Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s27: The Guṇas
Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s27
- Language
- English
The Guṇas
v2.c24.s27.1
The development of prakṛti arises by means of its three constituent powers, or guṇas,¹ which are postulated in view of the character of the effects of prakṛti. Prakṛti is a string of three strands. Buddhi, which is an effect, has the properties of pleasure, pain and bewilderment, and so its cause, prakṛti, must have answering properties. The guṇas are not perceived, but are inferred from their effects. The first of these is called sattva. It is potential consciousness, and therefore tends to conscious manifestation and causes pleasure to the individual. Etymologically, the word sattva is derived from " sat," or that which is real or existent. Since consciousness (caitanya) is generally granted such existence, sattva is said to be potential consciousness. In a secondary sense, " sat " also means perfection, and so the sattva element is what produces goodness and happiness. It is said to be buoyant or light.² The second, rajas, is the source of all activity and produces pain. Rajas leads to a life of feverish enjoyment and restless effort.¹ The third is tamas, that which resists activity and produces the state of apathy or indifference. It leads to ignorance and sloth. The respective functions of sattva, rajas and tamas are manifestations (prakāśa), activity (pravṛtti), and restraint (niyamana),² producing pleasure, pain and sloth. The three guṇas are never separate. They support one another and intermingle with one another. They are closely related as the flame, the oil and the wick of a lamp.³ They constitute the very substance of prakṛti. All things are composed of the three guṇas,⁴ and the differences of the world are traced to the predominance of the different guṇas. The origin of this conception is undoubtedly psychological, since the kinds of feeling tone are made the basis of the distinction, but even so early as the period of the Sāṁkhya Kārikā the guṇas signified factors or constituents of prakṛti.⁵ They are called guṇas (or qualities), since prakṛti alone is substantive, and these are merely elements in it. They may be regarded as representing the different stages of the evolution of any particular product. The sattva signifies the essence or the form which is to be realised, the tamas the obstacles to its realisation, and the rajas represents the force by which the obstacles are overcome and the essential form is manifested. A thing is always produced, never created, according to the Sāṁkhya theory of satkāryavāda. Production is manifestation and destruction is non-manifestation. These two depend on the absence and presence of counteracting forces. A thing is manifested when the impediments are removed. It is sattva or the form of a thing that is manifested; it is rajas that brings about the manifestation; tamas is the resistance to be overcome, the obstacle to the manifestation of sattva.¹ While sattva and tamas answer to the affirmative being and negative non-being, rajas refers to the struggle between the two. Everything has its ideal essence, which it strives after, and actual setting, which it tries to get rid of. The latter is its tāmasa state, the former its sattva state, while the process of striving represents the rājasa condition. Sattva, finally, is that by which a thing manifests itself to consciousness. Since these moments are found in all existence, they are attributed to the original prakṛti.²
v2.c24.s27.2
¹ S.K., 16.
v2.c24.s27.3
² Sukhaprakāśalāghava.
v2.c24.s27.4
¹ Duḥkhopaṣṭambhakatva, pravartakatva, while tamas is characterised by mohagurutvāvaraṇaiḥ (Tattvakaumudī, p. 13).
v2.c24.s27.5
² Prakāśakriyāsthitiśīlam . . . (V.S., ii. 18).
v2.c24.s27.6
³ S.K., 13.
v2.c24.s27.7
⁴ Triguṇātmaka.
v2.c24.s27.8
⁵ Cp. Śvet. Up., iv. 5. “Ajām ekāṁ lohitaśuklakṛṣṇām . . .” Śaṁkara sees in it a reference to the three colours mentioned in the Chāndogya Upaniṣad (vi. 4). Śaṁkara makes an adherent of the Sāṁkhya school interpret it thus: “In this verse, by the words ‘red, white and black’ are to be understood rajas, sattvam and tamas. The red is rajas (emotion), because it naturally makes red, produces unrest, rañjayati; the white is sattvam (essentially good), because it naturally makes bright; the black is tamas (darkness), since it naturally darkens. As the three guṇas belong to the primal prakṛti, they are called ajā, unborn.” The guṇas are so called because they bind the spirit (guṇa = rope) (S.P.B., i. 61).
v2.c24.s27.9
¹ Dr. Seal writes: "Every phenomenon consists of a threefold arché: intelligible essence, energy and mass. In intimate union these enter into things as essential constitutive factors. The essence of a thing (sattva) is that by which it manifests itself to intelligence, and nothing exists without such manifestation in the universe of consciousness (samaṣṭibuddhi). But the essence is only one of three moments. It does not possess mass or gravity, it neither offers resistance nor does work. Next, there is the element of tamas, mass, inertia, matter-stuff, which offers resistance to motion as well as to conscious reflection. But the intelligence-stuff and the matter-stuff cannot do any work, and are devoid of productive activity in themselves. All work comes from rajas, the principle of energy, which overcomes the resistance of matter and supplies even intelligence with the energy which it requires for its own work of conscious regulation and adaptation" (*The Positive Sciences of the Hindus*, p. 4). To some Dr. Seal's clever attempt would seem not so much interpreting the Sāṃkhya as rewriting it.
v2.c24.s27.10
² Sometimes it is said that activity, which characterises the whole universe, has no meaning apart from something that resists activity. Thus rajas, or the active phase, implies tamas, or the passive aspect. Without it there will be perpetual activity of all things. The activity itself serves rational ends, and so the sattva aspect also is present (*Tattvakaumudī*, p. 13).
