Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

俱舍論記 18.13

俱舍論記 18.13

Language
Classical Chinese

18.13

「非能破者至僧眾所成」者,釋下一句。非是天授能破者成此僧破體,但是所破愚僧所成。休法師云:「天授是僧,非但能破,亦有所破之義。以此能破亦有成義。」今解:不然。今破彼得聖法輪之因,令不得聖。天授雖是僧,無得聖故,非所破也。又論但說所破僧成。

Regarding "It is not possessed by the one who causes the schism ... it is possessed by the Saṃgha assembly": this explains the last line. It is not Devadatta, the one who causes the schism, who possesses this entity of schism; it is possessed only by the foolish Saṃgha that is split. Dharma Master Xiu says: "Devadatta is a monk; not only does he cause the schism, he also has the aspect of being split. Thus the one who causes the schism also possesses it." Now it is explained: this is not so. Here one breaks their cause for attaining the noble wheel of Dharma, preventing them from attaining nobility. Although Devadatta is a monk, because he does not attain nobility, he is not one who is split. Moreover, the treatise only says that it is possessed by the Saṃgha that is split.

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)