Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Early Chauhan Dynasties c10: Chapter I: The Origin and Original Habitat of the Chauhāns

Early Chauhān Dynasties c10

Language
English

Chapter I: The Origin and Original Habitat of the Chauhāns

c10.2

The opinions regarding the origin and original habitat of the valiant Chauhāns to whom, according to Tod, impartial opinion must assign “the van in the long career of arms” are almost as numerous as the authors who have thought it fit to deal with the subject. Bards and Rājasthānī chroniclers regard them as fire-born; their *gotrochchāra* makes them lunar Kṣatriyas; and Dr. G.H. Ojha, relying on a number of old *kāvyas* and other records, maintains that they are Rājpūts of the solar race. Ratnapāla’s plates state that Chāhamāna was born from the eyes of the “lord of the eastern quarter.”¹ Further, there are the views of many writers, Indian as well as European, who regard them as descendants of some foreign tribe or other. As, in the babel of these opinions, it is not easy to see where the truth lies, we shall, in the first instance, state a bit fully, wherever necessary, the arguments underlying the more prominent of the theories referred to above; then submit them to criticism; and finally give our own view, without in the least presuming, however, to assert that it would be the last word on the subject.

c10.3

¹ *EI*, XI, pp. 308 ff.

c10.4

**The Agnikula myth.** Rājasthānī bards and chroniclers, of whom Chand Bardāī is the best known, regard the Chauhāns as fire-born. His account of the origin of the tribe can be thus summarised.

c10.5

“Viśvāmitra, Gautama, Agastya and other sages began a great sacrifice on Mount Ābū. *Daityas* (demons), who always dislike such rites, rendered it impure by showering down flesh, blood, bones, urine and many other impure things. With a view to ridding the sages from this nuisance, Vasiṣṭha created, from the sacrificial pit three warriors, Parihāra, Chaulukya, and Paramāra, but none of these three succeeded in the work assigned to him. Vasiṣṭha, therefore, dug a new pit, and as a result of the oblations poured into it, there issued forth a four-armed figure, of lofty stature, red-coloured, red-faced, and bearing weapons in all his hands. The sages named him Chahuvāna. With the assistance of Āsāpurī, whom he thereafter regarded as his family deity, this warrior defeated the *daityas* and drove them back to the nether regions of *Pātāla*.”²

c10.6

² *Pṛthvīrājarāso*. Part I, pp. 45-51.

c10.7

This story is repeated with a few alterations here and there by the Sisāṇā inscription of the Chauhāns of Bedlā,³ Nainsī’s *Khyāt*,⁴ *Hammīrarāso* of Jodharāja,⁵ *Vaṁśabhāskara* of Sūryamalla Miśraṇa,⁶ and the *History of the Chauhāns of Mainpurī*.⁷

c10.8

³ From Dr. G.H. Ojha’s transcript.

c10.9

⁴ I, p. 119, Nāgarī Prachāriṇī Sabhā edition.

c10.10

⁵ pp. 7-14.

c10.11

⁶ p. 515.

c10.12

⁷ *Chauhān-chandrikā*, pp. 41-43.

c10.13

**Criticism of the myth.** No serious student of history can, of course, believe that fire actually produced warriors. But when one is ready to grant the existence of lunar and solar Kṣatriyas, the concept of an *Agnikula* race does not necessarily appear weird and extraordinary and we could easily put the Chauhāns among the fire-born septs, if there were any historical warrant for it. But research into their history shows that as far as the Chauhāns are concerned the Agnikula myth does not go beyond the end of the Christian era. In fact, it appears to be nothing more than the creation of the poetic or imitative brains of bards who, in their hunt for a fine pedigree for their patrons, happened to light on the story of the fire-origin of the Paramāras in some book like the *Navasāhasāṅkacharita*, and found that it could not only easily but also splendidly explain the origin of the Chauhāns too, if they (the bards) simply added the further detail that the Chauhāns, though coming from the same fire-pit as the Paramāras, the Pratīhāras and the Chaulukyas,⁸ were the last to be born and succeeded where their elder Agnikula brethren had failed. It really was a fine piece of work; but great indeed, would have been the astonishment of these bards who adapted it to their purpose, if they had known that the story of the Paramāras' origin was, in its turn, as shown elsewhere (*Rājasthān Bhāratī*, III, 2, 2ff.) by us, based on a similar legend in the *Rāmāyaṇa* regarding the Śakas, the Pahlavas, the Kāmbojas and some other non-Aryan tribes who are said to have been created by Vasiṣṭha to fight against Viśvāmitra, the snatcher of his cow, Kāmadhenu.⁹ In the *Navasāhasāṅkacharita* the first Paramāra is said to have been created for the same purpose, i.e., for bringing back Vasiṣṭha's cow.¹⁰