v2.c24.s27.11
The guṇas are not qualities in the Vaiśeṣika sense, since they possess the properties of lightness, activity, etc.³ Vijñānabhikṣu makes them types of reals,⁴ while in the early Upaniṣads⁵ they stand for psychic states which produce physical and mental evil. The guṇas are said to be extremely fine in texture. They are always changing. Even in what is regarded as the state of equilibrium the guṇas are continually changing into one another.⁶ These changes in themselves do not produce objective results, so long as the equililibrium is undisturbed. If there is a disturbance of the equilibrium (guṇakṣobha), then the guṇas act on one another and evolution takes place. The varied interaction of the guṇas accounts for the variety of the world. Whichever guṇa is preponderant in any phenomenon, it becomes manifest in it, though the others are not absent. In material things at rest, tamas is preponderant, while sattva and rajas are subordinate; in things in motion, rajas is preponderant, while the others are latent. So the terms "sattva, rajas and tamas" are employed to mark predominant aspects rather than exclusive characters. Though the guṇas work together for the production of the world of effects, still they never coalesce. They are modified by mutual influence on one another or by their proximity. They evolve, join and separate. No one loses its power, though the others may be actively at work.¹ Prakṛti and its products possess the guṇas and so are unconscious. They are devoid of the power of discriminating between themselves and puruṣa. They are always objective, while puruṣa alone is subject.
v2.c24.s27.12
³ S.P.B., i. 61.
v2.c24.s27.13
⁴ Vācaspati and Sāṃkhyakārikā do not give this interpretation.
v2.c24.s27.14
⁵ Śvetāśvatara and Maitrāyaṇī Upaniṣads.
v2.c24.s27.15
⁶ Sārūpapariṇāma.
v2.c24.s27.16
¹ Y.B., ii. 18.
v2.c24.s27.17
A different view of guṇas is found in Vijñānabhikṣu, who regards them as subtle entities, infinite in number according to the diversity of individuals. It is not correct, according to this view, to say that the universal guṇas produce a diversity of effects on account of their varying combinations, since such a view cannot account for the appearance of minor differences.² Though the manifestations of the guṇas are innumerable, still on account of the possession of certain features in common, as lightness, they are classified into three kinds.³ Each of the three "causal substances, sattva, etc., has manifold individual manifestations."⁴ The guṇas cannot be created or destroyed. While the concrete phenomenal modes are subject to addition and subtraction, growth and decay, which changes are brought about by collocations and alterations from potential to actual, still the potential and the actual together are ever the same. It is just as in a game of dice: they are ever the same dice, but as they fall in various ways, they mean to us different things. All change relates to the position, order, grouping, mixing, separation of the eternally existing essentials, which are always integrating and disintegrating.⁵
v2.c24.s27.18
² S.P.B., i. 127.
v2.c24.s27.19
³ S.P.B., i. 128.
v2.c24.s27.20
⁴ Ibid.
v2.c24.s27.21
⁵ Tattvakaumudī, pp. 13-16; Tattvavaiśāradī, ii. 20; iv. 13-14; and Yogavārttika, iv. 13-14.
v2.c24.s27.22
EVOLUTION
v2.c24.s27.23
Prakṛti is the fundamental substance out of which the world evolves. In the unmanifested condition, prakṛti is but the union of opposites. When they are all held together in a state of equilibrium (sāmyāvastha), there is no action. The state of rest is said to be the natural condition of prakṛti.¹ Yet the absence of outer activity does not mean the absence of any tendency to act. The tendencies to manifestation (sattva) and activity (rajas) are held in check by the tendency to non-manifestation and non-activity (tamas). The Sāṃkhya conceives the supreme principle of the world as a unity with a real opposition of elements. An abstract unit can be either perpetually active or perpetually inactive. Prakṛti is not, by nature, unstable, and need not differentiate itself of necessity.² When there is a disturbance of the equilibrium of the guṇas, we have the destruction of prakṛti,³ the relieving of the tension by the overweighting of one side, and the setting in of the process of becoming. Prakṛti evolves under the influence of puruṣa. The fulfilment of the ends of the puruṣa is the cause of the manifestation of prakṛti in the three specialised states.⁴ Since prakṛti is one and ubiquitous, all things have prakṛti for their basis, and, in a sense, everything shares the characters of everything else. But, as a matter of fact, the things do not manifest all effects at once. The cause of development follows a definite law of succession in space, time, mode and causality.⁵ We cannot say why this development happens. We have only to accept it. Prakṛti, which contains within itself the possibilities of all things, develops into the apparatus of thought as well as the objects of thought.
v2.c24.s27.24
¹ Y.B., ii 18.
v2.c24.s27.25
² See Spencer: *First Principles*, p. xix.
v2.c24.s27.26
³ Prakṛtināśa.
v2.c24.s27.27
⁴ Trayāṇāṃ tv avasthāviśeṣāṇām ādau puruṣārthatā kāraṇam bhavati (Y.B., ii. 19). See also Vācaspati on it.
v2.c24.s27.28
⁵ Pariṇāmakramaniyama.
