Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Early Chauhan Dynasties c45.s1: Section I

Early Chauhān Dynasties c45.s1

Language
English

Section I

c45.s1.1

*Authors and Subjects Studied*¹

c45.s1.2

¹ For full references read our paper on the subject in the *Rājendra Sūri Memorial Volume*, pp. 841-866.

c45.s1.3

Our information about the subjects and authors studied in Rājasthān, and specially the Chauhān dominions, cannot be regarded as exhaustive. We have no Brāhmaṇic sources worth mentioning except the *Śārṅgadharapaddhati* which falls a little outside our period, being the work of the grandson of Rāghavadeva, a court-poet and Paṇḍit of Hammīra of Raṇthambhor. Yet the position is not so unsatisfactory, as it appears to be at first sight, for the Jainas while devoting the greatest attention to their own system, studied the philosophic works of others, and tried also to vie with non-Jainas in the knowledge of secular subjects like poetics and drama, with the result that their *Bhaṇḍāras* have preserved invaluable books and their commentaries which, but for their care, would have been lost to posterity. In India few have served the cause of Sarasvatī so well as the Jaina custodians of the big *bhāṇḍāras* at Paṭṭan, Jaisalmer and Bīkāner.

c45.s1.4

*Subjects Studied.* From the *Gaṇadharasārdhaśatakabṛhadvṛtti*, we learn that a good Jaina scholar was expected to master his own *siddhānta* along with the philosophic systems of the Buddhists and Brāhmaṇas. He read also classical poetry, prose and drama, astronomy and astrology, poetics, prosody and grammar; and had specially to be an adept in propounding his own theories and refuting the views of rival schools.²

c45.s1.5

² See the *Apabhraṁśakāvyatrayī*, p. 20.

c45.s1.6

*(a) Jaina āgama.* Of the Jaina *siddhānta* works generally 84 are enumerated³; and these had many commentaries and subcommentaries by authors, of whom some were Rājasthānīs. The first great Jaina commentator of Rājasthān was Haribhadra Sūri of Chitor (700-800 A.D.) who in his works⁴ utilised the labours of many earlier writers.⁵ Obviously Jaina scriptures were being intensively studied at Chitor in the eighth century.

c45.s1.7

³ The *siddhānta* included ११ अङ्ग, १२ उपाङ्ग, ६ छेदसूत्र, ४ मूलसूत्र, १० प्रकीर्णक, अनुयोगद्वारसूत्र, नन्दीसूत्र, १२ निर्युक्ति, विशेषावश्यकभाष्य, २० अन्यप्रकीर्णक, पर्यूषणकल्प, जितकल्पसूत्र, श्राद्धजितकल्प, पाक्षिकसूत्र, वन्दित्तुसूत्र, खामणासूत्र, यतिजितकल्प, and ऋषिभाषित.

c45.s1.8

⁴ He commented on the अनुयोगद्वारसूत्र, आवश्यकसूत्र, दशवैकालिकसूत्र, नन्दीसूत्र, and प्रज्ञापनासूत्र.

c45.s1.9

⁵ He mentions जिनदास महत्तर, जिनभद्रक्षमाश्रमण, देववाचक, भद्रबाहु and संघदासगणि.

c45.s1.10

Many other Jaina scholars carried further Haribhadra’s work.⁶ Specially notable was the work of the great Kharataragachchha scholar, Abhayadeva Sūri, who in spite of his ill-health wrote wonderfully lucid and learned commentaries on many Jaina scriptural works.⁷ These were studied not only in Kharataragachchha circles but also by others in Rājasthān, nay in fact, in every part of India where the Śvetāmbara Jainism flourished. And almost equally popular in Rājasthān were the works of Malayagiri Sūri,⁸ a younger contemporary of Kumārapāla’s *guru*, Hemachandra Sūri.⁹

c45.s1.11

⁶ सिद्धर्षिसूरि and वर्धमान सूरि commented on the उपदेशमाला and शीलाङ्कसूरि on the आचाराङ्गसूत्र.

c45.s1.12

⁷ अभयदेव is known as the नवाङ्गवृत्तिकार, *i.e.*, commentator on the nine *aṅgas* to distinguish him from other Abhayadevas. Though he passed most of his life in Gujarāt, his disciple, Jinavallabha and his successors had Rājasthān as the main centre of their activity.

c45.s1.13

⁸ His पिण्डनिर्यूक्तिवृत्ति was copied at Chitrakūṭa and the व्यवहारसूत्रटीका at सिंहपुरी in Śākambharī respectively in the Vikrama years 1289 and 1344 (जैनपुस्तक प्रशस्तिसंग्रह, pp. 118 and 133).

c45.s1.14

⁹ Other writers on *āgama* subjects like मलधारी Hemachandra, Droṇāchārya who revised the commentaries of नवाङ्गवृत्तिकार Abhayadeva, Nemichandra Yaśodeva whose पाक्षिकसूत्रवृत्ति was copied at Āghāṭa in V. 1309, क्षेमकीर्ति, Koṭyāchārya, Devendra Sūri and Śānti Sūri were also well known in Rājasthān. For fuller references see the *Rājendra Sūri Memorial Volume*, pp. 841-866.

c45.s1.15

(*b*) *Philosophy and Logic.* The exegetical work on the *āgamas* was important. But in an age of religious controversy, where one system had to contend against the other, it was obviously equally necessary to give a systematic presentation of the Jaina system, specially its fundamental principles. To our period belongs the credit of having accomplished this work not only with success but great distinction.

c45.s1.16

Besides his commentaries on the *āgamas*,¹⁰ already referred to, Haribhadra wrote the *Anekāntajayapatākā* and *Anekāntavādapraveśa*, in which he not merely expounded the Jaina philosophy of *Anekānta* but also reviewed critically other current philosophic systems.¹¹ How popular the study of his latter work was can be seen not only by the laudatory references to it in Jaina literature but also by the pride eminent Jaina teachers had in studying and teaching it. The *Gaṇadharasārdhaśatakabṛhadvṛtti* speaks of Jinavallabha’s proficiency in the treatise. Jinapati Sūri sent his students to study it at the feet of Yaśobhadrāchārya. Jinapati’s rival, Pradyumna Sūri, boasted of having read it. Of his other philosophic works, we should like to mention the *Yogabindu* and the *Yogadṛṣṭisamuchchaya*, both of which present a valuable synthesis of old Jaina and Pātañjala Yogic systems. Haribhadra’s commentary on the *Nyāyapraveśa* of Diṅnāga introduced the Jaina world to Buddhist logic; and from his reference to the Jaina teachers Kukkāchārya, Divākara (probably Divākaramitra of the *Harṣacharita*), Dharmapāla (the great Buddhist teacher mentioned also by Yuan Chwang), Dharmakīrti (c. 635.50), Dharmottara, Vasubandhu, Śāntirakṣita and Śubhagupta, it may not be even too much to presume that Buddhist philosophy had many students in Rājasthān, in the beginning of our period, and to a certain extent influenced Jaina logic. Jaina scholars inside as well as outside Rājasthān, commented on Buddhist books.¹² Jinavallabha Sūri studied Kamalaśīla's commentary on the *Tattvasaṅgraha*¹³ and so did many of his disciples.