c10.14

⁸ It is to be noted that the Pratīhāras and Chaulukyas too are not Agnikulas according to their early records. On the origin of the Pratīhāras see my paper in *Poona Orientalist*, Vol. II.

c10.15

⁹ *Bālakāṇḍa*, Cantos 54-55.

c10.16

¹⁰ Canto XI, vv. 64-71.

c10.17

**Myths of origin from Indra, the Moon, and the Sun.** The myth of origin from Indra is found only in the Sevāḍī Plates of Ratnapāla.¹¹ The descent from the Moon, besides being mentioned in their *gotrochchāra*, which speaks of the Chauhāns as *Somavaṁśins*, i.e., Kṣatriyas of the lunar family,¹² appears to have been accepted as true at one time by the Chauhān rulers of Chandrāvatī.¹³ The *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, a Chauhān *praśasti* (probably of Vigraharāja IV's reign), the *Hammīramahākāvya* and the *Surjanacharita* describe the Chauhāns as solar Kṣatriyas;¹⁴ and of modern writers, Dr. G.H. Ojha has written much to support the Chauhāns' claim to solar origin.¹⁵ The *Vaṁśabhāskara*, the authority of which is utilised by some writers of the traditional school, tries to strike a compromise between the theories of solar and fire origin by regarding the Sun and Fire as ultimately identical.¹⁶

c10.18

¹¹ See footnote 1.

c10.19

¹² *Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan*, II, p. 357.

c10.20

¹³ See verse 8 of Luṇṭigadeva's Ābū inscription, (v. 1377).

c10.21

¹⁴ *PV.*, I and II; *praśasti*, vv. 35-37; *HM.*, I, 14-17; *SC.*, VIII, 151-62.

c10.22

¹⁵ *History of Rājputānā*, I, pp. 72-74.

c10.23

¹⁶ See for instance Pandit Jhabarmalla Sharma's paper in the *Rājasthānī*, Calcutta, III, Part 2, pp. 1-8.

c10.24

**Criticism of the above myths.** The above myths go against and, in a way, refute each other. The theory of *Aindra* origin, as already stated, is supported by only one solitary epigraph; and even regarding that we are not sure whether the writer ever meant Indra by the word, *prāchīdikpati*. He might have mistakenly used it for the Sun, the actual lord of the eastern quarter for an unsophisticated mind. The theory of lunar origin is never mentioned before V. 1377. The theory of solar origin cannot be traced earlier than the middle of the twelfth century. Thus, even this the earliest of these theories is not old enough to settle satisfactorily the question of the Chauhāns’ real origin; it merely registers the Śākambharī Chauhāns’ claim to solar descent, without providing even a single cogent argument to prove it. Even if we take all the statements in its support at their face value, they would not prove that the Chauhāns belonged to a pure Kṣatriya stock, because according to these the first Chauhān was born after Kaliyuga had set in, the Buddha had been an *avatāra* of Viṣṇu and the *Mlechchhas* had begun invading India.¹⁷ To be a member of the solar family, he therefore should have been some very late descendant of Ikṣvāku, the first solar king of India. Curiously enough, however, he is described as such neither by the early *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, nor the medieval *Hammīramahākāvya*; nor the comparatively late *Surjanacharita* of Chandraśekhara. He is mentioned instead as a son of the Sun-god, *i.e.*, as an uncle of Ikṣvāku, if we must decide at all the question of the exact relationship between Ikṣvāku and Chāhamāna; and that such uncles, when separated from each other not merely by some generations but aeons, actually had little connection with each other or with the epic solar Kṣatriyas needs perhaps no demonstration. We know that, like Chāhamāna, the monkey-king, Sugrīva, the divine twins Aśvins, the fiery Revanta, and Yama were reputedly the sons of *Sūrya*.¹⁸ Yet does anyone maintain that they were solar Kṣatriyas (with their pedigrees running up to Rāma and Raghu) or even blood-relations in any recognised sense?

