Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Origin and Development of the Bengali Language v1: Volume 1

The Origin and Development of the Bengali Language v1

Language
English

Contents

Volume 1

Front matter

v1.c1.1

THE ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE BENGALI LANGUAGE

v1.c1.2

The page provided is blank.

v1.c1.3

THE ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE BENGALI LANGUAGE

v1.c1.4

BY SUNITI KUMAR CHATTERJI M.A. (Calcutta), D.Lit. (London) Khaira Professor of Indian Linguistics and Phonetics and Lecturer in English and Comparative Philology in the University of Calcutta

v1.c1.5

With a Foreword by SIR GEORGE ABRAHAM GRIERSON, K.C.I.E.

v1.c1.6

In Two Parts Part I : Introduction, Phonology

v1.c1.7

University of Calcutta seal

v1.c1.8

CALCUTTA UNIVERSITY PRESS

v1.c1.9

PRINTED BY BHUPENDRALAL BANERJEE AT THE CALCUTTA UNIVERSITY PRESS, SENATE HOUSE, CALCUTTA

Foreword

v1.c2.1

It gives me great pleasure to have this opportunity of publicly wishing God-speed to Professor Chatterji’s admirable work and of recommending it to all students of the modern languages of India.

v1.c2.2

There are two possible lines of investigation of this subject. In one, we can follow the example of Beames and view all the forms of speech as a whole, comparing them with each other, and thence deducing general rules. The other is to follow Trumpp, Hoernle, and Bloch, in taking one particular language as our text, examining it exhaustively, and comparing it with what is known of the others. Professor Chatterji, in taking Bengali as the basis of his work, has adopted the latter procedure and, if I may express my own opinion, the more profitable one. The ultimate object of all students must, of course, be to follow the lines so excellently laid down by Beames, and to give a general comparative grammar of the Indo-Aryan languages; but such an attempt,—admirable though Beames’s work was,—cannot be really successful till each of the different languages has been separately and minutely dissected under the strictest scientific rules. The palace of comparative grammar cannot be built without bricks, and the bricks are made up of the facts of each particular language.

v1.c2.3

For many reasons, Bengali, in itself, is specially deserving of careful study. With a literature going back for several centuries, and preserved

v1.c2.5

with some care, it gives opportunities for the study of its history that are wanting in some other forms of Indian speech. It is a typical descendant of the great language that, under the name of Māgadhī Prakrit, was the vernacular of eastern North India for many centuries. This was the official language of the great Emperor Aśoka, and an allied dialect was used by the Buddha and by Mahāvīra, the apostle of Jainism, in their early preaching. With the shifting of political gravity at a later epoch, it became superseded as a literary form of speech by dialects current farther to the West, but as a spoken language it has developed into the modern Bengali, Oṛiyā, Bihārī, and Assamese.

v1.c2.6

Hitherto the ordinary Bengali grammars have been silent about the history of the language and the origin of its forms, and in popular books published in India, the wildest theories about these have occasionally been put forth without a shadow of justification. On the other hand, Beames, Hoernle, and Bhandarkar have written much that is illuminating in regard to it, but sufficient materials were not available to any of them for dealing with the many points of phonetics, accidence, and vocabulary that present themselves on closer examination. For this reason we can heartily welcome the ripe fruits of Professor Chatterji's labours that are to be gathered from the following pages. Endowed with a thorough familiarity with Bengali,—his native tongue,—he has been able to bring together an amount of material which no European could ever have hoped to collect; and he has had the further advantage of pursuing his theoretical studies under the guidance of some of the greatest European authorities on Indian philology. This work is accordingly the result of a happy combination of proficiency in facts and of familiarity with theory and exhibits a mastery of detail controlled and ordered by the sobriety of true scholarship.

v1.c2.7

In a work of this kind, necessarily offering conclusions here and there on points which in the present state of our linguistic knowledge cannot be decided with absolute certainty, it is not to be expected that all scholars will agree with every statement contained in it; and, as regards myself, I must confess that he has not convinced me that I am wrong in one or two matters in which he has lucidly expressed his disagreement. But, unless we searchers after knowledge sometimes differed, learning would not progress, and there would be the less chance of arriving at the ultimate truth. I therefore welcome his criticisms, and if his arguments, on further consideration, prove that he is right, I shall be among the first to congratulate him. These points are, however, of minor importance, and in no way affect the main thesis of his book,—to give a clear and accurate account of the origins and growth of the Bengali language. In this respect, every one who reads it will admit that the author has succeeded and that his volume is a fine example of wide knowledge, and of scholarly research.

v1.c2.8

RATHFARNHAM, CAMBERLEY (SURREY), OCTOBER, 1925.

v1.c2.9

GEORGE A. GRIERSON.

v1.c2.10

[The page is blank.]

v1.c2.11

idáṁ náma ṛṣibhyaḥ pūrvajébhyaḥ pūrvébhyaḥ pathikṛdbhiaḥ

v1.c2.12

āvīr āvīr ma ēdhi

v1.c2.13

utá tvaḥ páśyan ná dadarśa vácam utá tvaḥ śṛṇván ná śṛṇōti ēnām utó tuasmāi tanúam ví sasrē jāyéva pátyē uśatí suvásāḥ

Preface

v1.c3.1

In 1921 the University of London accepted my thesis on ‘the Origin and Development of the Bengali Language’ for the degree of ‘Doctor of Literature.’ The present work is substantially the same thesis, but it has been entirely re-written and in some portions re-arranged, and has also been considerably augmented by the inclusion of some new matter.

v1.c3.2

The idea of systematically investigating the history of my mother-tongue first struck me over twelve years ago when I was at college in my native town of Calcutta reading for the Master of Arts examination in English with Old and Middle English and History of the English Language and a little Germanic Philology as my special subjects. The modern methods of linguistic investigation which I saw applied to English filled me with admiration and enthusiasm; and as the problem of Indo-European is equally connected with my own speech, my interests naturally began to turn wistfully in that direction. From Morris and Skeat, Sweet and Wright, and Jespersen and the rest, and from Helfenstein and Brugmann,—masters of Indo-Aryan philology like Uhlenbeck and Wackernagel, Whitney and Pischel, Beames and Bhandarkar, Hoernle and Grierson and others were naturally approached and studied for guidance and light: and I began also to look round myself, to observe facts in the words as written and as actually spoken. A few years of haphazard reading and observation, and taking notes, and stumbling on in this way, while working as Assistant Professor and Lecturer in English and in Comparative Philology in the University of Calcutta; and then in 1916 I presented as a three years’ research programme for the Premchand Roychand Studentship of the Calcutta University a scheme for ‘an Essay towards an Historical and Comparative Grammar of the Bengali Language,' with a specimen of my work embodied in a thesis on 'the Sounds of Modern Bengali' as a preliminary to the investigation of Bengali Phonology. My programme and my thesis were approved by the adjudicators, the late Principal Rāmēndra Sundara Trivēdi and Mahāmahōpādhyāya Paṇḍit Haraprasāda Sāstri, M.A., C.I.E. For the University Jubilee Research Prize for the following year the subject was announced as 'Comparative Philology with special reference to the Bengali Dialects,' and this allowed me an opportunity to put into shape my notes on the dialects of Bengali, while winning me the prize. The three years' work as Premchand Roychand student consisted of a monograph on the Persian element in Bengali, a study of the Bengali verb and verb-roots, and a study of the language of the Old Bengali Caryā poems, combined with further notes on Bengali Phonetics.