c45.s1.17

¹⁰ As supplementary to the work on the *āgama* texts, Haribhadra had his religious compositions, the *Dharmasaṅgrahaṇī*, *Kṣetrasamāsaṭīkā*, *Pañchavastu*, *Dharmabindu*, *Aṣṭaka*, *Soḍaśaka*, *Panchāśaka*, and *Sambodhaprakaraṇa*. In some of these he not merely expounded Jaina principles but sounded a clarion call for all-sided reform, doctrinal as well as social.

c45.s1.18

¹¹ (1) जिनेन्द्रमतव्यवस्थापक···अनेकान्तजयपताकादि(गणधरसार्धशतकबृहद्वृत्ति)
(2) जुगपवरागम मन्निउ सिरिहरिभद्दपहु, पडिहयकुमयसमूहू पयासिहमुत्तिपहु । (चर्चरी, १४, अपभ्रंशकाव्यत्रयी) See also अनेकान्तविजयपताकावृत्तिटिप्पणक of Munichandra.

c45.s1.19

¹² Rabhasanandi wrote a commentary on Dharmakīrti’s *Sambandhaparīkṣā*. Kalyāṇachandra commented on Dharmakīrti’s *Pramāṇavārttika*.

c45.s1.20

¹³ See the *Gaṇadharasārdhaśatakabṛhadvṛtti*, Introduction to the *Apabhraṁśakāvyatrayī*, p. 20.

c45.s1.21

Umāsvatī, Mallavādin, Samantabhadra, and Siddhasena Divākara were the Jaina philosophers studied most in Rājasthān in Haribhadra's time.¹⁴ The Brāhmaṇa philosophers known to him were Avadhūtāchārya, Iśvarakṛṣṇa, Āsuri, Kumārila, Patañjali, Kālātita and Bhgavad Gopendra. If we identify Avadhūtāchārya with Advayavajra or Avadhūtipāda, he has to be regarded as a Buddhist writer. But Dattātreya also, for whom there is a shrine at Ābū, had this designation.¹⁵ Āsuri, a great Sāṅkhya teacher, preceded Iśvarakṛṣṇa, the writer of the *Sāṅkhyasaptati*.¹⁶ Kumārila is a well-known *Pūrva-mīmāṁsā* philosopher. Patañjali's *Yogasūtras* supplied the basic material for Haribhadra's works on Yoga and were later on utilised also by Hemachandra in his work, the *Yogaśāstra*. Bhagavad Gopendra and Kālātita were Yogins.¹⁷

c45.s1.22

¹⁴ Umāsvāti, known also as Vāchakaśramaṇa, is the famous author of the *Tattvārthādhigama-sūtra* which is accepted as an authoritative exposition of Jaina philosophy by both the Digambaras and Śvetāmbaras. Siddhasena wrote two important works on logic, the *Nyāyāvatāra* and the *Sanmatitarka*. Jinapati Sūri's disciples studied the *Nyāyāvatāra* with Yaśobhadrāchārya. It was commented on by Siddharṣi Sūri (10th century). Samantabhadra is the great Digambara scholar, the author of a commentary on the *Tattvārthādhigamasūtra*, called the *Gandhahastimahābhāṣya* Its introductory portion is known as the *Āptamīmāṁsā*. Mallavādin is the author of the *Nayachakra*, a book on Anekānta philosophy. The *Dharmottaraṭippanaka*, a commentary on the Buddhist logical treatise, *Nyāyabinduṭīkā*, is also ascribed to him.

c45.s1.23

¹⁵ The *avadhūtas* were known as such, either because they tried to get the knowledge of the नाडी called अवधूत or because they followed the धूत discipline in which there is no place for the recognition of वर्णाश्रमधर्म.

c45.s1.24

¹⁶ The popularity of the सप्तति can be gauged by the presence of its copy at Jaisalmer with the commentary of Gauḍapāda.

c45.s1.25

¹⁷ *Yogabindu*, verses 200 and 300. The *Yogadṛṣṭisamuchchaya* refers to Patañjali, Bhagvaddattavādī, and Bhadanta Bhāskarabandhu, the last one of whom may have been a Buddhist writer on Yoga.

c45.s1.26

The *Sanmatitarka* of Siddhasena Divākara was commented on by the *Tarkapañchānana* Abhayadeva Sūri in his great work, the *Vādamahārṇava*. The book presents not only the Jaina point of view but also the theories of others to show how the Jaina view was superior to theirs, and should like the *Tattvasaṅgraha* of Śāntirakṣita and the *Pañjikā* of Kamalaśīla be regarded as an encyclopaedia of Indian Philosophy. It richly deserves the title *Jinendramatavyavasthāpaka* given to it by Sumatigaṇi.

c45.s1.27

The Kharataragachchha *āchārya*, Jineśvara Sūri wrote the *Pramāṇalakṣaṇa*, along with a commentary, "to take away from his seet the blot that it had no *tarka* work of its own"; and the trail he blazed was followed by many others. The great debater Devasūri, who is generally known as Vādi-Devasūri, wrote the *Pramāṇatattvālaṅkāra* and furnished it with a commentary of his own, the *Syādvādaratnākara*. Next followed the works of Hemachandra, a younger contemporary of Devasūri and *guru* of Kumārapāla, and of his pupils, Rāmachandra and Guṇachandra.¹⁸ Towards the end of our period, Malliṣeṇa Sūri wrote the *Syādvādamañjarī*, though we cannot be sure that it reached Rājasthān during our period. And the same may be said of the works of some other Jaina logicians.¹⁹ But we speak of them here, because most of the good literature produced in Gujarāt of those days reached Rājasthān. The *vihāra* of Jaina *sādhus* from Gujarāt to Rājasthān and back was a frequent affair and so were the pilgrimages to religious places in Rājasthān and Gujarāt; and this intercommunication was rendered all the easier by the fact that the inhabitants of these provinces spoke a common language, now generally termed Western Rājasthānī.

