Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

History of Dharmashastra (Ancient and Mediaeval Religious and Civil Law in India) v5.c73.t1.179

History of Dharmaśāstra (Ancient and Mediaeval Religious and Civil Law in India) v5.c73.t1.179

Language
English

v5.c73.t1.179

⁹⁷⁰ The rules about Piṇḍapitṛyajña have been set forth in Āśv. Śr. S. II. 6 Nārāyaṇa notes (on Āśv gr. IV 7 2) that Āśvalāyana treats of only the procedure relating to the rite for pitṛs and that he does not at all refer to the dinner given to *daiva* or Vaiśvadeva brāhmaṇas at the time of śrāddha It is therefore possible that feeding daiva brāhmaṇas was added to the ancient ritual, though it must be said that Manu III. 125, Yāj. I. 224-28 and Vas XI. 27 prescribe such feeding. Dr. Caland (in 'Ahnencult' p 161) asserts that he can prove that the detail of feeding *daiva* brāhmaṇas spread from the Śrāddhasūtra of Kātyāyana to the other sūtras and he relies on the fact that Kātyāyana (in Kaṇḍikā 2) prescribes that the viśve devāh should be invoked with the verse 'Viśve devāsa āgata' and the performer should mutter the verse 'viśve devāḥ śṛnutemam' which are respectively Vāj S. VII. 34 and XXXIII 53. But Dr. Caland tries to prove too much. The first verse occurs twice in the Ṛg. (II 41. 13 and VI 52 7) and the second occurs in Ṛg. VI. 52 13, Tai S II 4 14 5. They are not found only in the Vāj. S as Dr. Caland seems to have thought It is possible that other works took over those mantras from the Ṛgveda or the Tai S It may also be noted that Yāj. I. 229 mentions only 'Viśve devāsa' and specifies that it is a ṛk (and not a mantra or yajus). So Yāj. at least does not appear to have borrowed the prescriptions of Kātyāyana. It is not necessary to examine the other arguments.

Cites (7)