c10.25

¹⁷ *PV.*, I, 36-74.

c10.26

¹⁸ *Ibid.*, II, 31-84.

c10.27

**The value of the myths.** But, though individually indefensible, cumulatively the above myths are not without considerable value regarding the problem of the Chauhāns’ origin. According to the Achaleśvara inscription of Luṇṭigadeva, the first Chauhān was created after the solar and lunar races had become extinct.¹⁹ His services were needed to put down the *asuras* interfering with the sacrificial rites of the sage Vatsa. The Agnikula myths centre round a similar core, though external details, no doubt, are quite different. The myths of solar origin regard Chāhamāna as a Kṣatriya created in Kaliyuga. He was produced, they say, to wipe out the *Mlechchhas*.²⁰ Thus these myths agree in pointing to two facts:—
1. That the Chauhāns were not tribally connected with the old lunar and solar Kṣatriyas.
2. That the Chauhāns probably gained recognition as Kṣatriyas rather late in history, and most probably by fighting for Hinduism against non-Hindus.

c10.28

¹⁹ क्षितौ प्रशान्तौ किल सूर्यसोम-वंशौ विशालौ प्रवरौ हि पूर्वम् ।

c10.29

²⁰ *PV.*, II, 68.

c10.30

**The views of Tod, V.A. Smith, and William Crooke.** More than a century ago, Tod seems to have discovered these truths. But with the imperfect data at his disposal, he regarded the Chauhāns as descendants of the non-Aryan Takṣakas.²¹ V.A. Smith believes them to be related to the three other Agnikula races, the Pratīhāras, the Paramāras and the Solaṅkīs, and approvingly quotes William Crooke's remark that the Agnikula myth “represents a rite of purgation by fire, the scene of which was the southern Rājputānā whereby the impurity of the foreigners was removed and they became fitted to enter the Hindu caste system.”²²

c10.31

²¹ *Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan*, I, p. 80.

c10.32

²² *Early History of India*, 3rd edition, p. 412.

c10.33

**Criticism of these views.** Though not without a modicum of truth, the above views cannot be accepted, because while making too much of the Agnikula myth which, as shown above, is a fabrication of perhaps the fifteenth century, they wholly ignore the evidence of the inscriptions of the so-called Agnikula races according to which the Pratīhāras of Maṇḍor were the descendants of a Brāhmaṇa, Hariśchandra, and his Kṣatriya wife, Bhadrā, the Paramāras perhaps of the Vasiṣṭha Brāhmaṇas of the Ābū area, and the Chauhāns of a Brāhmaṇa claiming Vatsa *gotra*.²³

c10.34

²³ For the Maṇḍor Pratīhāras' origin see my paper in the *Birlā Vidyā Vihār Magazine*, Vols. II and III, pp. 11-20; for the Paramāras, the *Rājasthān Bhāratī* III, Pt. 2, pp. 2-8; and for the Chauhāns our view in this chapter.

c10.35

**Dr. D.R. Bhandarkar's theory.** Much more comprehensive, far better reasoned, and almost brilliant, though no less boldly speculative than these is the theory of the Chauhāns’ origin advanced by Dr. D.R. Bhandarkar who maintains that, most probably, the Chauhāns were Khazars and originally belonged to a priestly section of some foreign tribes.²⁴

c10.36

²⁴ Dr. Bhandarkar’s article in *IA.*, XLI, pp. 25-29.