c45.s1.28

¹⁸ प्रमाणमीमांसा of Hemachandra and द्वव्यालङ्कारवृत्ति of Rāmachandra and Guṇachandra.

c45.s1.29

¹⁹ Of these writers Nemichandra is said to have refuted the views of Kanāda. चन्द्रप्रभ was the author of दर्शनशुद्धिप्रमेयरत्नकोश and न्यायावतारविवृत्ति. पार्श्वदेवगणि wrote the न्यायावतारप्रवेशपञ्जिका. Ānanda Sūriand Amarchandra may have written the book known to गङ्गेश उपाध्याय as सिंहव्याघ्री. श्रीचन्द्र wrote the न्यायप्रवेश-टिप्पण. Devabhadra's न्यायावतारटिप्पण is a commentary on the न्यायावतारविवृति. Ratnaprabha had a commentary on the प्रमाणनयतत्त्वालोकालंकार called the स्याद्वादरत्नाकरवार्त्तिक. राजशेखर wrote the रत्नावतारिकापञ्जिका and the स्याद्वादकलिका.

c45.s1.30

It was really magnificent work that these Jaina savants accomplished for Indian philosophy. Their peculiar mode of thinking inclined them towards toleration and let them appreciate truth wherever they found it. For truth, according to the *Anekāntavādin*, is manysided. What is true under a certain set of conditions need not necessarily be true under others; and truth may sometimes be where we least expect it.

c45.s1.31

(c) *Brāhmaṇa philosophers.* We have mentioned above the names of some Brāhmaṇa philosophers. For the post-Haribhadra period, we have to add the names of Śaṅkaranandana, Kaṇāda, Akṣapāda, Vātsyāyana, Bhāradvāja, Uddyotakara, Vāchaspati, Vyomaśiva, Aniruddha, Śrīdhara, Vatsāchārya, Udayana, Jayanta and Harṣa. Śaṅkaranandana is perhaps the great *Advaitic* philosopher, Śaṅkara. From the rare references to him and his system of thought in Jaina literature, it appears that *Advaita* was not a popular subject with the Jainas, though in some ways it is nearer to the Jaina system of philosophy than even Buddhism. Their favourite subject of study was *Tarkaśāstra* or *Hetuvidyā*. In this field Devasūri criticized Udayana, who in his *Kusumāñjali* maintained a theory of creation radically opposed to that of the Jainas.²⁰ Udayana's *Kiraṇāvali* was studied by the Kharatara *āchārya* Jinavallabha as well as Pradyumna Sūri of the line of Vādideva Sūri. Jayanta's *Nyāyamañjarī*, an independent commentary on the *Nyāyasūtras* of Akṣapāda shares with Udayana's works the honour of being attacked by Vādī Deva Sūri. Kaṇāda was criticised by Nemichandra. Śrīkaṇṭha's *Nyāyakandalī* was commented on by Abhayatilakagaṇi (1257 A.D.) and Ratnaśekhara. The latter in his *Nyāyakandalīpañjikā* describes the views of Kaṇāda, Praśastakaradeva, Vyomaśivāchārya, Udayana and Vatsāchārya. The *Kharataragachchhapaṭṭāvali* refers to Śrīdhara's view on the nature of darkness. The young Kharatara *āchārya*, Jinachandra, had studied this subject and defeated Padmachandrāchārya of Rudrapallī in a debate about it. Copies of the *Nyāyakandalī* have been found in many Jaina *Bhaṇḍāras*. Vāmeśvaradhvaja's *Nyāyakusumāñjalisaṅketa*, though now little known, was also a work of no little merit. We have palm-leaf and paper manuscripts of the book in Rājasthān as well as Gujarāt²¹. Bhā-Sarvajña is represented by his *Nyāyasāra* and *Nyāyabhūṣaṇa*. The Vedāntic work, *Khaṇḍanakhaṇḍa-khādyaka* of Harṣa, probably reached Rājasthān before V. 1291. Its early popularity with the Jainas probably was due not so much to their agreement with Harṣa's philosophy as to his brilliant dialectics which made short work of most systems of philosophy. It was difficult to maintain any thesis against his destructive criticism. It was in the Jaina philosopher's own interest that he should be familiar with this new weapon in the armoury of Brāhmaṇa philosophers, and turn it, whenever possible, against his own opponents.

c45.s1.32

²⁰ The *Naiyāyikas* regard *Iśvara* as creator. The Jainas disbelieve and criticize this view. The Paṭṭan *Bhaṇḍāras* have a न्यायकुसुमाञ्जलिपरिमल by Divākara. (*Catalogue of the Mss. in Paṭṭan Bhaṇḍāras, Introduction*, p. 44.)

c45.s1.33

²¹ *Catalogue of the Paṭṭan Bhaṇḍāra Mss.* 1. pp. 103-04. The name संकेत is given in verse 2. We have seen old paper Mss. of the book at Bikāner.

c45.s1.34

(d) *Kāvyas and nāṭakas.* The *kāvyas* and *nāṭakas* studied by the Jainas of Rājasthāna can conveniently be classified under three heads : (1) Works produced by Jaina writers with a view to propagating their religious teachings, (2) Classical works of great masters like Kālidāsa, (3) Other works. We shall take them in this order.

c45.s1.35

(1) Of *Kāvyas* with a religious bias there are many, for the Jaina teachers cultivated the art of poetry not so for its own sake as to convey the message of the *Tīrthaṅkaras* to the people in a form that they could appreciate and assimilate. The versatile Haribhadra Sūri is said to have written the *Kathākośa*, the *Dhūrtākhyāna*, the *Munipaticharita*, the *Yaśodharacharita*, the *Vīrāṅgadakathā* and the *Samarāïchchakahā*. But of these only two, the *Dhūrtākhyāna* and the *Samarāïchchakahā* have been discovered so far. The *Dhūrtākhyāna* is a good satire on popular Hinduism. The *Samarāïchchakahā* is a Prakrit *gadya-kāvya* interspersed with verses. Its flowing style, easy prose, and absence of unnecessary ornamentation, coupled with an interesting narrative which drives home the Jaina lesson that a man suffers on account of his bad actions and can rise only by cultivating good virtues, has mnde it very popular with the Jaina writers of all ages and provinces.²² It was summarised into Sanskrit by Pradyumna Sūri in V. 1324 (1267 A.D.)

