The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v2.c15.s17: 10. Ātreya
The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v2.c15.s17
- Language
- English
10. Ātreya
v2.c15.s17.1
Though, as mentioned earlier, the *Vaiśeṣikasūtras* suffered from lack of commentators, at least commentaries have been preserved for us since there are references to at least one such commentary in early times. The Jain writers Vādideva Sūri (fl. 1130) and Guṇaratna (fl. 1400) mention a *Bhāṣya* called *Ātreyabhāṣya* or *Ātreyatantra*, as does Vādindra (1175-1225), a Nyāya writer treated below.¹ Vādideva calls its author "a ripe old leading Brahmin" (to adopt Thakur's translation of *varṣiyān viprapuṅgavaḥ*). He details the views of its author on three points: (1) On the presence of the term *guṇa* in the definition of substance given in *Vaiśeṣikasūtra* I.1.14, Ātreya says that it is necessary to specify that a substance is something which has qualities, since if that were left out the definition would overextend to include motionness (*kriyātva*). (2) With respect to the definition of a motion (*Vaiśeṣikasūtra* I.1.16), Ātreya glosses the term "independent" (in "being an independent cause of contact and disjunction") in order to show that Kaṇāda did not mean to say that motions can cause contacts and disjunctions without any other causal conditions operating. Motion is "independent" only in the sense that another noninherence cause is not required—or perhaps that no extra-ordinary sort of causal factor need be appealed to. Furthermore, Ātreya is said to have thought that this phrase about causing contacts and disjunctions constitutes the definition; the other properties specified in this *sūtra* merely describe motions, but are not differentiating marks. (3) The third matter on which Ātreya is quoted pertains to the question whether doubts and illusions can arise from the visual organ, and if so how. Ātreya seems to suggest that when the visual organ goes out to grasp a distant object all it can get are the generic, universal features and not the details. As a result, doubts and illusions are the natural outcome.²
v2.c15.s17.2
The question of Ātreya's date is almost impossible to answer at present. There has, however, been a good deal of discussion about another old Vaiśeṣika commentary referred to by a number of writers, called *Rāvaṇabhāṣya*. This commentary is referred to by the Naiyāyika Padmanābha Miśra, and by the author of the Vedānta work *Prakaṭārthavivaraṇa*.³ This latter writer attributes to *Rāvaṇabhāṣya* the theory that the large (*mahat*) size, found in the triad and wholes, composed of four or more atoms, is produced by the loose aggregation (pracaya) of two dyads. D.N. Shastri⁴ suggests that the odd account of Vaiśeṣika theory expounded in Śaṃkara’s Brahmasūtrabhāṣya, according to which two dyads produce a caturaṇuka or “quadruple-atom” instead of the usual account which has four triads producing a quadruple-atom, may be due to the fact that Śaṃkara gets his Vaiśeṣika from the Rāvaṇabhāṣya. Anantlal Thakur⁵ suggests that when Mallavādin alluded to a commentary by Praśasta on the Vaiśeṣikasūtras, a Vākya and a Bhāṣya, the latter Bhāṣya may be the Rāvaṇabhāṣya, and its author may have been Ātreya. All of this is extremely speculative, and there is no hard evidence for much of it. That the Rāvaṇabhāṣya was an early text is clear from the fact that Jinendrabuddhi and Udayana know of it,⁶ but whether it was Ātreya’s work is unclear. Kuppuswami Sastri thought that the Rāvaṇabhāṣya was identical with the Vaiśeṣikacaṇḍi.⁷
v2.c15.s17.3
Equally mysterious are references to a Bharadvājavṛtti, which Udayana refers to in the Kiraṇāvali and remarks that it depends on the Rāvaṇabhāṣya (if we can trust Thakur’s memory!)⁸ An old Vṛtti is also quoted by Śaṃkara Miśra and by Candrānanda, author of a commentary of indeterminate age which was published recently.⁹ Ui¹⁰ thinks this Vṛtti may indeed be the Bharadvājavṛtti, but there is no particular evidence for this and Faddegon denies that it is.¹¹ The recent work by Gaṅgādhara Kaviratna Kavirāja called Bharadvājavṛttibhāṣya is not on the old Bharadvājavṛtti, Ui asserts.¹² There is also the fact that Uddyotakara was of the Bharadvāja clan.
Cites (3)
- Vaiśeṣikasūtra — Kaṇāda, Sanskrit
- Brahmasūtrabhāṣya (Śārīrakamīmāṃsābhāṣya) — Śaṅkara, Sanskrit
- Kiraṇāvalī — Udayana, Sanskrit