Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c23.10

The Classical Accounts of India c23.10

Language
English

c23.10

But is Damascenus' account of this embassy a trustworthy and faithful account? Strabo evidently gives credit to it, and to some extent confirms it by stating that the Hermes he himself had seen and in another place, while he attributes our embassy to a Pandion rather than a Porus, he still connects it with the Indian who burned himself at Athens. Plutarch in noticing the self-cremation of Calanus, Alexander's Gymnosophist, adds, that many years afterwards at Athens another Indian in the suite of Augustus similarly put an end to his life, and that his monument is still known as the Indian's tomb. Horace, Florus, and Suetonius give indeed another character and other objects to the embassy but write too loosely to be authorities for any fact not reconcilable with the narrative of Damascenus. With that narrative Dio Cassius, too, in the main agrees; but as he specifies tigers, a truly royal gift, and unknown to Damascenus, as among the Indian presents, he gives us an opportunity of testing his and Damascenus' accuracy. For he affirms that the tigers of the embassy were the first ever seen by Romans. Now Suetonius mentions it as a trait of Augustus, that he was ever so ready to gratify the people with the sight of rare or otherwise remarkable animals, that he would exhibit them “extra ordinem”, out of due course and on ordinary days and that in this way he exhibited a tiger on the stage. And Pliny states that “a tame tiger” (and other than tame tigers our ambassadors would scarcely carry about with them) “was shown in Rome for the first time at the consecration of the Theatre of Marcellus (the in scena of Suetonius) in the Nones of May and during the consulships of Q. Tubero and Fabius Maximus, or in the year 11 B.C. i.e. nine years after the date of our embassy, and therefore, a tiger presented by it. The evidence of Dio Cassius on this point is then, to say the least of it, unsupported, and we see no reason to believe that tigers were among the Indian gifts. We thus find the account of Damascenus confirmed in several particulars, and in none satisfactorily impugned. We accept the Indian Sophist, we accept the Hermes, we accept the beggarly presents, and because we accept so much we accept also the Greek letter, and the Pandyan or Puru, king of kings; for we believe, as Strabo also evidently believed, that what Damascenus wrote, he wrote from his own knowledge. But how then explain what is so at variance with our established notions?