c45.s1.36

²² It is highly praised for instance, by Siddharṣi Sūri, Vādideva Sūri, Lakṣmaṇagaṇi, Malayagiri and Pradyumna Sūri.

c45.s1.37

Haribhadra was followed by his pupil, Dākṣiṇyāṅka Udyotana Sūri who completed his great *kathā*, the *Kuvalayamālā* at Jālor in 778 A.D., in the reign of Vatsarāja Pratīhāra.²³

c45.s1.38

²³ संवत्सरशतनवके द्विपष्टिसहितेऽतिलंघिते चास्याः। ज्येष्ठसितपञ्चम्यां पुनर्वसौ गुरुदिने समाप्तिरभूत् ॥

c45.s1.39

Its style is similar to that of the *Naladamayantīchampū* of Trivikrama and the language used is Prākrit, though the writer has given also a few descriptions in Apabhraṁśa and Paiśāchī. This *kathā* was summarised into Sanskrit by Ratnaprabha Sūri in the thirteenth century. Of the Jaina poets earlier than himself, Dākṣiṇṇyāka mentions Vimalāṅka, Raviṣeṇa, Devagupta, and Bhavaviraha.

c45.s1.40

Another great Jaina writer was Siddharṣi Sūri who completed his *Upamitibhavaprapañcha kathā* at Bhillamāla in V. 962. It is as much a work of philosophy as of poetry and is one of the finest allegories in any language. Written in simple and easily understandable Sanskrit (because the vain people of his time had come to think slightingly of Prakrit)²⁴ and with a narrative as interesting as any folk-tale, it appealed not only to scholars but also to the masses who cared probably more for the story than the allegory that underlay its structure. His *Niṣpuṇyaka* is an unimitable character. Siddharṣi's another literary creation was the *Chandrakevalicharita*. It was written in V. 974. To the same century belongs also the important Apabhraṁśa work, the *Bhaviṣayatta-kahā* of Dhanapāla. Slightly later than him was Maheśvara Sūri, who wrote his *Jñānapañchamīkahā* in Prakrit and the *Saṁyamamañjarīkāvya* in Apabhraṁśa. It is interesting to find here many old folk tales dressed out and presented in a Jaina garb.

c45.s1.41

²⁴ तत्रापि संस्कृतं तावद्दुर्विदग्धहृदि स्थिता । (उपमितिभवप्रपञ्चकथा)

c45.s1.42

Jaisalmer has a manuscript copy of Dhanapāla's *Tilakamañjarī*, dated V. 1130. This Dhanapāla, though originally hailing from the present Uttar Pradesh, passed most of his life at the court of the Paramāra rulers, Muñja and Bhoja of Dhārā. Some time after the Ghaznavite invasion of western India, he went to Satyapura and composed his Apabhraṁśa poem, *Satyapurīya Śrī Mahāvīra Utsāha* in praise of the Satyapura image of Mahāvīra. Earlier, probably at Dhārā, he had written the *Ṛṣabhapañchāśikā* and the *Mahāvīrastava*. Of the earlier Jaina poets referred to by him, we have already said a few words about Haribhadra Sūri. Pādalipta was the author of the Prākrit poem, *Taraṅgavatī*, the language of which had by Nemichandra’s time become so archaic; that he had to summarise it into 1900 *gāthās* of a simpler style. I have been unable to find anything about Jivadeva Sūri, the predecessor of Dhanapāla. Bappabhaṭṭi, the author of the *Tārāgaṇa*, a poem no longer extant, was perhaps the friend and spiritual guide of Āma (Nāgāvaloka or Nāgabhaṭa II)²⁵. Mahendra Sūri was Dhanapāla’s *guru*.²⁶

c45.s1.43

²⁵ See our “Studies in the प्रभावकचरित” *JA*, 1937.

c45.s1.44

²⁶ The work of the following Jaina scholars also deserves notice : Vardhamāna Sūri (died 1021 A.D.) wrote the उपमितिभवप्रपञ्चा-समय. His disciple, Jineśvara Sūri, the founder of the Kharataragachchha, added to Jaina literature the निर्वाणलीलावती, वीरचरित्र and कथाकोष. *Nirvāṇalīlāvatī* is no longer available. But we have its summary in Sanskrit by जिनरत्ननाचार्य. Jineśvara's disciple, Jinachandra, wrote the *Saṁvegaraṅgaśālā*, a manuscript of which exists at Jaisalmer. The work appears to have been very popular, for it is referred to in more than one epigraph and many books. His co-disciple जिनभद्र wrote the सुरसुन्दरी-कथा. At the suggestion of Prasannachandra, a disciple of *Navāṅgavṛttikāra* Abhayadeva, Guṇachandra composed in Prakrit a poem called *Mahāvīrachariam*. It has eight *prastāvas* and its extent is 12,000 *ślokas*. देवभद्रसूरि wrote the पार्श्वनाथचरित in V. 1168. Vardhamānāchārya composed the Prākrit *Ādināthacharita* in five *avasaras*, using Apabhraṁśa also here and there. His *Manoramācharita* was written in V. 1140. Pūrṇabhadragaṇi, a disciple of Jinapati Sūri, wrote the अतिमुक्तचरित्र. His धन्याशालिभद्र-चरित्र was written at Jaisalmer in V. 1285. Lakṣmītilaka, a disciple of the Kharatara *Achārya*, Jineśvara Sūri, finished his प्रत्येकबुद्ध-चरित in V. 1311. Then, in addition to these works of Kharatara scholars, from Vardhamāna to Lakṣmītilaka, we have at Jaisalmer many others (of the period 900-1300 A.D.), written not by *Kharataras* but followers of other *gachchhas*. Of these some were certainly studied in Rājasthān : in the case of others there is a strong probability, though absolute proof is lacking. We mention below some of them.

c45.s1.45

Śīlāchārya wrote the *Chauppanna-mahāpuruṣachariam* in V. 925. It has a *praśasti* of 48 verses presented to the Kharatara Jinabhadra which indicates its popularity among the Kharataras. *Śālibhadracharitra* (Prakrit) was copied out in V. 1222. The *Vilāsavatikathā*, an Apabhraṁśa work by Sādhāraṇa (V. 1123) is based on the *Samarāichchakahā* of Haribhadra Sūri. Devachandra Sūri wrote the *Śāntināthacharita* in V. 1160. Its extent is 12000 *ślokas* and the language is Prakrit. *Pṛthvīchandracharita* of Śānti Sūri was written in V. 1161. Yaśodeva Upādhyāya wrote the *Chandraprabhacharita* in V. 1178. Nine years later, came the *Narmadāsundarikathā* of Mahendra Sūri, in V. 1216 the *Nemināthacharita* of Haribhadra Sūri, in 1216 the *Munisuvratacharita* of Padmaprabha Sūri, and in V. 1322 the *Śāntināthacharita* of Munideva.