v2.c24.s27.29
Mahat, or the Great, the cause of the whole universe, is the first product of the evolution of prakṛti. It is the basis of the intelligence of the individual. While the term “mahat” brings out the cosmic aspect, buddhi, which is used as a synonym for it, refers to the psychological counterpart appertaining to each individual. In the Sāṃkhya, stress is laid on the psychological aspect of “mahat.” From the synonyms of buddhi,¹ and its attributes of virtue (dharma), knowledge (jñāna), equanimity (vairāgya), and lordship (aiśvarya), and their opposites, it is clear that buddhi is to be taken in the psychological sense. But the designations of “mahat,” the Great, Brahmā, etc., imply that it is used in the cosmic sense also.² Buddhi is not to be confused with the incorporeal puruṣa. It is regarded as the subtle substance of all mental processes. It is the faculty by which we distinguish objects and perceive what they are. The functions of buddhi are ascertainment and decision. All other organs function for the intellect (buddhi), which works directly for the puruṣa, enabling the latter to experience all existence and discriminate between itself and prakṛti.
v2.c24.s27.30
¹ Mati, khyāti, prajñā, jñāna.
v2.c24.s27.31
² In later Vedānta, buddhi is taken collectively, as the upādhi of Hiraṇyagarbha.
v2.c24.s27.32
Like the other products of prakṛti, buddhi has the three guṇas. In its sattva aspect, buddhi is distinguished by the observance of duty, knowledge, freedom from desire and divine powers; in its aspect as rajas it produces desires; and in its tamas aspect, it produces negligence, ignorance, etc. Vijñānabhikṣu says that all souls are divine,³ though their “innate lordliness suffers obscuration by rajas and tamas.”⁴ The elemental creation is distinguished from pratyayasarga or the creation of buddhi, which is fourfold, ignorance (viparyaya), incapacity (aśakti), contentment (tuṣṭi), and perfection (siddhi). There are fifty subdivisions of these.⁵ Five kinds of ignorance are admitted which are avidyā and asmitā (or egotism), each of which is eightfold; rāga (desire), tenfold; dveṣa (hatred), and abhiniveśa (or fear), which are eighteenfold. There are twenty-eight varieties of incapacity and nine kinds of contentment and eight forms of perfection.
v2.c24.s27.33
³ Sarva eva puruṣā īśvara iti.
v2.c24.s27.34
⁴ S.P.B., ii. 15. See also Y.B., i. 2.
v2.c24.s27.35
⁵ S.K., 46.
v2.c24.s27.36
Buddhi is both eternal and non-eternal. It exists in germ as seed-force in the causal condition of prakṛti when its functions are not manifested. When it is transformed into the condition of effect it is called buddhi. Vijñānabhikṣu regards it as never-failing and as containing all saṃskāras.¹ The memories are stored in buddhi, and not in ahaṃkāra or manas. " Even after the dissolution of ahaṃkāra and manas by means of the knowledge of the truth, there remains recollection."²
v2.c24.s27.37
¹ S.P.B., ii. 41-42.
v2.c24.s27.38
² S.P.B., ii. 42.
v2.c24.s27.39
Apparently, the functions assigned to intellect by the Kārikā can be performed by it only if it is posterior to the self-sense or ahaṃkāra, and of the manas and the senses, as well as something knowable as the gross elements; but the Sāṃkhya holds that all these are not present at the first stage when buddhi is present. We have, therefore, to take it in a cosmic sense, as the basis of the distinction between the subject and the object, the perceiving and the perceived; but then we shall have to assume a world-spirit, which the Sāṃkhya does not allow. The status of mahat or buddhi is left in an uncertain condition. Buddhi, as the product of prakṛti and the generator of ahaṃkāra, is different from buddhi which controls the processes of the senses, mind and ahaṃkāra. If the former is identified with the latter, the whole evolution of prakṛti must be regarded as subjective, since the ego and the non-ego are both the products of buddhi. This ambiguity is found in the other products of prakṛti also.
v2.c24.s27.40
Ahaṃkāra (self-sense), or the principle of individuation, arises after buddhi. Through its action the different spirits become endowed each with a separate mental background. We have here also to distinguish the cosmic and the psychological aspects. Psychologically, the sense of selfhood is impossible without a non-ego or an object. But the development of the objective comes after the rise of ahaṃkāra in the Sāṃkhya theory of evolution. We have to admit the possibility of a cosmic ahaṃkāra out of which individual subjects and objects arise. Ahaṃkāra is conceived as material, and while buddhi is more cognitive in function, ahaṃkāra seems to be more practical. Psychologically, the function of ahaṃkāra is abhimāna or self-love. Agency belongs to it, and not to the self or puruṣa.³ as consciousness to self-consciousness. The former is the logical presupposition of the latter. We infer the existence of ahaṃkāra from its effects.¹ It is regarded as a substance, since it is the material cause of other substances. The puruṣa identifies itself with the acts of prakṛti through ahaṃkāra. It passes to the self the sensations and suggestions of action communicated to it through manas. It thus helps in the formation of concepts and decisions. Ahaṃkāra is not what individualises the universal consciousness, since the individuality is already there according to the Sāṃkhya. It individualises the impressions that come from the outer world. When the ahaṃkāra is dominated by the aspect of sattva, we do good work; when by rajas, evil ones; and when by tamas, indifferent ones. In dreamless sleep the function of ahaṃkāra may be absent, but the desires and the tendencies are all there.² It is difficult to know how the self-sense is derived from the intellect, or mahat.