c10.37

The first of Dr. Bhandarkar’s theses, viz., that they were Khazars is based on a coin of Vāsudeva Vahman. On its obverse is a legend in Sassanian-Pahlavī which reads “Saf Varsu Tef-Sri Vāsudeva” in the inner circle to the right, and on the margin, “Saf Varsu Tef-Wahman Multān Malkā”, meaning Śrī Vāsudeva Vahman, king of Multān. On the reverse we have Śrī Vāsudeva in Nāgarī characters and the Pahlavī legend, Tukan Zaulistān Sapardalakshan, *i.e.*, Ṭakka, Zābulistān and Sapādalakṣa. As the letters *v* and *ch* were in old Indian scripts so similar to each other that one could easily be mistaken for the other, Dr. Bhandarkar concludes that “Vāsudeva Chahman”, *i.e.*, Vāsudeva Chāhamāna is the right reading instead of “Vāsudeva Vahman” as read by Rapson, and that this Vāsudeva Chāhamāna, again, should be identified with Vāsudeva mentioned in the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* and the *Prabandhakośa* as the founder of the Śākambharī line of the Chauhāns. The *Prabandhakośa* places him in V. 608, but according to Dr. Bhandarkar this dating is wrong, because the coin discussed above shows that he could not probably have flourished before 627 A.D. Vāsudeva of the coin probably was the chieftain of a foreign tribe called Khazar which later on came to be known as Gurjara. So Vāsudeva Chāhamāna of the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* and the *Prabandhakośa*, with whom the Khazar Vāsudeva has been identified, and naturally also the tribe to which he belonged, must be regarded as of foreign extraction.

c10.38

**Criticism of the theory.** It is not difficult to disprove the above view. It is undoubtedly easy to read Chahman for Vahman in the Nāgarī script of the seventh century, the two letters being similar as pointed out by Dr. Bhandarkar. But how does he explain its being read as Wahman when the legend is actually in Sassanian-Pahlavī script? The coin under discussion has, according to Rapson,²⁵ the name Śrī Vāsudeva only in Nāgarī characters and all the remaining portions in Sassanian-Pahlavī; and in this foreign script, in which alone, it might be noted, the name Vahman occurs, the letters *v* and *ch* are quite dissimilar. According to Dr. J.M. Unvala, with whom I had some correspondence on the subject, the forms of these two letters in Sassanian, invariably, are ^1(v) and ‘(ch) respectively in all the three positions, initial, medial and final. Only very rarely are archaic forms met with, viz., 2 and 𐡎 or 𐡎 . “In all the forms, however, *v* and *ch* are never ambiguous and *v* cannot be read *ch* or *vice versa*.” As this similarity of the letters, however, forms the very foundation of Dr. Bhandarkar’s theory of the Khazar origin of the Chàuhāns, needing as it does as its first requisite the similarity of the words Vahman and Chahman, it loses all its force the moment we realise that the letters *v* and *ch* do not possess in Sassanian-Pahlavī the similarity that they have in the Nāgarī of the seventh century.

c10.39

²⁵ Rapson’s *Indian Coins*, pp. 30-31.

c10.40

**Priestly origin.** In support of the second part of his theory, namely, that the Chauhāns “belonged to some priestly class of foreign tribes”, Dr. Bhandarkar gives the following reasons :—

c10.41

(1) Sāmanta, the earliest prince mentioned in records after Vāsudeva, has been called a Brāhmaṇa of the Vatsa *gotra* in the Bijolīā inscription.

c10.42

(2) The poet Rājaśekhara’s marriage with Avantisundarī, a Chauhān lady, can be explained only if we regard the Chauhāns as Brāhmaṇas.

