Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

大般涅槃經集解 71.10

大般涅槃經集解 71.10

Language
Classical Chinese

71.10

案僧亮曰:犢子以所見問佛,欲觀其同異耳。外道所見不同,或說無善惡果報、或說有善惡無道、或說有道不修得、或說男得女不得、或說出家得在家不得、或說離欲得在欲不得,二問也。寶亮曰:亦無定執也。佛所以默者,欲申己之迹,非置答之謂也。

Sengliang remarks: The Vātsīputrīya questioned the Buddha using his own views, merely wishing to see how they agreed or differed. The views of non-Buddhists differ: some say there is no retribution for good and evil; some say there is good and evil but no Path; some say there is a Path but it is attained without cultivation; some say men attain it but women do not; some say renunciants attain it but householders do not; some say those who abandon desire attain it but those with desire do not—these are the two questions. Baoliang remarks: He too had no fixed attachment. The reason the Buddha remained silent was to reveal his own traces, not that he intended to set aside answering."

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)