v2.c24.s27.41
³ S.P.S., vi. 54. Vijñānabhikṣu quotes the Chāndogya passage " bahu syām prajāyeya " (let me multiply myself, let me procreate), and comments: " The creation of the elements and all the rest is preceded by abhimāna, and so it is said to be the cause of creation " (S.P.B., i 63).
v2.c24.s27.42
¹ S.P.S., i. 63.
v2.c24.s27.43
² S.P.B., i. 63.
v2.c24.s27.44
The guṇas take three different courses of development from ahaṃkāra according to which the latter is said to be sāttvika, rājasa or tāmasa. From ahaṃkāra in its sattva aspect (vaikārika) are derived the manas and the five organs of perception and the five of action, and from the same in its tāmasa aspect (bhūtādi) the five fine elements. The rājasa aspect (taijasa) plays its part in both and is present in the results.³ From the tanmātras, or the five fine elements by a preponderance of tamas, the five gross elements arise. In all these developments, though one of the guṇas may be predominant, the others are also present, perform their functions, and help indirectly the evolution of the products.
v2.c24.s27.45
³ S.K., pp. 24-25. Vijñānabhikṣu holds that the sāttvika ahaṃkāra gives rise to manas, the rājasa to the ten organs, and the tāmasa to the five tanmātras (S.P.B., ii. 18). Aniruddha accepts the usual view that rajas is a condition precedent to all evolution, while the other guṇas determine the character of the constituents. While Vācaspati holds that from mahat arises ahaṃkāra and from ahaṃkāra the tanmātras, Vijñānabhikṣu is of opinion that the separation of ahaṃkāra and the evolution of the tanmātras take place in the mahat.
v2.c24.s27.46
Manas is the organ which has the important function of synthesising the sense-data into percepts, suggesting alternative courses of action and carrying out the decrees of the will through the organs of action. As in the case of the intellect and the self-sense, so also in the case of manas no distinction is made between the organ and its function. Manas is said to be the doorkeeper, while the senses are regarded as the doors.¹ The co-operation of manas is necessary for both perception and action.² It assumes manifold forms in connection with different senses.³ Manas is not all-pervading, since it is an instrument possessing movement and action.⁴ It is made up of parts, since it is connected with the senses. Buddhi and the other organs are not eternal in the sense that there is an eternal subject or Īśvara possessing them.⁵
v2.c24.s27.47
¹ S.K., 35. Buddhi, ahaṃkāra and manas are not always carefully distinguished. They are taken as the inner organ (antaḥkaraṇa). " Antaḥkaraṇa is one and one only according to the threefold distinction of mere states; as in the case of the seed, the sprout, and the huge tree, etc., it falls under the relation of effect and cause." Vijñānabhikṣu quotes a verse from Vāyu Purāṇa to the effect: " Mano mahān matir brahmā pūr buddhiḥ khyātir, Īśvaraḥ" (S.P.B., ii. 16). See also S.P.B., ii. 40.
v2.c24.s27.48
² S.P.S., ii. 26.
v2.c24.s27.49
³ S.P.S., ii. 27.
v2.c24.s27.50
⁴ S.P.S., v. 69-70.
v2.c24.s27.51
⁵ S.P.S., v. 127.
v2.c24.s27.52
The five organs of perception are the functions of sight, hearing, smell, taste and touch. The need creates the function. Since we have the desire, we create the functions and the objects to satisfy them.⁶ The senses are not formed of the elements, since the sense and the elements arise out of ahaṃkāra.⁷ The senses are not eternal, since their rise and destruction are seen. Each sense grasps one quality. The senses are not the organs of sight, etc., as the functions of manas.⁸ They are the means of observing the fine and the gross elements.⁹ The organs of action are the functions of the tongue, feet, hands, and the organs of evacuation and reproduction. Manas, with the organs, is said to produce by their action the five vital airs,¹⁰ which are given an independent place in the Vedānta system. According to the Sūtra, prāṇa (life) is a modification of the senses and does not subsist in their absence.¹¹
v2.c24.s27.53
⁶ Cp. M.B., xii. 7758. Rūparāgād abhūc cakṣuḥ. From attachment to form the eye was produced. See M.B., Śāntiparva, 213. 16.
v2.c24.s27.54
⁷ S.P.S., ii. 20.
v2.c24.s27.55
⁸ S.P.S., ii. 23.
v2.c24.s27.56
⁹ S.K., 34.
v2.c24.s27.57
¹⁰ S.P.S., ii. 31.
v2.c24.s27.58
¹¹ v. 113.
v2.c24.s27.59
The world as the object of perception has the five tanmātras,¹ corresponding to the five sense-organs. These are the essences of sound, touch, colour, taste and smell conceived as physical principles, imperceptible to ordinary beings. Each of them is exclusively concerned with one sense, while the gross elements appeal to more than one sense. These invisible essences are inferred from visible objects, though they are said to be open to the perception of the yogis.² The fine elements are said to be devoid of difference (viśeṣa), while the gross elements arising from them have a definite quality.³ The tanmātras cannot act as sense stimuli until they combine to form atoms. Bhūtādi, or ahaṃkāra, dominated by tamas, is absolutely homogeneous, inert and devoid of all characters except quantum or mass. With the co-operation of rajas it is transformed into subtle matter, vibratory, radiant and instinct with energy, and the tanmātras of sound, touch, colour, taste and smell arise Ākāśa forms the transition link between bhūtādi and the tanmātras. A distinction is made between kāraṇākāśa, non-atomic and all-pervasive, and kāryākāśa, or atomic ākāśa, formed by the combination of bhūtādi, or mass, units with the sound essences. The latter are found held up in the original kāraṇākāśa as the medium for the development of the atoms of air.⁴ According to the Vyāsabhāṣya, the tanmātra of sound is produced from ahaṃkāra, and from the tanmātra of sound accompanied by ahaṃkāra is produced the tanmātra of touch with the attributes of sound and touch, and so on; the others are produced by the addition of one attribute at each step.