c45.s1.46

Hemachandra’s poetical works probably reached Rājasthān during his life time. They include the *Dvyāśrayamahākāvya*, *Kumārapālacharita* (Prakrit) *Triṣaṣṭiśalākāpuruṣacharita* and a number of hymns. The Sanskrit *Dvyāśraya* was commented on by Abhayatilaka (V. 1312), a pupil of the Kharatara Lakṣmītilaka, who is known to have revised his co-disciple Pūrṇakalaśa’s commentary on the *Kumārapālacharita* (V. 1307). Hemachandra’s one disciple, Devachandra, wrote the play, the *Chandralekhā-vijaya*, and the other, Ramachandra, wrote a large number of poems and plays.²⁷ To Udayasiṁha’s reign belongs also the *Prabuddharauhiṇeya*, a play in six acts by another Rāmchandra, a pupil of Jayaprabha Sūri. The *Hammīramadamardana* of Jayasiṁha Sūri, a manuscript of which, dated V. 1286, has been found at Jaisalmer, has been very often referred to and utilised in this book.

c45.s1.47

²⁷ The best known of these are (1) (1) राघवाभ्युदय, (3) (4)रघुविलास,(5) कुमारविहारशतक, (6) नलविलास, (7) सत्यहरिश्चन्द्र, (8)कौमुदीमित्रानन्द, (9)मल्लिकामकरन्द, (10) रोहिणमृगाङ्क, (11)वनभाला and निर्भयभीम Of the last of these, there is a manuscript V. 1306) written in the reign of *Mahārājakula* Udayasiṁha of Jālor. Rāmachandra’s literary achievement was great enough : but even greater was his pride in it.

c45.s1.48

(2) *Classical works.* Along with the *Kāvyas* written by Jaina authors, the Jaina community continued studying the works of great poets like Kālidāsa. Sumatigaṇi mentions his *Meghadūta*. Āsaḍa commented on it. The high regard in which the poet was held is shown also by the following verse quoted by Jinapāla²⁸.

c45.s1.49

²⁸ “Kālidāsa etc. are poets; so are we. The property of being material objects belongs to mountains and molecules alike.” (Comment on the 5th verse of the *Charchari*).

c45.s1.50

कवयः कालिदासाद्याः कवयो वयमप्यमी ।
पर्वते परमाणौ च वस्तुत्वमुभयोरपि ॥

c45.s1.51

Bhāravi, the writer of the *Kirātārjunīya* was well-known. Vinayachandra calls him *Chhatra-Bhāravi* and counts him among writers of *sadgranthas*.²⁹ Jaisalmer has a palm leaf manuscript of a commentary on the *Kirātārjunīya* by Prakāśavarṣa Kāśmīraka.³⁰ But by the twelfth century, Bhāravi’s fame had been eclipsed by that of Māgha, the great Rājasthānī poet from Bhillamāla. Jinapāla quotes the following well-known verse about Māgha³¹:—

c45.s1.52

²⁹ *Paṭṭan Catalogue of Mss.* (G.O.S.), p. 49.

c45.s1.53

³⁰ *Jaisalmer Catalogue of Palm-leaf Mss.* p. 55.

c45.s1.54

³¹ “With their zeal (for poesy) impeded by Māgha, poets compose not a single line. They think only of (the poet) Bhāravi, acting thus like monkeys who with their agility gone on the onset of (the cold month) of Māgha, have no desire to stir even a step. They think only of the Sun.” Comment on the 4th verse of the *Charchari*.

c45.s1.55

माघेन विघ्नितोत्साहा नोत्सहन्ते पदक्रमे ।
स्मरन्ति भारवेरेव कवयः कपयो यथा ॥

c45.s1.56

Vinayachandra mentions the poet’s famous designation *Ghaṇṭā-Māgha*. Pradyumnāchārya was proud of having studied the *Māgha-mahākāvya*. Jaisalmer has a copy of Bhaṭṭi’s *Rāmakāvya*. We find it quoted also in some of the books on poetics produced in Gujarāt. But much more popular than Bhaṭṭi, however, was the great stylist, Harṣa, the author of the *Naiṣadhīyakāvya* a copy of which was brought by the Kharatara Saṅgha of Jaisalmer in V. 1378, at the advice of Jinakuśala Sūri. Jaisalmer has also copies of a very old commentary on it, the *Sāhityavidyādharī*. The poem reached Gujarāt in Vastupāla’s time, and very soon became popular among Jainas as well as non-Jainas.³² It may have reached Rājasthān from there.

c45.s1.57

³² *Prabandhakośa*, p. 60 (Singhi Granthamālā) where we get the story of its being slyly copied out by Vastupāla from Harihara’s manuscript.

c45.s1.58

Of Prakrit poets, Vākpatirāja, the author of the *Gauḍavaho*, perhaps, attained the greatest celebrity in western India. Here is Vākpati’s wife’s opinion, as reported by Jinapāla:³³

c45.s1.59

³³ “We know not the future poets; our salutations to those who are no more. But of the present poets there is none who equals my husband” (Comment on the 6th verse of the *Charcharī*).

c45.s1.60

होहिंति केचि जे ते न याणिमो, जे गया नमो ताण ।
संपइ इह जे कविणो ते मह पइणो न सारिच्छा ॥

c45.s1.61

Jaisalmer has a palm-leaf manuscript of the *Gauḍavadhasāraṭīkā*. Copies of the work at Paṭṭan, and the story of his friendship with the Jaina scholar and teacher, Bappabhaṭṭi Sūri, in works like the *Prabhāvakacharita* also indicates his popularity in the Jaina world.³⁴

c45.s1.62

³⁴ See the *Bappabhaṭṭisūricharita* of the *Prabhāvakacharita*, where Vākpatirāja is depicted as a Vaiṣṇava and friend of Bappabhaṭṭasūri.

c45.s1.63

Dhanapāla offers his homage among others to Vyāsa, Vālmīki, Guṇāḍhya, Pravarasena, Rājaśekhara, Rudra, Kardamarāja, Bāṇa and Bhavabhūti. From Haribhadra we get the names of Harṣa and Subandhu. Additional names from the *Kuvalayamālā* are Sātavāhana, Śataparṇaka, and Prabhañjana. It is therefore obvious that most of the non-Jaina Sanskrit and Prakrit literature was studied by the Jaina *literati*; (a fact proved also by the facility with which they quote these authors in their books on rhetorics)³⁵, though possibly not to the same extent by the people in general who, as now, may have remained satisfied with elementary reading, writing and arithmetic.³⁶

c45.s1.64

³⁵ See for instance the नाट्यदर्पण of Rāmachandra and Guṇachandra which brings to light many unknown works.