v1.c3.3

In 1919 I was selected for a Government of India linguistic scholarship for the scientific study of Sanskrit in Europe. My three years' stay in Europe, during 1919-1922, at the Universities of London and Paris, has naturally enough been of the greatest value for me in my work. It enabled me to come in touch in London with scholars like Dr. L. D. Barnett, with whom I read Prakrit, and who supervised my work in London; Dr. F. W. Thomas, who as lecturer in Comparative Philology at University College guided me in my study of Indo-European Philology; Professor Daniel Jones, under whom I studied Phonetics, who was not only my « śikṣā-guru » but also a warm friend and helper; besides Sir E. Denison Ross, Director of the School of Oriental Studies, and most sympathetic of men, and Professor R. W. Chambers (of University College), and Messrs. E. H. G. Grattan and Robin Flower (also of University College), whose classes respectively in Persian, Old English, Gothic and Old Irish I attended; and in Paris, I had the privilege of sitting at the feet of a master like Professor Antoine Meillet for different branches of Indo-European linguistics, and of studying Sanskrit and other Indo-Aryan philology under Professor Jules Bloch, besides meeting other eminent scholars like Professors Sylvain Lévi, Paul Pelliot and Jean

v1.c3.4

Przyluski. While I was in England Sir George Grierson took a personal interest in my work, an interest which manifested itself in many ways and which he in his kindness and his love of science still retains. This has benefited me to the greatest degree imaginable; and the fellowship of common studies with this *doyen* of Indo-Aryan Linguistics which it has been my very great fortune to enjoy, has been, along with my coming in similar personal touch with Professor Jules Bloch, an inspiration in my studies and my labours; and I may say the same of my coming to know Professor Meillet, the *savant* and the teacher. To all these gentlemen I have to convey my most grateful thanks for all their kindnesses and for all that I have received from them as their pupil.

v1.c3.5

The work, while it was being prepared in London in 1920-1921, had the advantage of being looked over in its first draft (except in some sections relating to the verb) by Dr. Barnett; and I am very grateful to him for much helpful advice in suggesting improvements in arrangement and in the general treatment, as well as for some references. After it was approved by the University of London, Sir George Grierson, in spite of his very heavy and urgent scientific work, honoured my book, in MS., by a careful perusal, and his criticisms and suggestions he embodied in several pages of notes. Professor Jules Bloch also did the same thing. These notes I constantly kept beside me in re-writing my thesis. Everywhere I have profited by their criticisms, and in most cases I have accepted their suggestions. I have also received some references and one or two suggestions from my friends in Calcutta while finally preparing the work for the press, and these have been acknowledged in their proper places. I have to mention here specially the names of Professor Hem Chandra Rāychaudhuri, my old college friend and colleague in the University, and of Professor Satyendranāth Basu of the University of Dacca, for some suggestions in the earlier part of the work.

v1.c3.6

In preparing the present work, the plan adopted by Professor Bloch in his ‘Formation de la Langue marathe’ has given me the clearest notions about what a book on the origin and development of a modern Indo-Aryan language should contain: and Professor Bloch’s work, which Sir George Grierson has described as 'without any doubt the most important book dealing with the Modern Indian languages that has appeared since the publication of Hoernle's *Grammar of the Gaudian Languages* in 1880,' has, in the clarity of its exposition and in the width of its erudition as well as in the sureness of its judgment, offered me the best model that I could have. But in my own book, as I find, I had to discuss many points, some of them side-issues, especially in the *Introduction*, which should be but merely touched upon in a work of a professedly linguistic character, not being immediately *à propos* for history of language; and perhaps, I had to be fuller in detail; and at times, repetition became unavoidable. That was due partly to the fact that an appreciation of the racial, historical and cultural background was thought to be helpful in following the linguistic development; and the reason of the repetition is that the work of re-writing and printing my book went hand-in-hand (so that I had no opportunity of surveying the present work as a whole before the printing of it was finished), and that the same phenomenon had to be viewed from different aspects, and a repetition of a fact or an argument was felt to be necessary where a mere reference was not enough. I hope, however, that the general unity of the work has not suffered thereby. I have tried my best not to be dogmatic, and although I had to speculate and hypothesize at times to explain facts, I hope I have not let loose my fancy to roam freely, unchecked by the restraints of science. In my book no great points have been raised, no remarkable theories advanced: and fortunately there is hardly any scope for that. I have simply tried to apply the methods of Comparative Philology, as accepted by the present-day masters of the science, in working out the history of Bengali. A number of things have come into my notice as one of the first workers in the field along what may be called scientific lines, at least among Bengali speakers: and these would strike any other observer. Many of the views expressed may ultimately prove to be wrong, with the accession of new facts—as, for instance, from the systematic study of the dialects of Bengali and of the cognate speeches. The work here submitted, however, is the outcome of sincere labour in a subject for which I have the greatest love,

v1.c3.7

and it is here presented as an Essay towards an Historical and Comparative Grammar of Bengali, and as a contribution towards the scientific study of the Modern Aryan languages of India.

v1.c3.8

Linguistics as a modern science is still in its infancy in India, and the meagre dose of ‘Comparative Philology’ or ‘Historical Grammar’ which our college students reading advanced courses in Sanskrit or English, not supplementing it by any acquaintance with another cognate language of equal importance, most unwillingly gulp down, is hopelessly inadequate to create an intelligent interest in the subject. Added to this initial difficulty, Indo-Aryan linguistics both of the classical and modern periods has formed the favourite haunt of mere amateurs who seek to compensate for their want of knowledge of the principles of historical grammar and of the modern science of language by professing utter contempt of it; and the professed student of literature who knows the language but not its history shares in this contempt. To make confusion worse confounded, the spirit of scholasticism is not yet dead: we have elaborate grammars of Sanskrit masquerading as Bengali grammar, in which the genuine Bengali forms have been branded as vulgar (asādhu) beside the so-called ‘polite’ (sādhu) forms borrowed from Sanskrit. The first professedly historical grammar and etymological dictionary of Bengali (by that erudite and versatile scholar Rāi Bahādur Yogesh Chandra Rāy Vidyānidhi, published by the Vaṅgiya Sāhitya Pariṣad, Bengali year 1319-1322), for instance, has not been able to shake off the Sanskrit idea by appreciating the true line of linguistic development. A historical grammar of Bengali in the true sense of the term there has never been in Bengali; and there has not been a work exclusively on Bengali by any European scholar, on the lines of Trumpp’s Sindhi Grammar, or Kellogg’s Hindī Grammar, or C. J. Lyall’s Sketch of Hindustani, to guide the Bengali scholar in acquiring a true perspective which the too near presence of Sanskrit and the fact of the language being his mother-tongue generally blur for him. But there have been at times been refreshing manifestations of common sense in writing grammars of Bengali. The first Bengali to write a grammar of his mother-tongue was the Father