v2.c24.s27.60
¹ That only. See Praśna Upaniṣad, iv. 8. Cp. the theory of the elements of elements of Empedocles.
v2.c24.s27.61
² Tattvakaumudī, p. 5.
v2.c24.s27.62
³ Cp. this with the Chāndogya view (vi. 4) of the production of the gross elements by the intermingling of the five elements, where the former receive their special name from the presence in them of a greater proportion of one element. According to one view of the Vedānta, each element consists of a half of one element and one-eighth of each of the other four.
v2.c24.s27.63
⁴ See Seal: Positive Sciences of the Ancient Hindus.
v2.c24.s27.64
According to Gauḍapāda and Vācaspati, the gross elements arise from the compounding of the fine elements by the process of accumulation. There is, of course, the difficulty that on this view ether, which has but one quality, audibility, cannot be contrasted as a gross element with the corresponding fine element.⁵ Vācaspati holds that the ether atom is generated from the other essence, the air atom from the two essences of sound and touch, of which that of touch is the chief, the light atom from the tanmātras of sound, touch and form, of which that of form is the chief, the water atom from the four tanmātras, and the earth atom from the five tanmātras, of which those of taste and smell are the chief ones respectively.¹ Vijñānabhikṣu holds a slightly different opinion. The ether atom is produced from the ether tanmātra through the help of bhūtādi.²
v2.c24.s27.65
⁵ See Tait. Up., ii. 1.
v2.c24.s27.66
¹ Tattvavaiśaradī, i. 44.
v2.c24.s27.67
² Yogavārttikā. Nāgeśa extends to all atoms this co-operation of bhūtādi. Sarvatra tanmātrais tattabhūtotpādane 'haṁkārasya sahakāritvam bodhyam.
v2.c24.s27.68
When the gross atoms combine, their properties are found in their products, so that they do not give rise to a new kind of existence (tattvāntara).³ The ākāśa atom possesses penetrability, the air atom impact or mechanical pressure, the light atom radiant heat and light, the water atom has viscous attraction and earth cohesive attraction. By a combination of the gross atoms the element of earth arises. The capacity of the tanmātras to produce the feeling of pleasure or of pain is not perceived while they subsist as tanmātras. Since it is discernible in the state of the gross atoms, the gross elements are distinguished as soothing (śānta), terrific (ghora), and dull (mūḍha). The atoms of earth, etc., by various changes of quality, appear as the manifold variety of cosmic existence. There are not any intrinsic differences between things which are of the same stuff. As the potentiality of everything is in everything,⁴ there is always change for the sake of puruṣa. The gross atoms⁵ constitute the inorganic as well as the organic bodies, and in the development from the one to the other there is no breach of continuity. Inorganic, vegetable and animal kingdoms are the three stages in the process of development, marked only by changes in the qualities of the constituents⁶ and not in the constituents themselves. The appearance of the different qualities is brought about by the different arrangements of the atoms. To the four kinds of bodies usually admitted, the Sāṃkhya adds two, viz. those born of will (sāṃkalpikam) and artificial ones (sāṃsiddhikam). Earth is the material cause of all these bodies,¹ though the other elements are present as auxiliary to it. The gross body is composed of the five elements, though there are some who think that ether is not necessary, and others who hold that earth alone will do. It is also said that, while the element of earth predominates in the body of man, that of light predominates in the world of the sun.²
v2.c24.s27.69
³ The evolution of the specific (viśeṣa) from the unspecific (aviśeṣa) is called tattvāntarapariṇāma, as distinct from a mere change of qualities, dharmapariṇāma.
v2.c24.s27.70
⁴ Y.B., iii. 14.
v2.c24.s27.71
⁵ Since they contain tanmātras of different kinds as their constituents, the gross atoms cannot be identified with the Vaiśeṣika atoms. The tanmātras, which have no parts, are invisible compared to the Vaiśeṣika atoms.
v2.c24.s27.72
⁶ Dharmapariṇāma.
v2.c24.s27.73
¹ V. 112.
v2.c24.s27.74
² iii. 17-19.
v2.c24.s27.75
Prakṛti and its effects, constituted by the three guṇas, are said to be non-discriminating (aviveki), object (viṣayaḥ), common to many puruṣas (sāmānyam), non-intelligent (acetanam), and productive (prasavadharmi).³ Each evolute is finer than the one succeeding it and grosser than the one preceding it. The series from prakṛti to the five gross elements numbers twenty-four, and puruṣa is said to be the twenty-fifth principle of the Sāṃkhya system.⁴ The twenty-three principles derived from prakṛti are effects, since they are different from prakṛti and puruṣa, are of limited magnitude, and possess the attributes of pradhāna, such as growth and assimilation, and serve as instruments of puruṣa.⁵ All the things of the world are said to be the vikṛtis of prakṛti. Prakṛti stands to vikṛtis in the relation of an original substance to its modifications. Mahat, ahaṃkāra, and the five tanmātras are the effects of some and causes of others. The five gross elements and the eleven organs are only effects and not causes of others. While prakṛti is only cause, the
v2.c24.s27.76
³ S.K., 11.
