Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c18.16

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c18.16

Language
English

c18.16

Otherwise, the *Sharī'ah* would not permit temple-destruction, much less replacement of a temple with a mosque. As hinted above, it divides the world into *Dāru 'l-Islām* (Islam-ruled domain) and *Dāru 'l-Ḥarb* (infidel-ruled domain). Usually, *Jihād* is permissible in the second domain only. Infidels inhabiting the first domain are called *Dhimī-s* (literally, 'protected' infidels), namely such infidels as earn the right to subsist and follow their religion privately in lieu of payment of *Jizyah* and allied taxes, with attendant indignities, as subjects (not citizens) of the Muslim state.² The *Dhimmī-s'* life, property, and places of worship are duly protected, though they may not be permitted to build new ones.³ According to the *Sharī'ah*, therefore, it was incumbent upon Bābar to protect the Rāma temple rather then tamper with it, such less to erect a mosque on its site, by force of arms. He was, for the same reason, a usurper and his mosque an unauthorized and illegitimate one.