v1.c3.9

of Modern India, the great Rājā Ram Mohun Roy, whose work was published in English in 1826, and in Bengali in 1833; and he knew what we should mean by ‘Bengali.’ Chintāmaṇi Gānguli’s book (published in the early eighties) is a great advance on the so-called Bengali grammars of the period, and in recent times we have Nakulēśvara Vidyābhūṣaṇa’s little book (first edition Bengali year 1305, fourth edition 1315), and mention may be made of Hṛṣikēśa Śāstrī’s book (Bengali year 1307 = 1900). But the first Bengali with a scientific insight to attack the problems of the language was the poet Rabindranath Tagore; and it is flattering for the votaries of Philology to find in one who is the greatest writer in the language, and a great poet and seer for all time, a keen philologist as well, distinguished alike by an assiduous enquiry into the facts of the language and by a scholarly appreciation of the methods and findings of the modern western philologist. The work of Rabindranath is in the shape of a few essays (now collected in one volume) on Bengali phonetics, Bengali onomatopoetics, and on the Bengali noun, and on other topics, the earliest of which appeared in the early nineties, and some fresh papers appeared only several years ago. These papers may be said to have shown to the Bengali enquiring into the problems of his language the proper lines of approaching them.

v1.c3.10

Two works, however, though not on historical grammar, have been specially useful in writing this book, and I cannot be too grateful to the scholars responsible for them. These are the Bengali Dictionary of Jñānēndra Mōhan Dās, and the edition of the ‘Śrī-Kṛṣṇa-Kīrttana,’ our most important Middle Bengali text, by Basanta Rañjan Rāy Vidvad-vallabha. The former work presents the richest collection of material for phonology and for the study of the formative affixes of both New Bengali and Middle Bengali; and the latter with its excellent commentary and word index, especially the latter, has been an invaluable help for both phonology and morphology. For the rest, stray papers and monographs on points of vocabulary and grammar, in the Journal of the Vaṅgīya Sāhitya Pariṣad and in periodicals like the ‘Prabāsī,’ have at times been requisitioned. These latter of course are not always

v1.c3.11

up-to-date in their methods, but have nevertheless been very useful. My obligations in each case are indicated at the proper place. In connexion with the chapter on the Phonology of the Persian Element in Bengali, I have to acknowledge gratefully the assistance I received from my friend Khān Bahādur Shamsu-l-‘Ulamā Maulavī Muḥammad Hidāyat Husain, PH.D., of the Presidency College, Calcutta, with whom I went through my list of Perso-Arabic loan-words in Bengali in relation to their original forms.

v1.c3.12

I have not given a bibliography separately, as all the books consulted or referred to have been sufficiently described in the text.

v1.c3.13

To indicate the pronunciation I have given phonetic transcriptions [within square brackets] in the alphabet of the International Phonetic Association slightly modified for Bengali. This has been noted in a special section immediately before the list of Contents.

v1.c3.14

The book is now placed before the public, and while I do so I recall with the greatest sorrow that Sir Asutosh Mookerjee is no longer in our midst to see it completed. Sir Asutosh’s services to his University and to his people and his towering personality are well known in our country, and I need not dilate upon them here. For the foreign scholar interested in Indian Philology and in the spread of modern science in India to form some idea of the work of Sir Asutosh in the University of Calcutta, I would refer to the obituary note on him from Professor Sylvain Lévi, who had occasion to know the man as well as his ideals and achievements, in the ‘Journal Asiatique’ for 1924. In his sudden and untimely death in May 1924, I mourn the loss not only of a great national figure but also of a personal friend, and especially of one who was keenly interested in this work. Those of us who were privileged to come in intimate touch with his personality and followed his lead in university matters can say whole-heartedly that his indeed was a « svādu sakhyam » as well as a « svādvī praṇitiḥ ». After my return from Europe late in 1922, I was at a loss how to print my book, and naturally I turned to Sir Asutosh, my patron, my friend, philosopher and guide. Sir Asutosh had watched my career abroad, and he at once offered to publish my book through my *Alma* Mater. For over a decade before that time, Sir Asutosh had been actively engaged in establishing and furthering the study of Bengali and other Indian Modern Languages in the University of Calcutta. He was responsible for the foundation of the first post of research-lecturer for an Indian language in an Indian University—the Bengali research fellowship established in 1913. After creating the University Departments of Post-graduate Teaching and Research in Arts and Science in 1916, which formally transformed Calcutta University from an examining body (teaching but indirectly through affiliated colleges) into a teaching and investigating one, he instituted the study of Indian Vernaculars as a subject for the M. A. examination in 1919. He made provision for the teaching of all the important vernaculars of India, Aryan and Dravidian; and at his instance important volumes of typical selections from the different North Indian languages were undertaken and published. In 1922, he founded the Khaira chair of Indian Linguistics and Phonetics with the endowments furnished by the late Kumār Guruprasād Singh of Khaira, and selected me as its incumbent. Sir Asutosh's idea was to establish in Calcutta a school of Indian philology, in the widest sense of the term. He had a number of well thought-out plans, but death has put a stop to all of them. When my book was taken up by the University Press, Sir Asutosh showed a personal interest in it, and after the initial difficulties in preparing the necessary types with diacritical marks were overcome, thanks to his solicitude, he watched the progress of the work, and was at times impatient at the delay. It was a most cherished hope of mine that he would see the completion of the work, and it is my greatest regret that this hope remains unfulfilled.

v1.c3.15

While carrying the book through the press, I have received uniform kindness and encouragement from everybody concerned, and I cannot be too grateful to them. I have to express my thanks especially to the Assistant Registrar of the University, Bābu Yogesh Chandra Chakravartti, M.A., whose unfailing courtesy and prompt action have been of great help; to Bābu Atul Chandra Ghaṭak, M.A., Superintendent

v1.c3.16

of the University Press, who took a keen interest in my book, and granted me every facility that the University Press could offer, and allowed me many special privileges : his kindness has been constant during the three years that the book took to print—the first forme was printed early in 1923, and the last ones in 1926; to Bābu Kālipada Dās, B.A., Chief Assistant in the University Press, whose expert proof-reading and whose most intelligent interest have saved me from many a typographical error and many a *lapsus calami*. I have also to record that the compositors in the University Press, Bengali young men all of them, appreciated my labours and gave their most cheerful coöperation. A number of typographical errors nevertheless will appear. For these I am to a large extent responsible, as all the proofs from first to last (there were sometimes five or six proofs to read before one forme could be printed) were corrected by me. In the *Additions and Corrections* at the end of the book I have pointed out such typographical and other errors as have come to my notice, but I fear some more, though I hope they are of a trivial sort, have escaped my scrutiny, and for this I crave the indulgence of the reader.

