Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v2.c16.s8.3

The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v2.c16.s8.3

Language
English

v2.c16.s8.3

1. KAṆĀDA (Footnotes 6-16 prepared by Masaaki Hattori)
1. Ui, B1048, pp. 4-5.
2. Bhimacarya Jhalakikar, B5967.
3. Cf. V. V. Sharma, B53, p. 225.
4. Ui, B1048, pp. 8-9.
5. Ui, B1048, pp. 40-64.
6. This statement is based on Jambuvijaya's edition of Candrānanda (B58). The sūtra-text commented on by Śamkaramiśra has ten chapters, each consisting of two sections, and the sūtrapāṭhas is quite different from that found in the Candrānanda version. Comparison of the sūtrapāṭhas is made on pp. 77-100 of B58.
7. The word padārtha ("category") does not occur in the sūtras.
8. In the sūtras, the word bhāva is used in the sense of sattā.
9. Later Vaiśeṣikas hold that the relation of inherence exists between (1) whole (avayavin) and parts (avayava), (2) quality (guṇa) and quality-possessor (guṇin), (3) motion (karman) and motion-possessor (kriyāvat), (4) universal (jāti) and individual (vyakti), and (5) an eternal substance (nityadravya) and ultimate particularity (antyaviśeṣa). The expression "effect and cause" does not apply to (4) and (5). Candrānanda states that "effect and cause" is a synecdoche; cf. his comment on VS VII.².29.
10. Later Vaiśeṣikas recognize 7 other attributes, namely gravity (gurutva), fluidity (dravatva), viscidity (sneha), impression (saṃskāra), merit (dharma), demerit (adharma) and sound (śabda), all of which are mentioned in the sūtras but are not listed here.
11. Substance is twofold : one possessing many substances (anekadravyaṃ dravyam) and one possessing no substance (adravyaṃ dravyam). There is no substance which possesses one substance.
12. Inference of this type (employed also in the previous section) is called pariśeṣa.
13. The Mīmāṃsaka view on sound is criticized.
14. The sūtra III.1.13 allows different interpretations. Candrānanda's interpretation has been adopted.
15. The peculiar property of color, etc., is colorness (rūpatva), etc. Cf. Candrānanda's comment on VS IV.1.9.
16. Attributes are noninherence causes (asamavāyikāraṇa), while space and time are efficient causes (nimittakāraṇa).

Cites (1)