Early Chauhan Dynasties c10.24
Early Chauhān Dynasties c10.24
- Language
- English
c10.24
**Criticism of the above myths.** The above myths go against and, in a way, refute each other. The theory of *Aindra* origin, as already stated, is supported by only one solitary epigraph; and even regarding that we are not sure whether the writer ever meant Indra by the word, *prāchīdikpati*. He might have mistakenly used it for the Sun, the actual lord of the eastern quarter for an unsophisticated mind. The theory of lunar origin is never mentioned before V. 1377. The theory of solar origin cannot be traced earlier than the middle of the twelfth century. Thus, even this the earliest of these theories is not old enough to settle satisfactorily the question of the Chauhāns’ real origin; it merely registers the Śākambharī Chauhāns’ claim to solar descent, without providing even a single cogent argument to prove it. Even if we take all the statements in its support at their face value, they would not prove that the Chauhāns belonged to a pure Kṣatriya stock, because according to these the first Chauhān was born after Kaliyuga had set in, the Buddha had been an *avatāra* of Viṣṇu and the *Mlechchhas* had begun invading India.¹⁷ To be a member of the solar family, he therefore should have been some very late descendant of Ikṣvāku, the first solar king of India. Curiously enough, however, he is described as such neither by the early *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, nor the medieval *Hammīramahākāvya*; nor the comparatively late *Surjanacharita* of Chandraśekhara. He is mentioned instead as a son of the Sun-god, *i.e.*, as an uncle of Ikṣvāku, if we must decide at all the question of the exact relationship between Ikṣvāku and Chāhamāna; and that such uncles, when separated from each other not merely by some generations but aeons, actually had little connection with each other or with the epic solar Kṣatriyas needs perhaps no demonstration. We know that, like Chāhamāna, the monkey-king, Sugrīva, the divine twins Aśvins, the fiery Revanta, and Yama were reputedly the sons of *Sūrya*.¹⁸ Yet does anyone maintain that they were solar Kṣatriyas (with their pedigrees running up to Rāma and Raghu) or even blood-relations in any recognised sense?
Cites (3)
- Hammīramahākāvya — Nayacandrasūri, Sanskrit
- Surjanacarita — Candraśekharakavi 1500, Sanskrit
- Pṛthvīrājavijaya — Jayānaka, Sanskrit