c10.43

**Partial correctness of the view.** We agree partially with this part of Dr. Bhandarkar’s theory. That there is not much ground for assigning a foreign origin to the Chauhāns has been shown above. But that they were originally Brāhmaṇas has to be conceded, though not on the basis of Dr. Bhandarkar’s second reason, the marriage of Avantisundarī with the Brāhmaṇa poet, Rājaśekhara, inasmuch as *anuloma* marriages were till then permitted both by canonical and customary law.²⁶ Personal examination of the cast of the Bijoliā inscription, kindly made over to me by the late Dr. G.H. Ojha, would convince others, as it has convinced me, that Dr. Bhandarkar is right in regarding “विप्रः श्रीवत्सगोत्रेऽभूत्” as the right reading instead of “विप्रश्रीवत्सगोत्रे भूत” of Kavirāja Shyamaldas’s defective edition. This obviously is an unambiguous statement of the Brāhmaṇa origin of the Chauhāns; and in spite of all the attempts to explain it away,²⁷ we feel inclined to believe it, when we find it supported fully by the *Kyām Khān Rāso* of the Muslim Chauhān author, Jān,²⁸ and in a great measure by the Sūndhā inscription of the Chauhāns of Jālor and the Achaleśvara inscription of the Chauhāns of Chandrāvatī.²⁹ Jān makes Chahuvāna a descendant of Vatsa of the *Jāmadagnya* gotra; the inscriptions state that the first Chauhān was born from the eye and meditation of the sage Vatsa. The Chauhāns’ *gotrochchāra* speaks of them as *vatsagotrins*, and though this by itself would be no strong argument, because the Rājpūts are known at times to have adopted the *gotras* of their *purohitas*,³⁰ the additional evidence supplied in this connection by the records just mentioned disposes one to treat this as an extra reason for regarding Sāmanta of Śākambharī and his ancestors as Brāhmaṇas who like the Pallavas, Kādambas, and the Guhilas were either forced or induced by the prevailing conditions to give up their priestly calling and enter the Kṣatriya fold.³¹

c10.44

²⁶ Ibn Khurdādbā mentions *anuloma* marriages as current in this time. The Brāhmaṇa Hariśchandra married the Kṣatriyā Bhadrā (*EI*, XVIII, p. 95). Saṁgamarāja of Kashmir gave his daughter in marriage to a Brāhmaṇa (*Rājatarangiṇī*, VII, 10-12).

c10.45

²⁷ Mr. Akshaya Keerty Vyas equates *vipra* with *mahīdeva* and the latter term with Mahārāja, even though there is not a single instance in the vast range of Sanskrit literature and epigraphy where the word *vipra* can conclusively be shown to have been used for a Kṣatriya.

c10.46

²⁸ vv. 45-48 put as an appendix to this chapter. For a fuller discussion see my introduction to the Rāso (No. 13, राजस्थान पुरातत्त्व ग्रन्थमाला, जयपुर)

c10.47

²⁹ Sūndhā inscription, v. 4 and Achaleśvara inscription, v. 7.

c10.48

³⁰ For the controversy on the *gotras* of the Rājpūts see C.V. Vaidya’s *History of Medieval India*, II, pp. 50ff. and Dr. G.H. Ojha’s *History of Rāj-pūtānā*, I, pp. 347 ff. The matter can only be of secondary interest to a student of Chauhān history, because Sāmanta’s *gotra* can only be his own and not his *purohita’s*. He is mentioned by our authorities not only as a *Vatsagotrin* but also as a *vipra* or Brāhmaṇa; and a Brāhmaṇa is required by no authority, old or new, to take the *gotra* of a *purohita*.

