Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

大般涅槃經義記 4.42

大般涅槃經義記 4.42

Language
Classical Chinese

4.42

下難定無,句別有三:以生破無,言「云何因乳而得生酪」以生難破,從乳生酪明非本無;二「若本無」下破無得生,先舉本無得生之言,「何故」已下次以破之。若本無酪而得生酪,本亦無草,何故不生?乳不生草,草可本無,乳中生酪,明酪非無。

Below, it refutes definite non-existence, comprising three distinct clauses. First, refuting non-existence through origination: the words 'how can cheese be originated because of milk?' refute it through origination; that cheese originates from milk shows that it is not inherently non-existent. Second, from 'if originally non-existent' downward, it refutes the notion that non-existence can bring about origination: it first cites the words that what is originally non-existent brings about origination, and from 'why' downward, it subsequently refutes it. If cheese is originally non-existent yet cheese can be produced, grass was also originally non-existent—why is it not produced? Milk does not produce grass, so grass may indeed be originally non-existent; but cheese is produced in milk, showing that cheese is not non-existent.

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)