v1.c3.17

For the *Index*, I am indebted to Bābu Sukumār Sēn, M.A., Lecturer in Comparative Philology, formerly pupil and now colleague in the University. He very kindly volunteered to prepare an index of all the Bengali words, and thus relieved me of a great burden. As he has been one of the very few serious students of Comparative Philology in our midst, whose enthusiasm for the subject is as great and as sound as his conscientious industry and his scholarly outlook, and who is himself engaged in philological researches, I could not wish this part of the work to be entrusted into better hands. He has the best thanks of his whilom teacher and friend.

v1.c3.18

I have indicated the scope of my work in a detailed list of *Contents*, and a further index of the topics discussed, as well as of the names, would have increased the bulk of the work and delayed the publication for a still longer period. The *Contents* I hope will be found to be enough.

v1.c3.19

« Méga biblíon, méga kakón » : the great evil however has been done—the text of my book, barring the *Contents* and the *Index*, runs up to nearly 1100 pages ; but this could not be helped—as the subject, it must be admitted, is a very wide one. I have not stinted any labour, and I have tried to do my best : but

v1.c3.20

« ā paritoṣād viduṣāṃ na sādhu manyē prayōga-vijñānam ».

v1.c3.21

THE UNIVERSITY, CALCUTTA : 15 JUNE, 1926.

v1.c3.22

SUNITI KUMAR CHATTERJI.

Abbreviations

v1.c4.1

A.C. = After Christ. Ap. = Apabhraṁśa. Arab. = Arabic. ASB. = Asiatic Society of Bengal, Calcutta B.C. = Before Christ. B., Beng. = Bengali. Bib. Ind. = Bibliotheca Indica Series, ASB. Bib. Nat. = Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris. BSOS. = Bulletin of the School of Oriental Studies, London. Coll. = Colloquial. DMG. = Deutsche Morgenländische Gesellschaft, Berlin. Drav. = Dravidian. E. = East, Eastern. EB. = East Bengal, East Bengali. eMB. = Early Middle Bengali. eMIA. = Early Middle Indo-Aryan. Ep. Ind. = Epigraphia Indica. Hind. = Hindōstānī. IA. = Indo-Aryan. IAnt. = Indian Antiquary, Bombay. IE. = Indo-European. IF. = Indogermanische Forschungen, Berlin. I.-Ir. = Indo-Iranian. JA. = Journal Asiatique, Paris. JAOS. = Journal of the American Oriental Society, New Haven. JASB. = Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, Calcutta.

v1.c4.2

JBBRAS. = Journal of the Bombay Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society. JBORS. = Journal of the Bihar and Orissa Research Society, Patna. JRAS. = Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, London. KKC. = ‘Kavi-kaṅkaṇa Caṇḍī,’ Vaṅga-vāsī edition. Langue Marathe = ‘La Formation de la Langue marathe’ by Jules Bloch, Bibliothèque de l’École des Hautes Études, Paris, 1919. LSI. = Linguistic Survey of India. LMB. = Late Middle Bengali. MIA. = Late Middle Indo-Aryan. Māg. = Māgadhī. MB. = Middle Bengali. MIA. = Middle Indo-Aryan. MSL. = Mémoires de la Société de Linguistique, Paris. N. = North, Northern. NB. = New Bengali. N.E. = North-East, North-Eastern. NIA. = New Indo-Aryan. N.W. = North-West, North-Western. OB. = Old Bengali. OIA. = Old Indo-Aryan. OWR. = Old Western Rājasthānī. Pers. = Persian. Pers.-Arab. = Perso-Arabic. Pkt. = Prakrit. S. = South, Southern. Śaur. = Śaurasēnī. SBE. = Sacred Books of the East Series, Oxford. S.E. = South-East, South-Eastern. ŚKK. = ‘Śrī-Kṛṣṇa-Kīrttana,’ edited by Basanta-Rañjana Rāya, VSPd., Bengali year 1323. Skt. = Sanskrit. SPd. = Sāhitya Pariṣad. Stand. = Standard.

v1.c4.4

*sts., stss.* = semi-tatsama, semi-tatsamas. S.W. = South-West, South-Western. *tbh., tbh s.* = tadbhava, tadbhavas. *ts., tss.* = tatsama, tatsamas. U.P. = United Provinces of Agra and Oudh. VSP. = ‘Vanga Sāhitya Paricaya’ or Typical Selections from Early Bengali Literature, Two Volumes, Calcutta University, 1914. VSPd. = Vangīya Sāhitya Pariṣad, Calcutta. VSPdP. = ‘Vangīya Sāhitya Pariṣad Patrikā.’ W. = West, Western. ZDMG. = Zeitschrift der Deutsche Morgenländische Gesellschaft, Leipzig.

Signs

v1.c5.1

means *gives, leads to, results in, is changed to, giving, leading to, etc.* : e.g., « *hasta* > *hattha* > *hātha* > *hātḍ* ».

v1.c5.2

< means *comes from, is derived from, coming from, being derived from, etc.* : e.g., « *hātḍ* < *hātha* < *hattha* < *hasta* ».

v1.c5.3

= indicates a cognate form, or a source type.

v1.c5.4

* before a word or affix indicates a hypothetical form not preserved in literature, but reconstructed : e.g., « *dīpa-rakṣa-* + *-uka-* > *dīva-rakkhua-* > *dīrakhō* ». This is found with forms in Indo-European, Indo-Iranian and other hypothetical stages of the speech, as well as in intermediate forms in Indo-Aryan.

v1.c5.5

? before a word or form indicates doubt as to the form proposed, or the form being the source of the word or connected with the word under discussion.

v1.c5.6

√ means root.

v1.c5.7

‡ before a word means it is dialectal, and not universally recognised.

v1.c5.8

† before a word indicates that it is obsolete.

v1.c5.9

+ joins up the component parts which are at the basis of a Modern Indo-Aryan or other word.

v1.c5.10

-, the hyphen, has been used to analyse words into their roots and affixes. When a word (Sanskrit or Pali or otherwise) is given with a hyphen at the end, it indicates merely the base form, to which other additions of suffixes or inflexions were made. Prefixes similarly have a hyphen after them, and suffixes and inflexions before them.

v1.c5.11

‘ ’: names of books are given within inverted commas.

v1.c5.12

« » have been used in all *transliterated* forms, except when they occur by themselves within ordinary brackets ( ).

v1.c5.13

[ ] square brackets enclose words in *phonetic transcription* (and in some cases also ordinary English words, and transliterated forms, occurring within ordinary brackets).

v1.c5.14

( ) in a transliterated or phonetically transcribed word shows that the letter or sound occurs optionally, and can be omitted either in writing or in pronunciation.

