Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

瑜伽師地論略纂 3.30

瑜伽師地論略纂 3.30

Language
Classical Chinese

3.30

為是常相,無常相者,三世共有,故名共相。若常相者,假說徵詰,非正彼宗。量云:汝宗五蘊應不墮三世,許常相故,如無為等。 若無常相,三世恒有,亦不應理。量云:汝宗五蘊非於三世恒是實有,無常相故,如兔角等。 若言表詮無常,非遮詮者,量云:五蘊諸法非三世恒有,世所攝故,如幻事。七

Regarding whether it is a permanent characteristic or an impermanent characteristic: it is shared across the three times, so it is called a common characteristic. If it is a permanent characteristic, this is a hypothetical cross-examination, not their actual school. The formal inference is: "The five skandhas in your school should not fall into the three times; because you accept that their characteristic is permanent; like the unconditioned." If it is an impermanent characteristic, that they are constantly existent across the three times also does not stand to reason. The formal inference is: "The five skandhas in your school are not constantly and substantially existent across the three times; because their characteristic is impermanent; like the horns of a hare." If they say this is an affirmative statement of impermanence and not an exclusion, the formal inference is: "The dharmas of the five skandhas are not constantly existent across the three times; because they are subsumed under the temporal periods; like an illusion." Under the objection

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)

Linked texts (1)