c10.49

³¹ For the Pallavas and Kādambas see Dr. D.C. Sircar’s *Successors of the Sātavāhanas*, pp. 225ff. and Dr. K.P. Jayaswal’s *History of India, 150 A.D. to 350 A.D.*, pp. 225ff. For the Guhilas read Dr. D.R. Bhandarkar’s *Guhilots*, *JPASB*, 1909, pp. 167ff. and Mrs. M. Sharma’s *Origin of the Guhilots*, *IHQ.* XXVIII, 83f. The progenitor of the Kādambas was, according to their earliest inscription, a Brāhmaṇa named Mayūraśarman. That the first Kādamba should have been, after the lapse of some time, regarded as a four-armed figure sprung from a drop of sweat that fell on the ground near a *kadamba* tree from the forehead of Śiva is an interesting fact showing how mythical accounts could be made up regarding the origin of important historical figures. Bappa, the founder of the Guhila dynasty of Mewār, is mentioned as a *vipra* up to Kumbhā’s time.

c10.50

**The original habitat of the Chauhans.** With our main problem thus settled, at least tentatively, we pass on to the next one most connected with it, namely, that of the original habitat of the Chauhāns. Negatively, we might, after our criticism of Dr. Bhandarkar’s view and the Agnikula myth, state that it was neither Ābū nor probably a foreign country. On the positive side we have the following indications :—

c10.51

(1) Inscriptions as well as old historical chronicles connect them with Jāṅgaladeśa and Sapādalakṣa.³²

c10.52

³² See *IA*, 1912, p. 196 ; *ASR*, VI, Plate XXI ; *Surathotsava*, II, 46 ; *Sukṛtasaṅkīrtana*, II, 43 etc.

c10.53

(2) Tradition maintains that they moved northwards and conquered Delhi from the Tomaras, which is a fact corroborated by epigraphic evidence.³³

c10.54

³³ See *JPASB*, XLIII, p. 108 and my paper on the Tomaras of Delhi in the *Rājasthān Bhāratī*, III, parts 3-4. *Pṛthvīrājarāso* also speaks of the Chauhāns having reached Delhi from Ajmer.

c10.55

(3) The description in the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* puts Vāsudeva’s capital a little to the east of Sāmbhar.³⁴

c10.56

³⁴ Vāsudeva is made to start from the western extremity of the lake Sāmbhar, to have the town of Sāmbhar on the way, and to proceed from there to his capital, an anonymous city, which may have been in the Ananta district of Sapādalakṣa.

c10.57

(4) The Harṣa inscription (V. 1030) shows that Ananta province (the tract situated near Sikar in the Jaipur division of Rājasthān) was the Chauhāns’ old seat of power. It was here that *tantrapāla* Kṣmāpāla tried to attack Vigraharāja II’s grandfather Vākpati, and it was here that the Chauhāns had the temple of their family deity, Harṣadeva.

c10.58

(5) The Bijoliā inscription regards Sāmanta as an *Ananta-sāmanta*, which in the light of the description in the inscription can only mean that he was a *sāmanta* of the Ananta province.³⁵

c10.59

³⁵ The words of the Bijoliā inscription are : “सामन्तोऽनन्तसामन्तः” These can be interpreted in two ways,
(1) Sāmanta, a *sāmanta* or chief of Ananta.
(2) Sāmanta who had *ananta* or innumerable *sāmantas*. In view of the statements in the Harṣa inscription, we have adopted the first sense, though the second one is not impossible and the poet might have intended to convey that too in addition to its primary sense. A third interpretation, Sāmanta who was known as Ananta, suggested by Dr. H.C. Ray, can be regarded as incorrect.

c10.60

(6) The Bijoliā inscription mentions also his being originally at Ahichchhatrapura, a name not inappropriate for the capital of *Ananta-gochara*, *i.e.*, the land of Ananta, the lord of Nāgas.³⁶

c10.61

³⁶ For one more indication in the Bijoliā inscription see the last two sentences of the chapter.

c10.62

(7) The *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, *Hammīramahākāvya* and the *Surjanacharita* give Pushkar as Chāhamāna's birth-place.

