Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s5.45

Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s5.45

Language
English

v2.c24.s5.45

Vātsyāyana points out that some logicians regarded the syllogism as consisting of ten members. In addition to the five given above, the following are included: (1) jijñāsā, or the desire to know the exact truth of the proposition, whether the hill is on fire in all its parts or in only some; (2) saṁśaya, or doubt about the reason, whether after all that which we regard as smoke is only vapour; (3) śakyaprāpti, or the capacity of the example to warrant the conclusion whether smoke is always a concomitant of fire, since it is not present in a red-hot iron ball; (4) prayojana, or purpose of drawing the conclusion; and (5) saṁśaya-vyudāsa, or the removal of all doubts about the relation of the middle to the major and its presence in the minor.⁴ These five additional members of the syllogism are, according to Vātsyāyana, unnecessary for proof, though they help to make our cognitions clear. They have in view the psychological process. Jijñāsā, or the desire to know, is undoubtedly the starting-point of all knowledge; but, as Uddyotakara observes, it is not an integral factor of reasoning or proof.¹