Transliteration

Transliteration of Bengali

v1.c6.s1.1

অ has been transcribed as « å », when the original sound of [ɔ] (see below, under *Phonetic Transcription*) is retained; as « å’ » or « ō » indifferently, when as a result of Umlaut and loss of following « i » or « u » the sound is altered to [o]: when the spelling is kept in view, « å’ » has been used, and when the pronunciation, « ō ». The letter « å » represents a long « অ » sound which seems to have resulted in OB. and MB. from an earlier group « ǎă, ǎwǎ, ǎhǎ ». A quiescent অ, not indicated in the Bengali spelling by ্ (= the « virāma » or « hasanta »), is transcribed « ḁ », i.e. a deleted « a »: e.g., অনল = « ȧnȧlȧ », but চল্ল = « cȧ’llȧ (cōllō) ». In a final য় « yå », where it represents an earlier « -ē », the « å » has not been noted: য় = « -y ». In personal names and names of books, simple « a » has been used for অ, and not « å », and the symbol « ḁ » also has not been employed.

v1.c6.s1.2

আ, ই, ঈ, উ, ঊ have been transcribed respectively as « ā, i, ī, u, ū ». As results of « sandhi », « â, î, û » also have been employed. ই উ forming separate syllables, in writing at least, are denoted by « ï, ü ».

v1.c6.s1.3

ঋ ৠ have been transcribed as « ṛ, ṝ », with a vertical bar below. the commoner « r, ḷ » being retained respectively for the so-called ‘cerebral r’ (ড়, ঢ়) and for the ‘cerebral l’ (= ঌ, not found in Bengali).

v1.c6.s1.4

এ ঐ ও ঔ = « ē, ȧi, ō, ȧu »; « Sandhi » এ, ও = « ê, ô ».

v1.c6.s1.5

ং = « ṅ » or « ṁ »; ঃ = « ḥ »; ँ = « ~ » on the top of the vowel (e.g., অঁ = ã, আঁ = ã, ইঁ = ĩ, ঈঁ = ī; উঁ = ũ, ঊঁ = ū̃; এঁ = ẽ, ওঁ = õ).

v1.c6.s1.6

ক, খ, গ, ঘ, ঙ = « k, kh, g, gh, ŋ ».

v1.c6.s1.7

চ, ছ, জ, ঝ, ঞ = « c, ch, j, jh, ñ ».

v1.c6.s1.8

ট, ঠ, ড, ঢ, ণ = « ṭ, ṭh, ḍ, ḍh, ṇ »; ড়, ঢ় = « ṛ, ṛh ».

v1.c6.s1.9

ত, থ, দ, ধ, ন = « t, th, d, dh, n ».

v1.c6.s1.10

প, ফ, ব, ভ, ম = « p, ph, b, bh, m ».

v1.c6.s1.11

য = « j » in *tadbhavas* mainly; and in some cases in *tatsamas*, য = « y ». See below, under য.

v1.c6.s1.12

র, ল = « r, l ».

v1.c6.s1.13

ব = « b » when initial, intervocal and final, « w » when post-consonantal.

v1.c6.s1.14

শ, ষ, স = respectively « ś, ṣ, s ».

v1.c6.s1.15

হ = « h ».

v1.c6.s1.16

য = « y ». য or য়, subscript or post-consonantal (= ্য) is transcribed « y ». য় has in some cases been ignored, where it stands for the « w » glide. Glide য় has been occasionally transcribed as « ẏ » and also as « ẇ » (see text, pp. 338-342). The group য় has generally been transcribed as « w », (or « ẇ » to indicate its character as a glide sound).

v1.c6.s1.17

ক্ষ = « kṣ »; জ্ঞ = « jñ ».

Transliteration of Sanskrit

v1.c6.s2.1

On the lines for Bengali as above. Practically the Geneva System has been followed.

v1.c6.s2.2

« ē, ō » have invariably been used for ए, ओ, to emphasise upon their long quantity; and the long diphthongs ऐ, औ are written « ai, au ». Accent in Vedic has been denoted by « ' » on the vowel bearing it: *e.g.*, « á, í, ŕ, á, ǘ ».

v1.c6.s2.3

The « anusvāra » has been indicated by « ṅ » or by « ṃ » following the etymology.

v1.c6.s2.4

ঋ = « ṛ »; ৠ = « ṝ » (i.e., « ṛ »); ঌ = « ḷ »; ৡ = « ḹ »; হ্ম = « lh ».

v1.c6.s2.5

ব has been denoted by « v » as usual, but in some cases, « w » has been employed, to emphasise upon the bilabial pronunciation.

v1.c6.s2.6

For « ə », see under *Phonetic Transcription* below.

Transliteration of Prakrit

v1.c6.s3.1

« ă, ĕ, ŏ » have been used to emphasise on their short quantity before double consonants. Disyllabic groups—« aï, aü ».

v1.c6.s3.2

The « anusvāra » = « ṅ, ṃ ».

v1.c6.s3.3

The « ya-śruti » has been denoted by « ẏ », and « ẇ » has been used for a similar « w » glide.

v1.c6.s3.4

In some cases, spirant pronunciation has been indicated by « g, j, ḍ, ḍ ».

v1.c6.s3.5

For « ə », see under *Phonetic Transcription* below.

Other Indian Languages

v1.c6.s4.1

Quiescent « ă » has not as a rule been indicated in languages other than Bengali by « ă » as it has been done in Bengali, except to make clear the derivation of a form or word in a particular case.

v1.c6.s4.2

Ōṛiyā and Assamese « å », as in Bengali.

v1.c6.s4.3

Bihārī « å », a rounded vowel sound as in Middle Bengali.

v1.c6.s4.4

Small « a, i, u », at the top of the line, indicate the attenuated final vowels of Maithilī, Sindhī, etc.

v1.c6.s4.5

The diphthongs are written « åi, åu » for Ōṛiyā and Assamese, and « ai, au » for the rest. The nasalised diphthongs are « aĩ, aũ ».

v1.c6.s4.6

The stops with simultaneous glottal closure, as for instance in East Bengali and in Sindhī, have « ’ » after them: e.g., « g’, b’ ».

v1.c6.s4.7

Generally « ṛ, ṛh » have been used for intervocal ड़(ḍ), ढ(ḍh) « ḍ, ḍh » where these letters are pronounced as the ‘cerebral r, rh.’

v1.c6.s4.8

For the letter व, « v, w » have indifferently been used: generally « w » for Hindōstānī. Assamese and Ōṛiyā follow the Bengali way—« b-, -b », « -b- » (intervocal), « -w- » (post-consonantal).

v1.c6.s4.9

Tamil palatals have been indicated by the italic « *n, r, t* », and the Tamil voiced cerebral spirant by « ḻ ».

v1.c6.s4.10

« ź » is the voiced form of the sibilant « ś » = श of Skt., which occurred in Indo-Iranian.

v1.c6.s4.11

« ç » has been used for the palatal fricative sound, unvoiced, of Indo-Iranian.