c10.63

No part of this evidence will go against us, if we conclude that their cradle-land was in the tract extending approximately from Pushkar in the south to Harṣa in the north. It had every right to be called Jāṅgaladeśa on account of abounding in *pīlu*, *karīra*, and *śamī* trees, the characteristic vegetation of such a tract,³⁷ and was also included in the territory which, according to the *Skanda Purāṇa* was known as Śākambhara-*sapādalakṣa*³⁸ and has been mentioned as Siwālikh by Minhāj-us-Sirāj.³⁹

c10.64

³⁷ आकाशशुभ्र उच्चश्च स्वल्पपानीयपादपः । शमीकरीरबिल्वार्कपीलूकर्कन्धुसंकुलः ॥ हरिणैणर्क्ष्यपृषदगोकर्णखरसंकुलः । सुस्वादुफलवान् देशो वातलः जाङ्गलः स्मृतः ॥ (*Śabdārthachintāmaṇi* p. 991)

c10.65

³⁸ See the Kumārikhaṇḍa of the *Skanda Purāṇa* which mentions a few other *Sapādalakṣas*, *i.e.*, territorial units supposed to have 1¼ lac villages. The Chauhāns belonged to the Śākambhara-*sapādalakṣa* which probably is the territorial unit meant by Wassāf who writes that “Siwālik contains 125,000 towns and villages.” (*ED.*, III, p. 31.)

c10.66

³⁹ Read for instance the following :—
(a) “Again, he (Muhammad Bahlim) rebelled, and founded the fortress of Nāghawr, in the territory of Siwālikh” (p. 110).
(b) “This Tāj-ud-din was in the service of Malik Karim-ud-din hamzah at Nāghawr of Siwālikh.” (p. 200).
(c) “The seat of territory, Ajmīr, with the whole of the Siwālikh (territory), such as Hānsī, Sirsutī, and other tracts were subjugated.” (pp. 468-469).
(d) A year subsequent to this, in 624 A.D., he marched against the fort of Maṇḍāwar within the limits of the Siwālik territory (p. 11). Raverty’s translation of the *Tabaqāt-i-Nāṣirī*.

c10.67

The Harṣa inscription regards it as the Chauhāns’ land; and it was so also according to the Bijoliā inscription, if my interpretation of the term, *Ananta-sāmanta* is correct. No Ahichchhatrapura is to be found there at present.⁴⁰ But that it could have existed in this tract alone can be inferred from the fact that Vāsudeva, the earliest Chauhān ruler known to us, is connected with the Sāmbhar lake, and another very early ruler, Nṛpa or Naradeva, the successor of Sāmanta of Ahichchhatrapura, is described as reigning at Pūrṇatalla or Pūntalā in the Jodhpur Division of Rājasthān.⁴¹ Ahichchhatrapura may have been somewhere between Pūntalā and Sāmbhar; at least it could not have been very far from them, for we have no evidence whatsoever to put the early Chauhāns in any area except that indicated in the beginning of this paragraph.

c10.68

⁴⁰ Dr. G.H. Ojha and Dewan Bahadur H.B. Sarda, however, think that Ahichchhatrapura still exists in the form of Nāgor, a town in the Jodhpur Division. Their chief arguments for identifying the towns are:—
(1) That the names Ahichchhatrapura and Nāgor are synonymous.
(2) That Nāgor was at a hard day's ride from Sāmbhar. The *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* puts Vāsudeva's capital, presumably Ahichchhatrapura, at the same distance from Sāmbhar. The synonimity, however, is doubtful, because not only Ahichchhatrapura is not an exact equivalent of Nāgor or Nāgapura, the exact equivalent being Ahipura, but also because Nāgapura or Nāgor, in spite of being a well-known Jaina *tīrtha*, is never mentioned as Ahichchhatrapura in any Jain work. Even more unsound is the argument from the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*. The description there shows that Vāsudeva passed the night in the temple of Śākambharī. (See the last verse of Canto IV.) Early in the morning, he started from there for his capital which he reached a little after sunrise. So naturally Vāsudeva's capital could not have been at a hard day’s ride from Sāmbhar, at least according to the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*.

c10.69

⁴¹ See verses 11 and 12 of the Bijoliā inscription. Viṣṇu in verse 11 equals Vāsudeva.

Cites (13)