temple); although his son prince Dāniyāl did not carry out the order.³ Another, rather more relevant example is that of the otherwise fanatic Shāh Jahān. It is on record (*Akhbārāt*, 9th year, sheets 49 ff.) that as governor of Gujarat Aurangzīb converted the Jaina temple of Cintāmaṇi Pārśvanātha, built by the Jaina business magnate Shāntidās Jauharī at Saraspur off Ahmedabad, into a mosque, named it Masjid-i Quwwatu ʼl-Islām,⁴ and got a cow slaughtered therein.⁵ But, on complaint by Mullā ‘Abdu’l-Ḥakimi,¹ Shāh Jahāṅ handed the temple back to Shantidas after 1647. (See Shāh Jahāṅ’s farmān in Appendix VI) It is a different matter, however, that on coming to power Aurangzib revoked the imperial decree, with these words: ‘The dismantled temples which have of late been repaired be pulled down (*butkhānah-hā-i munhadimah rā ki al-ḥāl marammat numūdah and bi-andāzand*).²
c18.39
³ Firishtah, Vol. II, p.839
c18.40
⁴ *Mirʼat-i Aḥmadī*, I, p. 220
c18.41
⁵ Thevenot, *Travels into the Indies*, p.10. Also see M.S. Commissariat, *Mandelslo's Travels in Western India*, Oxford etc., 1931, pp. 23-25; *Studies* *in the History of Gujarat*, p. 56
c18.42
¹ M.S. Commissariat, *Studies in the History of Gujarat*, p. 58
c18.43
² Mirzā Muḥammad Ḥasan alias ‘Alī Muḥammad Khān, *Mir’at-i Aḥmadī*, Vol. I, pp. 259-260
c18.44
On a visit to Riyadh and Jaddah at the invitation of the Su‘ūdī government, Mr. Inder Jit found that mosques, however big or historic, were shifted or demolished, nor were graves allowed to pose any problem, in order just to replan, modernize, and beautify the Su‘ūdī capital of Riyadh. In fact, there are many sources to confirm such a report.³
c18.45
³ Inder Jit, ‘A Lesson from Islamic History’, the *Pioneer*, October 2, 1990
c18.46
Well, the spirit of Islam has always to be kept in view. The Qur’ān is all for uprooting infidelity. The Prophet himself had been engaged in doing so all his life. All is fair in *Jihād*—slaughter, plunder, rape, enslavement, desecration and destruction of temples, conversion by force, etc. It is preposterous to assume that *Jihād* is just a defensive warfare. What could be the relation between defence and breaking idols? Or between defence and conquest, rather world-conquest? Nevertheless, once infidels accept subjection and payment of Jizyah, ‘Ushur, pilgrimage tax, etc., they become *Dhimmī*-s and are permitted to retain their places of worship, though they may not be permitted to build new ones. If some Muslim deprives them of their temples etc., restoration thereof to them is a must by *Sharī‘ah* as well as by pious precedent.
c18.47
To conclude: Capture of Delhi and Ayodhya by Bābar was not an act of *Jihād* on his part. It was a case of simple conquest of a secular nature. India was a *Dāru ’l-Islām* from before Bābar: Bābar did not make it so. Likewise, the Hindus were *Dhimmī’s* from before Bābar: Bābar did not make them so.
c18.48
Hence, their temples were, in terms of the *Sharī'ah*, entitled to proection rather than destruction by him. Therefore, in replacing the Rāma temple by the mosque in question, Bābar can be held guilty of violating the *Sharī'ah*. Righting the wrong done should brook no delay. The *Sharī'ah* is rather more exacting than the laws of other religions. If really followed, therefore, the wrong will be righted in the twinkling of an eye.
Cites (1)
- الجامع الصحيح — Muḥammad b. Ismāʿīl al-Bukhārī, Arabic