Persian and Arabic

v1.c6.s5.1

For the transliteration and phonetic transcription from these speeches, see under ‘Phonology of the Foreign Element: Persian,’ forming Chapter VI. of *Phonology*, pp. 559 ff., esp. p. 573.

v1.c6.s5.2

« x » has generally been employed to indicate the letter خ: the usual transcription is « kh » or « kh ».

v1.c6.s5.3

« š » = ش, *sh* of English; « ž » = ژ, or *s* as in English *pleasure* = French *j*.

Phonetic Transcription

v1.c7.1

The symbols are those employed by the International Phonetic Association. An introduction to this system is to be found in ‘The Principles of the International Phonetic Association’ London, 1912, and ‘L’Ecriture phonétique international,’ London, 1921 publications of the Association. See also G. Noël-Armfield’s ‘General Phonetics,’ 3rd ed., Cambridge, 1924. The symbols occurring in the present book are given below.

v1.c7.2

[:] after a symbol denotes length of the sound indicated by it, whether a vowel or a consonant; [~] on the top of a vowel indicates nasalised pronunciation; and ['] before a syllable indicates stress upon it and ["] indicates strong stress. The little vertical bar [|] beside a stop sound shows that it is unexploded, e.g., [p|, t|, k|].

v1.c7.3

[a:]: ‘front a,’ as in North English *man, cat*, heard in dialectal West Bengali pronunciation of a word like কাল [ka:l] *yesterday, tomorrow*, as opposed to কাল [ka:l] *time*. Nasalised form = [ã:].

v1.c7.4

[ɐ]: a central vowel occurring in Modern Portuguese: see pp. 621-622.

v1.c7.5

[ɑ]: ‘back’ or ‘central’ *a*—as in Standard Bengali কাকা [kɑkɑ] *uncle*, আমি [ɑmi] *I*. Nasalised form = [ɑ̃].

v1.c7.6

[æ]: the sound of *a* as in Southern English *man, cat* = West Bengali sound as in কেন [kæno] *why*, ত্যাগ [tæg] *abandonment*. Nasalised form = [æ̃].

v1.c7.7

[ɒ]: the sound of *o* as in Southern English *hot, lot*: it occurred in Old Bengali for the later অ = [ɔ] (see below): see Text, p. 258. It is a kind of [ɔ] without lip-rounding.

v1.c7.8

[b]: as in English = the Bengali ব.

v1.c7.9

[b’]: made with simultaneous glottal closure, as in Sindhi, or in dialectal East Bengali, e.g., [b’a:t] *boiled rice* = Standard ভাত [bhɑ:t].

v1.c7.10

[bh] : the ভ of Sanskrit and Hindī etc. : the voiced labial stop aspirated. [b] : bilabial fricative, the same as [v] for which see below. [c] : palatal stop, unvoiced—the old sound of Skt. च—resembling in acoustic effect a fronted or palatalised < k >, i.e., a sort of < ky >. [ch] : the same aspirated = the old sound of Skt. छ. [ć] : palatal affricate, unvoiced = the West Bengali চ. [ćh] : unvoiced palatal affricate, aspirated = West Bengali ছ. [ç] : unvoiced palatal fricative, the sound of ch in German ich : the old value of the Skt. श. [d] : interdental stop, voiced = দ of Bengali. (In OIA., this sound was alveolar). [d’] : the same, with accompanying glottal closure, as in dialectal East Bengali [d’a:n] paddy = Standard Bengali ধান [dha:n]. [dh] : voiced interdental stop, aspirated = ধ of Standard Bengali. [d] : voiced alveolar stop, as in English and Assamese. [ḍ] : voiced cerebral or retroflex stop made with curled-up tongue-tip = ड of Sanskrit. The Bengali ড is of the same class, but it is pronounced at a lower position, approaching the alveolar region. [ḍ’] : the above, with accompanying glottal closure : found in Sindhi, and in dialectal East Bengali, e.g., [ḍ’a:k] drum, tom-tom; to cover = Standard Bengali ঢাক [ḍha:k]. [ḍh] : voiced cerebral stop aspirated = Sanskrit ढ, West Bengali ঢ. [ð] : voiced interdental spirant = th in English this [ðis], then [ðen], same as ذ of Arabic as in ذات [ða:t], نذر [naðr] etc. [ḍ] : voiced dental or alveolar stop, velarised, i.e. made with simultaneous raising of the back of the tongue : occurring in Arabic (see Text, pp. 567ff). [ḷ] : voiced alveolar unilateral, velarised : occurring in Arabic (see p. 568). [dž] : voiced dental or alveolar affricate = dialectal East Bengali জ. [d̂ž] : voiced supra-alveolar or palatal affricate, as in English judge = [d̂žʌd̂ž]. [e] : high-mid front vowel, as in West Bengali দেশ [de:ʃ] land, country. Nasalised form = [ẽ].

v1.c7.11

[ĕ] : ‘semi-vowel e,’ the Bengali য় as in মায়া [maĕa] (Skt. মায়া = ma:ĭa:). [ĕ] : a sound intermediate between [e] and [ɛ] (see below). [ə] : the ‘neutral vowel’ or ‘shĕvā’—a central vowel as in English *again* [əgeĭn], Hindōstānī मूरत [mu:rət] *image*, रतन [rətən] *gem*, etc. [ɛ] : low-mid front vowel, as in dialectal East Bengali কেবল [kɛbəl] *only*, or in English *get* [gɛt]. Nasalised form = [ɛ̃]. [ɜ] : a central vowel, as in English *bird*, *her* [bɜ:d, hɜ:(ɹ)]. [f] : unvoiced denti-labial spirant, as in English. Often heard in Bengali for ফ = [ph]. [F] : unvoiced bilabial spirant, the puffing sound made in blowing out a candle : commonly heard in Bengali for ফ = [ph] (in dialectal East Bengali also for প = [p]). [g] : velar stop, voiced = English *g* in *go*, Bengali গ. (The symbol generally used for this sound in the IPA. alphabet is [g]). [g’] : the above, with glottal closure : found in Sindhī, and in dialectal East Bengali, as in [g’ɔ:r] = Standard Bengali ঘর [ghɔ:r] *house*. [gɦ] : voiced velar stop, aspirated = Skt. घ, West Bengali ঘ. [g] : voiced velar fricative = غ of Persian : found in dialectal East Bengali in an intervocal position. [g] : voiced uvular stop (the IPA. symbol commonly used is [G]). [γ] : voiced uvular fricative = Arabic غ. [h] : unvoiced glottal fricative, ‘unvoiced h,’ the *h* sound of English, as in *hat*, *happy*. This is the Skt. and Bengali «visarga», and the «prāṇa» or aspiration in the «aghōṣa mahā-prāṇa» or unvoiced aspirated sounds—[kh, ch (cɦ), ṭh, th, ph]. [ɦ] : voiced glottal fricative, or ‘voiced h’ = English *h* as in *behind* [bəɦaĭnd], *perhaps* [pəɦiæps] ; = Sanskrit হ, Bengali হ, Arabic ه. [ɦ̥] : a whispered *h*, = ح, the so-called ‘emphatic h’ of Arabic. [i] : high front vowel, unrounded, as in Bengali দীন [di:n] *poor*, দিন [di:n] *day*, English *seen* [si:n, siĭn]. Nasalised form = [ĩ]. [ɪ] : high front vowel, retracted and brought down very near high-mid position = English *i* as in *pit* [pɪt]. [ĭ] : ‘semi-vowel or consonantal i’ : the old value of Skt. ই.