v2.c24.s27.77
⁴ 1. Puruṣa.
v2.c24.s27.78
⁵ S.P.S., i. 129-134; S.K., 15.
v2.c24.s27.79
2. Prakṛti (unmanifested) = manifested.
v2.c24.s27.80
3. Buddhi, or intellect. 10. Manas.
4. Ahaṃkāra, or self-sense. 11-15. Five senses. 5-9. Five tanmātras of sound, 16-20. Five organs of action. touch, smell, form and 21-25. Five gross elements of ether, taste. air, light, water and earth.
v2.c24.s27.81
eleven products are simply effects. Seven of the products are both causes and effects, while the puruṣa is neither cause nor effect.¹
v2.c24.s27.82
¹ S.K., 3. Cp. Erigena : "That which creates and is not created ; that which is created and creates ; that which is created and creates not ; and that which neither creates nor is created" (De Divisione Naturæ, Lib. 5). See Garbhopaniṣad, 3.
v2.c24.s27.83
These products of the evolution, which are capable of originating other products like themselves, are said to be non-specialised (aviśeṣa), while those which cannot originate other existences like themselves are said to be completely specialised (viśeṣa). When ahaṃkāra gives rise to tanmātras, we cannot easily trace the presence of ahaṃkāra in the fine elements. What is derived from ahaṃkāra seems to be a different existence altogether, and this transformation is a case of tattvāntarapariṇāma. The senses and the gross elements cannot give rise to an altogether different kind of existence. So, while ahaṃkāra is non-specialised (aviśeṣa), the senses, etc., are highly specialised (viśeṣa).²
v2.c24.s27.84
² See Y.B., ii. 19, where the tanmātras and the feeling of personality are said to be aviśeṣa forms of the mahat, while the five elements are the viśeṣa forms of the tanmātras, and the five senses, the five organs of action, and manas are said to be viśeṣa forms of asmitā.
v2.c24.s27.85
Development is only the unfolding of what has already potential existence. The beginning and the end are alike determined. In spite of the things to which prakṛti gives rise, its substance is in no way diminished. The source of becoming is not exhausted by the things produced. No material thing can act without exhausting some of its latent energy. It is thus difficult to regard prakṛti as purely material in nature.
v2.c24.s27.86
It is difficult to understand the precise significance of the Sāṃkhya account of evolution, and we have not seen any satisfactory explanation as to why the different steps of evolution are what they are.
v2.c24.s27.87
The different principles of the Sāṃkhya system cannot be logically deduced from prakṛti, and they seem to be set down as its products, thanks to historical accidents. There is no deductive development of the products from the one prakṛti. Vijñānabhikṣu is aware of this defect, and so asks us to accept the Sāṃkhya account of evolution on the authority of the scriptures.³ But this is to surrender the possibility of philosophical explanation.
v2.c24.s27.88
³ Atra prakṛter mahān mahato 'haṃkāra ityādi sṛṣṭikrame śāstram eva pramāṇam (Sāṃkhyasāra). See also Jayanta's Nyāyamañjarī, pp. 452-466.
v2.c24.s27.89
Buddhi, ahaṃkāra, manas and the rest need not be taken as a series of chronologically successive stages of evolution. They are the results of the logical analysis of evolved selves. Vācaspati writes: "Every man uses first his external senses, then he considers (with the manas), then he refers the various objects to his ego (ahaṃkāra), and lastly he decides with his buddhi what to do."¹ While this analysis gives an explanation of the recognition of the different factors on the subject side, it does not help us towards understanding the precise functions of these factors when enlarged to a cosmic plane. The cosmic scheme is framed on the analogy of the human self, since man is a microcosm in which all the factors of reality are repeated, as it were, on a reduced scale. Answering to the alternations of waking, sleeping, we have creation and destruction of the world. In the state of dreamless sleep the self is present, though it does not apprehend the world. So, in the state of world-absorption (pralaya), the selves are not destroyed, though prakṛti is not perceived. When a man wakes up from sound sleep and says, "I slept well, I knew nothing," this nothing is the not-self, or avyakta prakṛti, from which arises the cognition of something. The state of prakṛti, when its activity sinks into rest, corresponds to the state of suṣupti or dreamless sleep of the individual soul. When one wakes up from it, there is first the dawning of consciousness, followed immediately by the rise of the sense of selfhood and the restlessness of desire. The senses and the five elements of sound, touch, etc., come next into activity. It is only when the man wakes up that the gross elements are apprehended by him. Consciousness or buddhi, is the first glow in the vacant sky that arises when the self is confronted by the not-self. The self becomes aware that there is something. It next becomes conscious of its individuality through distinction from the not-self. It has the feeling that "I perceive the object." Then we discover that the object is a series of mental states synthesised by mind and made up of elements.² The whole scheme of the Sāṃkhya evolution seems to be based on the psychological experience of the individual. But the transition from the psychological to the metaphysical was mediated by the historical fact that in the Upaniṣads the self-conscious Brahmā is said to be the first offshoot of the absolute consciousness. The conception of mahat as the first product of prakṛti can be traced to the derivation of the great soul from the unmanifested (avyakta) in the Kaṭha Upaniṣad.¹ Mahat is prakṛti (non-being) illuminated by consciousness (being). We have in the Upaniṣads the idea of Hiraṇyagarbha or Brahmā, the world soul, who is said to be derived from the impersonal Brahman. The only way in which the conception of the rise of mahat from prakṛti can be made intelligible is through the acceptance of the Vedānta position. There is the supreme Brahman beyond both the subject and the object. The moment it is related to the object it becomes a subject with an object set over against it.² While the nature of the supreme is pure consciousness, that of prakṛti is unconsciousness; and when the two intermingle we have consciousness-unconsciousness, or subject-object, and that is mahat. Even non-being is potential being or potential consciousness. Immediately the subject contrasts itself with the object, it develops the sense of selfhood. There is first intelligence and then selfhood. Creation is preceded by a sense of selfhood. "I shall be
v2.c24.s27.90
¹ Tattvakaumudī, p. 23.