c45.s1.65

³⁶ Vyāsa and Vālmīki, the authors of the *Mahābhārata* and the *Rāmāyaṇa* are well known. Guṇāḍhya wrote the *Bṛhatakathā* and in Dhanapāla's time was regarded as a contemporary of Sātavāhana. Pravarasena is the writer of the Prakrit poem, *Setubandha* or *Rāvaṇavadha*, and Rājaśekhara, of the *Bālarāmāyaṇa*, *Bālabhārata*, *Karpūramañjarī*, the *Viddhaśālabhañjikā*, and the *Kāvyamīmāṁsā*, the last of which is known to have been utilised by Hemachandra Nemikumāra's son Vāgbhaṭa, Amarachandra and Vinayachandra. Kardamarāja is praised as the creator of 'jewel-like nice sayings', Prabhañjana may be Prābhañjana or Hanumān, the reputed author of the *Hanumannāṭaka*. Mayūra (not enumerated in the last paragraph) is mentioned by Jinapāla. Vinayachandra mentions Bhoja as a great writer. It is not unlikely that many of his works also may have reached Rājasthān, though the only one found at Jaisalmer is a *Kathā*, the शृङ्गारमञ्जरी. The Jaisalmer Catalogue lists also मधुवर्णनम् and विरहिणीप्रलापम्, the works of an otherwise unknown poet named कलि. Other poems known to us from Jaisalmer are Bilhaṇa's विक्रमाङ्कदेवचरित; वृन्दावनयमक; मेघाभ्युदय of मानाङ्क; राक्षसकाव्य; घटखर्परकाव्य; and चक्रपाणिविजय of Lakṣmīdhara. Jinapati Sūri's rival, Pradyumnāchārya, studied the *Kādambarī*. Even his other rival, the much-ridiculed Padmaprabha, knew the work and accused Jinapati Sūri of plagiarizing it. Quotations from both the *Kādambarī* and the *Harṣacharita* abound in Jaina books on rhetorics. Subandhu is represented by a palm leaf Ms. of his वासवदत्ता, V. 1207, in the Jaina *Bhāṇḍāras* of Jaisalmer. The शृङ्गारमञ्जरी of Bhoja, listed above, is also a romance. The त्रैलोक्यमञ्जरी of Rudra, mentioned by Dhanapāla, may have been in prose. The लीलावतीकथा of कौतूहल (?), a son of भट्टभूषण and grandson of Bahalāditya, is in Prakrit verse and can according to Sri Lalchandra Bhagwandās Gāndhi, vie with the *Kādambarī* in poetic beauty. It is obvious from its palm leaf Ms. of V. 1265 that it was written in the twelfth century or even earlier.

c45.s1.66

Jinavallabha is said to have studied eighty four dramas.³⁷ This obviously means that he had read most dramas, Jaina as well as non-Jaina. How comprehensive the study of some of the Jaina writers could be can be seen also from the *Nāṭyadarpaṇa* of Rāmachandra and Guṇachandra who quote from fifty-five dramas, some of them, now no longer extant.

c45.s1.67

³⁷ Introduction to अपभ्रंशकाव्यत्रयी, p. 20.

c45.s1.68

In this age, when form predominated over sense, Murāri appears to have been specially popular. Jaisalmer has a palm-leaf manuscript of Narachandra's commentary on Murāri's *Anargharāghava*. Narachandra's *guru*, Devaprabha, wrote about it.

c45.s1.69

एकैकेन पदेन यस्य विदुषामन्तः सुधासारणि-
व्युत्पत्तिं वहता परां श्रवणयोरल्पप्रबन्धस्पृहा ।
सध्रीचीरमृतस्य यस्य भणितीर्वैदग्ध्यसंवर्मिताः
श्रुत्वा हर्षजुषो विलोचनयुगे यस्याः पयोबिन्दवः ॥³⁸

c45.s1.70

³⁸ *Catalogue of the Palm leaf Mss. in the Paṭṭana Bhaṇḍāras*, p. 301.

c45.s1.71

Murāri perhaps never received any higher praise. Another Jaina scholar, Pradyumnāchārya, when speaking of his studies of dramas, mentions *Murāri-nāṭaka* only, *i.e.*, *Anargharāghava*. Narachandra's pupil, Narendraprabha, on the other hand, exemplifies dramas by saying नाट्येषु-अभिज्ञानशाकुन्तलादिषु, showing thereby that Kālidāsa could not be forgotten even in this age of artificiality.³⁹

c45.s1.72

³⁹ Narendraprabha also says, काव्येषु रघुवंशादिषु.

c45.s1.73

(3) *Minor Poets*. The Rājasthānīs must have studied also the works of many other poets, now no longer extant. It was not every *kāvya* that received encouragement at the hands of Jaina teachers. They banned in temples the performance of popular plays like those dealing with the life of Rāma and Rāvaṇa, presenting only those dramas which induced people either to lead a religious life or to renounce the world.⁴⁰ This policy though not followed consistently, has led, we fear, to the extinction of many popular poems which otherwise would have been preserved in the Jaina *Bhaṇḍāras*. So all that we have now besides a few nice poems like the *Bharata-Bāhubali-ghora*, the *Gajasukumāra-rāsa*, *Neminātha-rāsa* and the *Bharateśvara-Bāhubali-rāsa* are a large number of short pieces, commemorating either the

c45.s1.74

⁴⁰ *Cf.* the following statement from the उपदेशरसायनरास of

c45.s1.75

श्रीजिनदत्तसूरि:—
धम्मिंय नाइय वर नच्चिज्जहि, भरह-सगरनिक्खमण कहिज्जहि ।
चक्कवट्टि-बल-रायहु चरियइँ, नच्चिवि ग्रन्ति हुंति पव्वइयईँ ॥ ३६॥
(अपभ्रंशकाव्यत्रयी), p. 47.

c45.s1.76

initiation or death of *Jaina-gurus*⁴¹ which appeal more to the religious-minded Jaina votary than to lovers of good poetry.

c45.s1.77

⁴¹ For a collection of these see the ऐतिहासिक काव्यसंग्रह edited by Sri Agarchand Nahta and Bhanwarlala Nahta.

