Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Conception of Buddhist Nirvana c8.16

The Conception of Buddhist Nirvāṇa c8.16

Language
English

c8.16

But if all, or almost all, the doctrines contained in our oldest documents are later inventions, what is it then that Buddha has taught and what in the III and II century B.C.—for this is probably the date which is assigned to the Pali canon in its final form—was superseded by another, reconstructed, Buddhism? We have a definite answer. It is Yoga. This only partly solves the difficulty, because if we are asked what Yoga is, we are told that one feels uneasy when asked such a question, "arien de plus malaise." Nevertheless, on the next page, we are informed that Yoga is nothing but vulgar magic and thaumaturgy coupled with hypnotic practices. This would mean that Buddha was not a follower of some philosophic system in the genre of Patañjali's where the psychology of trance plays a conspicuous part for the solution of definite problems, but that he was an ordinary magician who certainly did not think of denying the existence of a soul or of establishing a psychology without a soul or of being a pessimist. Not only is it asserted that yoga practices existed in India previously to the rise of Buddhism—thus of course, is very probable—but it looks as though the author were prepared to maintain that Buddhism itself, the genuine Buddhism of Buddha, nay, that even the Pali canon, contains nothing but obscure thaumaturgy¹. How else could one understand the following very explicit deliverances? "The yoga out of which Buddhism was produced had no speculative tendencies" (p 53), i e it was "a technical routine in itself quite foreign to every moral religious or philosophic view’ (p. 12)¹ It was, in a word, magic and thaumaturgy. “In this condition, i.e. in the condition of a yoga without speculative tendencies, “has the Buddhism of the Hinayāna remained, beginning from the Mahāvagga up to Buddhaghosa, viz. it was a yoga almost without any alloy” (p. 53)².

Cites (3)