v2.c24.s27.91
² Sir R. G. Bhāndārkar gives a Fichtean interpretation of the Sāṃkhya theory of evolution. The individual who knows directly what passes in his consciousness is aware of certain sensations of which he is not the generator. He therefore assumes an external nature. Its reality is evidenced
v2.c24.s27.92
¹ iii. II.
v2.c24.s27.93
² Cp. Bṛh. Up., i. 4. 2: Ikṣmācakre (He looked round); Chān. Up., vi. 2. 2: Tad aikṣata (That he saw). Cp. Bhagavata: "What they declare to be the citta, or mind, called Vāsudeva, i.e. Viṣṇu, that consists of mahat," yad āhur vāsudevākhyaṁ cittaṁ tan mahadātmakam (iii. 16. 21). See S.P.B., vi. 66.
v2.c24.s27.94
by the limitations of the free activity of consciousness. " In the state of consciousness when the 'me' feels itself limited, then intellect first of all posits or affirms the 'me' and then opposes to itself the 'not me.' The limitation of the 'me' implies its previous freedom or unlimitedness." We thus get the finite ego, the non-ego, the limitation, and the absolute self. The ahaṁkāra of the Sāṁkhya belongs to the finite ego. The subtle and the gross elements, as well as their counterparts, the senses, said to be produced by the ego, correspond to the non-ego. The free, unlimited absolute self is the puruṣa and its limitations by the non-ego bondage. But since the absolutely free puruṣa cannot be the source of limitations, the Sāṁkhya admits the existence of a distinct cause, which is its nature is infinite, and whose finiteness, from its intimate connection with the infinite ego, the ego attributes to itself from ignorance. See Indian Philosophical Review, ii. pp. 200 ff.
v2.c24.s27.95
many; I shall procreate."¹ The obscurity of the Sāmkhya theory is due to the fact that a psychological report is mixed up with a metaphysical statement. The order of psychological presentation need not be the order of real evolution unless the subject is the ultimate and supreme one. The Sāmkhya combines with its own presuppositions ideas essentially alien to it taken from the Upaniṣads.
v2.c24.s27.96
¹ Chān. Up., vi. 2. 3.
v2.c24.s27.97
SPACE AND TIME
v2.c24.s27.98
Every phenomenon of cosmic evolution is characterised by activity, change or motion (parispanda).² All things undergo infinitesimal changes of growth and decay. In the smallest instant of time (kṣaṇa) the whole universe undergoes a change. In the empirical world, space and time appear as limited, and are said to arise from ākāśa, when it is conditioned by coexistent things in space and moving bodies in time.
v2.c24.s27.99
² Vyaktam, sakriyam, parispandavat (Tattvakaumudī). See also Y.B., iii. 13.
v2.c24.s27.100
Vijñānabhikṣu says: "Eternal space and time are of the form of prakṛti, or the root-cause of ākāśa, and are only the specific modifications of prakṛti. Hence the universality of space and time is established. . . . But these, space and time, which are limited, are produced from ākāśa through the conjunction of this or that limiting object (upādhi)."³ Limited space and time are ākāśa itself particularised by this or that limiting object, though they are said to be its effects. Space and time are by themselves abstractions. They are not substances, as the Nyāya-Vaiśeṣika thought, but relations binding the events of the development of prakṛti. Events stand in relations of time and space. We have no perception of infinite time or infinite space, and so they are said to be constructed by the understanding. From the limited objects of perception which stand to one another in the relation of antecedence and sequence, we construct an infinite time order to represent the course of evolution. Vyāsa says: "Just as the atom is the minimal limit of matter, so the moment (kṣaṇa) is the minimal limit of time, or the time taken by an atom in motion in order to leave one point and reach the next point is a moment. But the continuous flow of these is a sequence (krama). Moments and the sequences of these cannot be combined into a real (vastu). Thus, time, being of this nature, does not correspond to anything real, but is a product of mind, and follows as a result of perceptions or of words"¹; but the moment is objective and rests on the sequence.² The sequence (krama) has for its essence an uninterrupted succession of moments which is called time (kāla) by experts. Two moments cannot occur simultaneously, since it is impossible that there be a sequence of two things that occur simultaneously. When a later moment succeeds an earlier, there is a sequence. Thus in the present there is a single moment and there are no earlier or later moments. Therefore, there is no combination of them. But those moments which are past and future are to be explained as inherent in the changes (pariṇāma). Accordingly, the whole world passes through change in any single moment;³ so all those external aspects of the world are relative to this present moment.⁴
v2.c24.s27.101
³ S.P.B., ii. 12; ii. 10. Cp. Y.B., iii. 52.
