The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v2.c15.s17.2
The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v2.c15.s17.2
- Language
- English
v2.c15.s17.2
The question of Ātreya's date is almost impossible to answer at present. There has, however, been a good deal of discussion about another old Vaiśeṣika commentary referred to by a number of writers, called *Rāvaṇabhāṣya*. This commentary is referred to by the Naiyāyika Padmanābha Miśra, and by the author of the Vedānta work *Prakaṭārthavivaraṇa*.³ This latter writer attributes to *Rāvaṇabhāṣya* the theory that the large (*mahat*) size, found in the triad and wholes, composed of four or more atoms, is produced by the loose aggregation (pracaya) of two dyads. D.N. Shastri⁴ suggests that the odd account of Vaiśeṣika theory expounded in Śaṃkara’s Brahmasūtrabhāṣya, according to which two dyads produce a caturaṇuka or “quadruple-atom” instead of the usual account which has four triads producing a quadruple-atom, may be due to the fact that Śaṃkara gets his Vaiśeṣika from the Rāvaṇabhāṣya. Anantlal Thakur⁵ suggests that when Mallavādin alluded to a commentary by Praśasta on the Vaiśeṣikasūtras, a Vākya and a Bhāṣya, the latter Bhāṣya may be the Rāvaṇabhāṣya, and its author may have been Ātreya. All of this is extremely speculative, and there is no hard evidence for much of it. That the Rāvaṇabhāṣya was an early text is clear from the fact that Jinendrabuddhi and Udayana know of it,⁶ but whether it was Ātreya’s work is unclear. Kuppuswami Sastri thought that the Rāvaṇabhāṣya was identical with the Vaiśeṣikacaṇḍi.⁷
Cites (2)
- Brahmasūtrabhāṣya (Śārīrakamīmāṃsābhāṣya) — Śaṅkara, Sanskrit
- Vaiśeṣikasūtra — Kaṇāda, Sanskrit