The Classical Accounts of India c6.s6.7
The Classical Accounts of India c6.s6.7
- Language
- English
c6.s6.7
Next to Alexander's companions who wrote about his Indian expedition, Megasthenes is the oldest classical writer who had a first-hand knowledge of India and ample opportunity of gathering information His *Indika*, or the collection of Fragments preserved in later writings, has long enjoyed the reputation of being a rich mine of useful and authentic information about India. The question how far the Fragments, usually ascribed to him, can really be accepted as such, and may be relied upon as authentic, has been fully examined in Appendix I. It will appear from what has been said there that the adverse comments against Megasthenes by ancient writers like Strabo, Pliny and Arrian are fully justified, and modern scholars have no right or reason to ignore them. On the whole, it is easy to distinguish critical writers like Strabo and Arrian from the host of others who preceded them and were justly condemned by them as credulous and uncritical. The remarks of Strabo and Pliny, particularly those quoted on pp. 246 ff., cannot be lightly dismissed, and a modern historian should not accept any statement of the early classical writers as true without corroborative evidence. This also applies to the later writers who seem to have derived much of their information from older sources. The unreliable character of the classical accounts is best shown by the mutually contradictory and palpably wrong statements about the absence of slavery, ignorance of writing, etc., and the many absurd tales of men and beasts, and unnatural phenomena solemnly reported by them.
Cites (1)
- Ἰνδική — Λούκιος Φλάουιος Ἀρριανός, Ancient Greek