v2.c24.s27.102
¹ Sa khalv ayaṁ kālo vastuśūnyo 'pi buddhinirmāṇaḥ śabdajñānānupātī.
v2.c24.s27.103
² Kṣaṇastu vastu patitah kramāvalambī.
v2.c24.s27.104
³ Tenaikena kṣaṇena kṛtsno lokaḥ pariṇāmam anubhavati.
v2.c24.s27.105
⁴ So the Yogis can perceive directly both the moments and their sequence (Y.B., iii. 52).
v2.c24.s27.106
The world is neither real nor unreal. It is not unreal, like a man's horn, nor real, since it passes away.⁵ It is not, however, to be regarded as indescribable, since such a thing cannot exist.⁶ The Sāmkhya repudiates the view that regards the world as a reflection of what is not,⁷ nor is the world a mere idea.⁸ The world exists in its eternal form of prakṛti and passes away in its transitory manifestations.⁹ The world has phenomenal reality as undergoing transformations.¹⁰ Cosmic process is twofold in character, creative as well as destructive. Creation is the unfolding of the different orders from the original prakṛti, and destruction is the dissolution of them into the original prakṛti. As a result of the disturbance of the condition of equilibrium, the universe is evolved with its different elements, and at the close of the world-period the products return by a reverse movement into the preceding stage of development, and so finally into prakṛti. Prakṛti remains in this condition until the time arrives for the development of a new universe. This cycle of evolution and reabsorption has never had a beginning and will never have an end. The play of prakṛti does not cease when this or that individual attains release.¹ though the emancipated are unaffected by the action of prakṛti. Though prakṛti is one only, and common to all puruṣas, it manifests itself in many ways: to the souls in bondage it evolves into many a form from the subtlest to the grossest; and to the freed it retraces its steps and becomes resolved into its own primeval form. So long as there are spectators, the play of prakṛti goes on. When all souls are set free, the play is over and the actors retire.² But as there will be always souls struggling to escape out of entanglement in prakṛti, the continuous rhythm of prakṛti’s activity will be maintained for ever. Saṁsāra will never reach its end.³ Since the state of dissolution is the normal condition, in the state of evolution there is a tendency to lapse into dissolution. When the desires of all puruṣas require that there should be a temporary cessation of all experience, prakṛti returns to its quiescent state. The guṇas are so finely opposed that no one becomes predominant. There is therefore no generation of new things and qualities. Even the state of pralaya is intended to serve the interests of puruṣas. In the state of pralaya, prakṛti is not inactive, though its changes are homogeneous.
v2.c24.s27.107
⁵ S.P.S., v. 52-53.
v2.c24.s27.108
⁶ S.P.S., v. 54.
v2.c24.s27.109
⁷ S.P.S., v. 55.
v2.c24.s27.110
⁸ S.P.S., i. 42.
v2.c24.s27.111
⁹ Sadasatkhyātir bādhābādhāt (S.P.S., v. 56).
v2.c24.s27.112
¹⁰ S.P.B., i. 26.
v2.c24.s27.113
¹ S.P.S., iii. 66.
v2.c24.s27.114
² S.K., 58-59; S.P.S., iii. 63.
v2.c24.s27.115
³ Y.S., ii. 22; S.P.S., ii. 4; S.P.S., i 159; i. 67; vi. 68. 69.
Cites (24)
- Sāṃkhyasūtra — Kapila, Sanskrit
- Sāṃkhyakārikā — Īśvarakṛṣṇa, Sanskrit
- Yogabhāṣya — Vyāsa & Patañjali (author of the Yogasūtra), Sanskrit
- Chāndogyopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Tattvavaiśāradī — Vācaspati Miśra, Sanskrit
- Mahābhārata — Sanskrit
- Bhāgavatapurāṇa — Vyāsa, Sanskrit
- Kaṭhopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Praśnopaniṣad — Pippalāda, Sanskrit
- Taittirīyopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Garbhopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Bṛhadāraṇyakopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Yogasūtra — Patañjali (author of the Yogasūtra), Sanskrit
- Śvetāśvataropaniṣad — Śvetāśvatara, Sanskrit
- Vāyupurāṇa — Vyāsa, Sanskrit
- Nyāyamañjarī — Jayanta Bhaṭṭa, Sanskrit
- Sāṃkhyasāra — Vijñānabhikṣu 1550, Sanskrit
- Maitrāyaṇīyopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Mahābhārata — Vyāsa, Sanskrit
- Vaiśeṣikasūtra — Kaṇāda, Sanskrit
- Sāṃkhyapravacanabhāṣya — Vijñānabhikṣu 1550, Sanskrit
- Pātañjalayogaśāstravivaraṇa — Śaṅkara, Sanskrit
- Yogavārttika — Vijñānabhikṣu 1550, Sanskrit
- Tattvakaumudī — Saṅghatilaka Sūri, Sanskrit