v1.c7.12

j] : voiced palatal fricative, like English *y* in *yes* [jɛs]. [j] : a stronger form of the preceding, with greater audible friction, approaching [ʒ], for which see below, after [z]. [ɟ] : voiced palatal stop = Skt. ज (the old pronunciation of which was like that of a fronted or palatalised ग = *gy*). [ɟʝ] : palatal affricate, voiced = West Bengali জ. [ɟʝ’] : palatal affricate, voiced, with glottal closure, found in dialectal East Bengali for the next sound, [ɟʝ], of Standard Bengali. [ɟʝʱ] : palatal affricate, voiced = West Bengali ঝ. [k] : unvoiced velar stop = Bengali ক, English *k* as in *baker* [beɪkə]. [kʱ] : the same, aspirated slightly = the English sound in *cap* [kʱæp], *king* [kʰɪŋ].

v1.c7.13

[kh] : the same, aspirated strongly = Skt. ख, Bengali খ. [l] : ‘clear l,’ as in South English *long* [lɔŋ], = Bengali ল. [ɫ] : ‘dark l,’ or velarised l, pronounced with simultaneous raising of the back of the tongue towards the soft palate, as in South English *well* [wɛɫ], *Bill* [bɪɫ].

v1.c7.14

[ɭ] : ‘cerebral ḷ,’ made with the curled-up tip of the tongue against the dome of the palate = Vedic ळ. The same aspirated, ळ्ह = [ɭʱ]. [ḷ] : ‘vocalic l’—forming a syllable with another consonant = Skt. लृ; like the *l* in English *bottle* [bɔtḷ, bɔtɫ].

v1.c7.15

[li] : slightly palatalised l as in dialectal West Bengali (see p. 539). [ʎ] : ‘palatal l,’ pronounced with simultaneous raising of the front of the tongue towards the hard palate : a sound found in dialectal French, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, etc. [m] : bilabial nasal = the Bengali ম. [ṃ] : ‘vocalic m,’ as in English *bottom* [bɔtṃ]. [ɯ] : high back unrounded vowel = an [u] made with spread lips : found in Tamil, in Japanese, and in other languages. [n] : alveolar nasal = the Bengali ন. [ɳ] : retroflex or cerebral nasal = the Sanskrit ण. [ṇ] : ‘vocalic n,’ as in English *button* [bʌtṇ].

v1.c7.16

[ŋ] : velar nasal : the Skt. ङ, Bengali ঙ, , English *ng* as in *sing* [sɪŋ]. [ɲ] : palatal nasal : the Skt. ञ, Bengali ঞ, French and Italian *gn*, Spanish *ñ*. [o] : high-mid back vowel, rounded, = Bengali ও in লোক [lo:k] *person*, *world*. Nasalised form = [õ]. [ŏ] : ‘semi-vowel o,’ *e.g.*, Bengali ওয় in খাওয়া [khaŏa]. [ò] : is a sound intermediate between [o] and [ɔ] (see below). [œ] : low-mid front vowel, rounded, = the French sound as in *cœur* [kœʀ]. [ɔ] : low-mid back vowel, rounded : the sound as in English *law* [lɔ:], = Bengali অ. Nasalised form = [ɔ̃]. [ø] : high-mid front vowel, rounded, = the German *ö* as in *schön* [ʃø:n], French *eu* as in *peu* [pø]. [p] : bilabial stop, unvoiced : Bengali প. [pʰ] : the same, slightly aspirated : English *p* in *put*, *pick* [pʰæt, pʰɪk]. [ph] : the same, strongly aspirated : Skt. फ, proper sound of Bengali ফ. [q] : uvular stop, unvoiced, = Arabic ق. [r] : alveolar trilled, voiced : Bengali র, Scots English *r*. [ɽ] : flapped r, or so-called ‘cerebral r’ = Bengali ড়, Hindi ड़. [ṛ] : ‘vocalic r’: = Skt. ऋ. [ɹ] : ‘fricative r,’ alveolar, as in South English. [ɻ] : retroflex fricative r, = the Tamil sound often transliterated « ḷ ». [ri] : slightly palatalised r, as in dialectal West Bengali (see p. 539). [ʀ] : trilled ‘uvular r,’ as in Northern French. [s] : dental or alveolar sibilant, = Skt. स, East Bengali স, English *s*. [ṣ] : unvoiced dental or alveolar sibilant, velarised, = Arabic ص. [ʃ] : palatal sibilant made with the blade of the tongue, with slight lip-rounding, = English *sh*, Arabic and Persian ش (in transcriptions written « š »). [ɕ] : palatal sibilant made with the front of the tongue = Bengali শ, ষ, স. [ʂ] : cerebral or retroflex sibilant made with the tip of the tongue curled-up against the dome of the palate = Sanskrit ष. [t] : unvoiced inter-dental stop = Bengali ত. (The Skt. त was originally « danta-mūliya » or alveolar, like the English *t*.) [th] : the same, aspirated strongly = Sanskrit थ, Bengali থ.

