The History of Indian Literature c9.128.3
The History of Indian Literature c9.128.3
- Language
- English
c9.128.3
A few of the Sútras found in it are already notoriously acknowledged not to be Páṇini's; and there is the further peculiar circumstance, that, according to the scholiasts of the Calcutta edition, fully a third of the entire Sútras are not interpreted in the Mahábháshya at all.† The question then arises whether this is merely because these particular Sútras are clear and intelligible of themselves, or whether we may not also here and there have to suppose cases where the Sútras did not yet form part of the text at the time when this commentary was composed. The so-called *gaṇas*, or lists of words which follow one and the same rule, and of which, uniformly, only the initial word is cited in the text itself, are for the present wholly without critical authenticity, and carry no weight, therefore, in reference to Páṇini's time. Some such lists must, of course, have been drawn up by Páṇini; but whether those now extant are the same is very problematical: indeed, to some extent it is simply impossible that they can be so.