c45.s1.78

(*e*) *Metrics*. On metrics the Rājasthānīs studied a number of good books. Specially popular was the *Jayadeva-chhandas*, a book in eight chapters, which is known to have been studied and taught by Jinavallabha, and is mentioned by Jinapāla in the *Kharataragachcha-paṭṭāvalī*. Jaisalmer has a manuscript not only of its text, but also a commentary on it by Harṣaṭa, son of Bhaṭṭa Mukula. The *Kaisiṭṭha* of Haribhadra was commented on by Gopāla. To V. 1192, belongs a manuscript of Jayakīrti's *Chhandonuśāsana* which is said to have been composed after consulting the works of Māṇḍavya, Piṅgala, Janāśraya, Setava, Pūjyapāda and Jayadeva. The *Chhandonuśāsana* may be presumed to have become known in Rājasthān along with his other works in the second half of the twelfth century.

c45.s1.79

(*f*) *Alaṅkāraśāstra* (Poetics). Specially popular with the Jainas was the study of Poetics. The *Gaṇadharasārdhaśatakabṛhadvṛtti* speaks of Jinavallabha's study of the *alaṅkāraśāstras* of Rudraṭa, Udbhaṭa, Daṇḍin, Vāmana and Bhāmaha. Pradyumnāchārya studied the *Kāvyaprakāṣa* of Mammaṭa. The Popularity of Rudraṭa's *Kāvyālaṅkāra* among the Jainas is shown by the commentaries of Namisādhu and Āśādhara. Udbhaṭa is represented at Jaisalmer by two manuscripts of *Udbhaṭālaṅkāravṛtti*. Daṇḍin's *Kāvyādarśa* has a commentary, the *Hṛdayaṅgamā*, the palm-leaf manuscript of which was written in V. 1161. Vāmana, Rājaśekhara, Kuntaka, Halāyudha and Hemachandra are also represented by the manuscripts of their works at Jaisalmer.

c45.s1.80

How fond the Jainas were of *Alaṅkāras* and expert in their use can be seen from Jinapāla's *Kharataragachchhapaṭṭāvalī* and the commentary on the *Charcharī*. In the latter he extols Jinavallabha for his proficiency in *chitrakāvyas*. It is ridiculous, he says, to think highly of poets who knew only *chakra* and *muśala bandhas*. Jinavallabha was proficient in the use of *Khaḍga*, *Saptachakrikā*, *Gaja* and *Gomūtrikā-bandhas*. He could complete verses (समस्यापूर्ति) by either composing the remaining quarters or supplying the missing verbs. Nor was Jinapati Sūri's proficiency any less. If Jinavallabha pleased Naravarman of Mālwā by his *samasyāpūrti*, Jinapati gladdened the hearts of the *paṇḍits* in Pṛthvīrāja's court, not only by completing verses but by passing a stiff test in *Alaṅkāra-śāstra*. His description of Pṛthvīrāja III's court is excellent. The verse that he presented in *chhatra-bandha* to the ruler makes good sense. He challenged Padmaprabha to vie with him in the use of Prakrit, Sanskrit, Māgadhī, Paiśāchī and Śaurasenī languages; he proved also his mastery of grammar, metrics, poetics, *rasa*, drama, logic, *jyotiṣa* (astrology and astronomy) and Jaina *siddhānta*. He asked his rival to question him about any difficult verse that needed explanation, or to put before him a verse that lacked some root or noun, a question or an answer, or something without which it could not give any sense. He could give the needed verse, even if there were no vowels or consonants; he could restore to their true order the letters of a verse that he heard once. He knew about the musical *rāgas* and could compose to order a song in any *rāga* sung before him. These achievements seem wonderful, but that a good scholar was expected to have them can be seen from the various *kaviśikṣās* of the period as well as the *Śārṅgadharapaddhati*, which is full of verses and exercises of this type. For a poet mere *pratibhā* (genius) was not enough, he was also to have *vyutpatti* and *abhyāsa*. *Abhyāsa* (practice) was to be under the direction of a poet. *Vyutpatti* resulted from the study of various arts, sciences, and scriptures.⁴²

c45.s1.81

⁴² लोके शब्दादिशास्त्रेषु काव्यनाट्यकथासु च ।

c45.s1.82

(*g*) *Grammar*. Knowledge of grammer was considered essential. An old verse quoted by Jinapāla states that one who attempts the study of the other *śāstras* without first studying grammar, verily tries to count the steps of a snake that had long ago slipped into water in the drakness of the night.⁴³ Buddhisāgara was the first Śvetāmbara teacher to write a comprehensive Sanskrit and Prākrit grammar, the *Pañchagranthī*.⁴⁴

c45.s1.83

⁴³ *Apabhraṁśakāvyatrayī*, p. 3.

c45.s1.84

⁴⁴ *Catalogue of Mss. in the Jaisalmer Bhaṇḍāras*, p. 20. The reason for its composition is given thus by जिनेश्वरसूरि:—

c45.s1.85

आगमादिषु च प्रौढिर्व्युत्पत्तिरिति कथ्यते ॥८॥(अलङ्कारमहोदधि G.O.S.)

c45.s1.86

तैरवधीरिरते यत्तु प्रवृत्तिरावयोरिह ।
तत्र दुर्जनवाक्यानि प्रवृत्तेःसन्निबन्धनम् ॥
कीदृशानि दुर्जनवाक्यानींत्याह—
श्रीबुद्धिसागराचार्यैर्वृत्तैर्व्याकरणं कृतम् ।
अस्माभिस्तु प्रमालक्ष्म बुद्धिमायातु साम्प्रतम् ॥

c45.s1.87

It was composed at Jālor in V. 1080, after consulting the works of Pāṇini, Chandra, Jinendra, Viśrānta, and Durga. Instead of being in the usual *sūtra* form, it was in verse, and as a grammar, thus stands in a class by itself. Kumārapāla's *guru*, Hemachandra, was another great grammarian. Pradyumnāchārya of Āśāvalli studied his *Vyākaraṇa*.⁴⁵ A copy of Hemachandra's *Laghuvṛtti*, copied as early as V. 1206, has been found at Jaisalmer.⁴⁶

c45.s1.88

⁴⁵ *Kharataragachchhapaṭṭāvali* of Jinapāla.

c45.s1.89

⁴⁶ *Jaina pustaka-praśastisaṅgraha* (Singhi Jaina Granthamālā), p. 105.