v1.c7.17

[t] : alveolar *t* as in English *better* [bɛtə]. [tʰ] : the same slightly aspirated = English *t* in *tap*, *tip* [tʰæp, tʰɪp]. [ṭ] : retroflex or cerebral stop, unvoiced, = *ṭ* of Skt. The Bengali *ṭ* is of the same class, but it is pronounced at a lower position, approaching the alveolar region. [ṭʰ] : the same aspirated = Sanskrit *ṭh*, Bengali *ṭh*. [ṭ] : unvoiced dental or alveolar stop, with velarisation, = Arabic *ẓ*. [ts] : unvoiced dental or alveolar affricate = East Bengali *ts*. [tʃ] : supra-alveolar and palatal affricate, unvoiced = English *ch* as in *church* = [tʃə:tʃ]. [u] : high back rounded vowel = Bengali *উ*, *ঊ*. Nasalised form = [ũ]. [ʊ] : high back rounded, slightly advanced and approaching the mid position, = English short *u* as in *put*, *book* [pʊt, bʊk]. [v] : voiced denti-labial fricative, = English *v*; frequently heard in Bengali for *ভ* = [bɦ]. [ʋ] : voiced bilabial fricative : it is the common Indian value of the « antastha va » = *ৱ* : very commonly heard in Bengali for *ভ* = [bɦ]. [ʌ] : a central vowel (or rather, a low-mid back vowel), considerably advanced, found in English, as in *sun*, *enough* [sʌn, ɪnʌf] = the Hindi stressed *अ* as in *रतन* [rʌtən], and very probably also the Sanskrit « saṃvṛta » *अ*. [w] : bilabial semi-vowel, or ‘consonantal u’ (= [ŭ]), as in English *wet*, *win*, the old value of the Skt. « antastha va » = *व*. [w̃] : bilabial semi-vowel, or fricative (= [ʋ]), nasalised, occurring in Apabhraṃśa, in Hindī, in Middle Bengali. [x] : velar spirant, unvoiced = German *ch* in *ach*, Persian *خ* : found in dialectal East Bengali. Occurs also in Slav, in Germanic: cf. pp. 243, 246, 387 : see also p. 558. Ordinarily transcribed « kh ». [χ] : uvular spirant, unvoiced, = the spirant form of [q]. [y] : high front vowel, rounded — an [i] pronounced with rounded lips = French *u*, German *ü*. [z] : alveolar voiced spirant = English *z*, Persian *z*. [ẓ] : the same sound, velarised, occurring in Arabic (= *ẓ*)

v1.c7.18

[ʒ] : voiced palatal fricative = French *j*, Persian *j*, (in *transliteration* from the Persian written « ž »). [θ] : inter-dental fricative, unvoiced = English *th* in *thin*, *thank* [θin, θæŋk], Arabic ث. [ʔ] : the ‘glottal stop,’ = Arabic ‘hamzah’ (أ, ء). [ʕ] : the ‘laryngal fricative’ = Arabic ‘ʕayn’ (ع). (In *transliteration*, the above two are denoted respectively by « ’ » and « ‘ »). [n, ŋ, ñ, ṇ, m] are respectively the nasals [n, ŋ, ɲ, ṇ, m] pronounced very brief : see pp. 360 ff. [a, i, u] are the vowels [a] or [ɑ], [i] and [u] respectively, pronounced very brief.

Contents

v1.c8.1

Foreword by Sir George A. Grierson, K.C.I.E. ... v—vii Benedictory . . . . . ix—x Author's Preface . . . . . xi—xx Abbreviations . . . . . xxi—xxiii Signs . . . . . xxiv Transliteration . . . . . xxv—xxvii Phonetic Transcription ... ... ... xxviii—xxxiv Contents . . . . . xxxv—xci Introduction . . . . . 1—149 Appendix A to Introduction ... ... ... 150—169 Appendix B ” ... ... ... 170—178 Appendix C ” ... ... ... 179—188 Appendix D ” ... ... ... 189—223 Appendix E ” ... ... ... 224—235 Phonology . . . . . 237—648 Morphology . . . . . 649—1052 Appendix to Morphology ... ... ... 1053—1056 Additions and Corrections ... ... ... 1057—1078 Index of Bengali Words . ... ... ... 1079—1179

v1.c8.2

§ 1 : Position of Bengali, its age as a characterised language, p. 1 ; § 2 : Number of Bengali Speakers, p. 1 ; Linguistic Boundaries—Aryan, languages on the frontiers of Bengali, p. 1 ; non-Aryan neighbours of Bengali, pp. 2-3 ; ‘Kōl’ and ‘Muṇḍā,’ p. 2. § 3 : The Indo-European speeches : the Indo-Iranian or Aryan branch : Indic, Dardic and Iranian

Detailed Contents

v1.c8.s1.1

INTRODUCTION, PP. 1-235.

v1.c8.s1.2

groups, pp. 3-4 ; other Indo-European branches, p. 5 ; § 4 : the extinct Indo-European speeches : Kuchean or Tokharian, ‘ Hittite,’ etc., pp. 5-6.

v1.c8.s1.3

§ 5 : Tabular Representation of the Indo-Aryan speeches, p. 6 ; § 6 : the Modern Indo-Aryan speeches, p. 6 ; § 7 : the Dardic Kaśmīrī etc., pp. 6-7 ; § 8 : Western Panjābī, p. 7 ; § 9 : Eastern Panjābī, p. 8 ; § 10 : Sindhī, p. 8 ; § 11 : Rājasthānī dialects and Gujarātī : ‘ Piṅgala ’ and ‘ Diṅgala,’ pp. 8-9 ; § 12 : Pahāṛī or Khaśa dialects : Khas-kurā (Nepālī or Parbatiyā) : Dramas in Bengalī and Maithilī from Nepal : Kumāūnī and Gaṛhwālī, etc., pp. 9-10 ; § 13 : Western Hindī dialects : Braj-bhākhā ; Hindōstānī, Hindī, Urdū ; Importance of Hindōstānī : pp. 11-13 ; § 14 : Eastern Hindī dialects : Awadhī : Malik Muhammad Jaisī and Tulasī-dāsa, p. 13 ; § 15 : Marāṭhī : the ‘ Jñānēśvarī,’ p. 14 ; § 16 : the Magadhan speeches : Bhōjpuriyā, Maithilī, Magahī, Ōṛiyā, Bengalī-Assamese, p. 14 ; § 17 : Halabī etc., pp. 14-15 ; § 18 : Sinhalese : its source : Eḷu : Maldivan, pp. 15-16 ; § 19 : the Gipsy dialects outside India, p. 16.

v1.c8.s1.4

§ 20 : Periods in the History of the Indo-Aryan speech : [1] Old Indo-Aryan, [2] Middle Indo-Aryan in (a) Early, (b) Transitional, (c) Second and (d) Third stages, and [3] New Indo-Aryan ; Vedic or Sanskrit, ‘ Prakrit,’ and ‘ Bhāṣā ’ : approximate Dates for these periods ; pp. 16-17. Characteristics of Old Indo-Aryan, pp. 17-18 ; characteristics of Middle Indo-Aryan in its various stages, pp. 18-19 ; characteristics of New Indo-Aryan, pp. 19-20. § 21 : Old Indo-Aryan Linguistics : the problem of the Prakrits, pp. 20-21. § 22 : ‘ Māgadhī Apabhraṁśa,’ the source of Bengalī and its sister-speeches, p. 21 ; the ‘ Prācya ’ speech, pp. 21-22. § 23 : Genealogical Classification of the New Indo-Aryan speeches on the basis of the Linguistic Survey of India, p. 22 ; some hypotheses in working out the history of New Indo-Aryan : the ‘ Koinē ’ dialects of ancient and modern times, p. 22.

v1.c8.s1.5

§ 24 : the Indo-European people, their problematic area of characterisation, and primitive home, p. 23 ; Dialects in Indo-European, « satəm » and « centum », p. 24. § 25 : Advent of the Indo-Europeans in Western Asia and Iran : the Aryans—the Mitanni—the Kassites—the Manda

First 127 of 3,185 passages. Read on

Cites (4)