History of Technology in India, Vol. I: From Antiquity to c. 1200 A.D. v1.c39.s4.26
History of Technology in India, Vol. I: From Antiquity to c. 1200 A.D. v1.c39.s4.26
- Language
- English
v1.c39.s4.26
We disagreed (Biswas and Biswas, 1989) with Chattopadhyaya’s paradigm (Chattopadhyaya, 1986) when he grossly undervalued the Vedic tradition, subscribing to the myth of Aryan intrusion into India, and suggesting that the credit for early science in India goes to the Indus valley people rather than the Rgvedic culture - as if the two were not contemporaneous and not part of a wider civilization. In the two volumes of his recent work (Chattopadhyaya, 1986; Chattopadhyaya, 1991), his consistent thread of argument has been that all the reason in ancient Indian science was borrowed or derived from non-Vedic sources and the Vedic literature had the monopoly of anti-reason. His Marxist protest against the extreme and oft-uttered expression ....‘the Vedas contain all knowledge’ was carried to the opposite extreme position and is untenable. Even Joseph Needham cautioned in his Foreword to the book by Chattopadhyaya (1986) that one ‘must beware of pouring out the baby with the bath-water’.