c45.s1.90

Pāṇini, Patañjali, and Bhartṛhari were known to Haribhadra Sūri as great grammarians, a fact that proves the popularity of the Pāṇinean system in the beginning of our period. This popularity continued, though in a lesser degree, after the composition of newer grammars like the *Sarasvatīkaṇṭhābharaṇa* and the *Siddha-Haima*. Jinavallabha studied eight grammatical systems,⁴⁷ of which the only one named, however, is that of Pāṇini.

c45.s1.91

⁴⁷ The Jaisalmer *Bhaṇḍāras* have manuscripts of कातन्त्रोत्तरम् (विद्यानन्दम्), कातन्त्रपञ्जिका of त्रिलोचनदास, कातन्त्रदुर्गपदप्रबोधम् of प्रबोधमूर्ति and कातन्त्र-विभ्रमटीका of जिनप्रभसूरि ।

c45.s1.92

(*h*) *Lexicography and other subjects.* Closely connected with grammar is lexicography.⁴⁸ Of the many lexicographical works at Jaisalmer, the *Śabdaratnapradīpa* has been mentioned more than once by Sumatigaṇi (V. 1295). It must therefore be regarded as an old lexicon. The *Apavarganāmamālā* was probably composed about 1150 A.D., as its compiler, Jinabhadra, was a contemporary of Jinavallabha and Jinadatta Sūri. Hemachandra's lexicons were well known. Of these, the *Anekārthasaṅgraha* has a commentary by Mahendra Sūri.

c45.s1.93

⁴⁸ The Jaisalmer *Bhaṇḍārs* have Mss. of शब्दरत्नप्रदीप, लिङ्गानुशासनविवरण of हेमचन्द्र, अनेकार्थकैरवकौमुदी of महेन्द्रसूरि, अपवर्गनाममाला of जिनभद्र, एकाक्षरनाममालिका of विश्वशम्भु, and अभिधानचिन्तामणिटीका.

c45.s1.94

The *Śārṅgadharapaddhati* has sections on *Rājanīti*, elephants, horses, military science, music, herbs and plants, omens, *svarodaya*, antidotes of poisons, *kautukas*, *bhūtavidyā*, *yoga* and *kalpasthāna*. The *Prabhāvakacharita* mentions seventy-two arts and sciences learnt by Prince Āma (Nāgāvaloka)⁴⁹. A shorter and more authentic list is to be found in the *Upamitibhavaprapañchakathā* of Siddharṣi Sūri according to which the subjects learnt by princes Ripudāraṇa and Nandivardhana were all scripts, mathematics, grammar, astrology, astronomy, prosody, dancing, cutting patterns, *indrajāla*, military science, medical science, logic, and characteristics of people.⁵⁰

c45.s1.95

⁴⁹ P. 152 (Nirṇayasāgar Edition)

c45.s1.96

⁵⁰ *Prastāva* 3, chapter 1; *Prastāva* 4 chapter 2. Siddharṣi's opinion on ज्योतिष and निमित्तशास्त्र is worth quoting. He writes, 'Astrology, निमित्तशास्त्र and similar other subjects, the results of which lie beyond human ken, were first taught by सर्वज्ञ. If the prediction goes wrong, it is the professor of the science who is to blame and not the science itself. People have only a limited knowledge of them. They do not know their sub-divisions.'

c45.s1.97

*Additional subjects studied by non-Jainas.* The non-Jainas naturally studied a few subjects, much more than the Jainas and Buddhists. The study of the Vedas continued as before in centres like Bhīnamāla which produced the great Brāhmaṇa poet and scholar, Māgha. Even now the Śrīmālī Brāhmaṇas hold a special position in Rājasthān, not on account of their learning, but the reputation that their ancestors must have built up during our period. According to Padmanābha's opinion Bhillamāla had 45,000 Brāhmaṇas. They knew the four *Vedas*, the six *aṅgas*, the eight grammatical systems, fourteen *vidyās*, eighteen *Purāṇas*, *Āyurveda*, Bharata- (*Nāṭyaśāstra*), *jyotiṣa*, *Piṅgala* (metrics), *Bāji* (*aśvaśāstra*) and *nāṭaka*. In every house was a *yajñaśālā* and *agnihotra*. They knew the secrets of the *smṛtis* and performed the six *karmans*. They daily performed sacrifices, offering duly apportioned shares to the gods, beginning with Indra⁵¹. Alberūnī knew Bhillamāla as the home of the astronomer, Brahmagupta.⁵² The *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* speaks of the *yajñas* at Ajmer, which again proves the continuity of the Vedic tradition among the Brāhmaṇas.

c45.s1.98

⁵¹ कान्हडदेप्रबन्ध (राजस्थान पुरातत्त्व मन्दिर) II, vv. 22-27.

c45.s1.99

⁵² Sachau, *Alberuni's India* I, 267.

c45.s1.100

Similarly, in the *Pāśupata* monasteries like Harṣa and Ekaliṅga the study and practice of this *Pāśupata* doctrines must have been given the first place. As to secular subjects, they were the same for the Jainas and non-Jainas. They all loved good literature; and if the number of times, a poet is quoted be any index of his popularity among the people, the poets most studied in Śārṅgadhara's time were Kālidāsa, Māgha, Trivikrama,⁵³ Bhartṛhari, Jayadeva, Kṣemendra,⁵⁴ Daṇḍin and Bāṇa. Next in order followed Dhanadeva Murāri, Rājaśekhara, Bhavabhūti, Deveśvara, Dāmodaradeva, Harihara, Harṣa, Jayamādhava, Bhallaṭa, Kṛṣṇamiśra, Bhānu, Harigaṇa, Mayūra, Rāghavachaitanya, Nārāyaṇabhaṭṭa, Lakṣmīdhara, Gauḍa Abhinanda, Chandradeva and Bhāsa. Vigraharāja's *praśasti* on the Delhi Aśokan pillar has been quoted by Śārṅgadhara, though the pillar has been wrongly described as a sacrificial post erected by Nṛga. Of women poets Śārṅgadhara notes Vijjikā, Śīlābhaṭṭārikā, Vikaṭanitambā, Phalgustanī, and Padmaśrī. If all this literature was being studied in Rājasthān, there can hardly be any doubt of the fact that Rājasthānīs then knew and studied Sanskrit more than they do at present.

c45.s1.101

⁵³ Author of the *Naladamayantī-Champū*.

c45.s1.102

⁵⁴ Author of the बृहत्कथामञ्जरी, नर्ममाला, औचित्यविचारचर्चा etc.

c45.s1.103

SECTION II

Cites (123)