Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India c11.s3: 7.3. The Mughal Harem
Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India c11.s3
- Language
- English
7.3. The Mughal Harem
c11.s3.1
There is another review of a special brand by A. Jan Qaiser of the History Department of Aligarh Muslim University published in the *Indian Historical Review*, New Delhi, 1991. This is a specimen of how a review may not be written. For it contains sentences like "whom do you think you are bluffing Mr. Lal?" or "what a consistency, Mr. Lal.?" (p. 346). Such is not the language of scholars. Therefore, I ignored Qaiser's review except devoting a page of my *Legacy of Muslim Rule* (p. 171) to take notice of one point. In *The Mughal Harem*, (Aditya Prakashan, New Delhi, 1988, p. 203). I had said that "The large establishment of wives and servants rendered the nobles immobile. No Indian scholars, engineers or travellers went abroad to learn the skills the Europeans were developing in their countries. While people from Europe were frequently coming to Hindustan, no Indian noble man could go to the West because he could not live without his harem and he could not take with him his cumbersome harem to countries situated so far away. Europe at this time was forging ahead in science and technology through its Industrial Revolution, but the Mughal elites kept themselves insulated from this great stride because of inertia. Consequently, the country was pulled back from marching with progress, a deficiency which has not been able to be made up until now."
c11.s3.2
Reacting to this statement, A. Jan Qaiser in his harsh review of the book observes; "Is Lal really ignorant of the fact that the Indians were being increasingly exposed to a number of European articles of technology and culture brought by the Europeans during the sixteenth, seventeenth and eighteenth century?" (p. 346). The poor man does not realise that he is only confirming my assertion that the Indian nobles were being only exposed (whatever he may mean by the word) to articles *brought* by Europeans. On their own they were incapable of doing anything more.
c11.s3.3
For Qaiser's information I may add that Professor M. Athar Ali, his colleague in Aligarh, agrees with my contention when he says (in his book *Mughal Nobility under Aurangzeb*, Bombay, 1970, p. 174) that "the ideas of the nobles concerning industry never went beyond Karkhanas or establishments employing artisans at low rates for their needs for luxuries (p. 164)... from the point of view of the Mughal nobility itself chief fault was its failure to change and adapt itself to a new developing situation not only in India, but in the whole world."
c11.s3.4
Since its publication *The Mughal Harem* has been reviewed in dozens of journals and magazines both in English and in Hindi. A couple of letters from a scholar in California are indeed touching: "I am quite aware of the years of research that has gone into your work and it is very much appreciated," and "My greatest admiration for your work and thanks for all you have given me in my research for understanding and knowledge."
c11.s3.5
In comparison, A. J. Qaiser's review is dross.
c11.s3.6
*7.4. History of the Khaljis and Other Books*
c11.s3.7
My *History of the Khaljis* was first published in 1950. It went through a second revised edition in 1967. A review published in the *Times Literary Supplement*, London, dated December 19, 1968 said, "When this book was published sixteen years ago it took its place at once among the standard authorities... This new edition embodies a good deal of fresh material derived from hitherto unutilised Rajput sources... In its latest form, this book is unlikely to be superseded." *History of the Khaljis* was mainly my dissertation for the Doctorate degree and was written at Allahabad between 1942 and 1945. The University of Allahabad was then known as the Oxford of India. During the years 1937 and 1945 when I was a student there, Dr. Sir Shafaat Ahmad Khan, Dr. Tara Chand, Dr. R.P. Tripathi, Dr. Ishwari Prasad and Dr. Beni Prasad were some of the great names in the then known as the History and Politics Department. They were all my teachers. Professor Mohammad Habib of Aligarh, was also as good and kind to me as my Professors at Allahabad. Naturally their ideas and views about medieval history left a deep impression on my young mind. Their ideas in turn were influenced by the contemporary Indian political scene which was then in great ferment. Between 1941 when I took the Master's degree and 1945 when I obtained the D. Phil., the struggle for Indian independence against British rule was at its peak (with Quit India Movement thrown in, in 1942). During those turbulent days it was felt that Hindu-Muslim combined endeavour was most needed to present a united front against the foreign British rule. Allahabad was the home of the Nehrus. Jawaharlal Nehru used to reside in Anand Bhavan when he was not in jail. Mahatma Gandhi also used to come and stay there for days together. Many important meetings of the Congress Working Committee used to be held in Anand Bhavan. The University was at a stone's throw from there. It is no wonder therefore that the Allahabad University became a think-tank for presenting Hindu-Muslim united front. This was one reason why it became a fashion and a tradition in the History and Politics Department not to say a word against Muslim rule in India; everything about it was to be praised. It was an attempt at forging Hindu-Muslim unity with retrospective effect. Naturally, we young scholars of impressionable age learnt about the Muslim rule in India with a definite pro-Muslim bias just as we were taught by our professors. But, I remember, we students used to discuss among ourselves that there was lot of 'white washing' and 'polishing' and *suppressio veri* in what we were taught in the class room.
c11.s3.8
The Faculty members of the History Department had brought out a number of excellent monographs on medieval Indian history. Beni Prasad's *History of Jahangir*, Banarsi Prasad Saksena's *History of Shahjahan*, R.P. Tripathi's *Some Aspects of Muslim Administration* and Ishwari Prasad's *History of the Qaraunah Turks* were widely read. Ishwari Prasad's *Medieval India* and *Muslim Rule in India* were our textbooks in B.A. and M.A. Tara Chand's *Influence of Islam on Indian Culture* and Mohammad Habib's *Sultan Mahmud of Ghaznin* were highly praised for breaking new grounds. We were recommended lots of books to read. Sir Jadunath Sarkar's *Aurangzib* was avidly read, and also criticised. But those were the days of a different culture not found now among Marxists and progressives. For instance, when there was criticism of some statement of Jadunath Sarkar, it was also acknowledged in and outside the class room (by R.P. Tripathi, for example) that Sarkar was the doyen of Indian historians and "head and shoulders above all of us".
c11.s3.9
During the early years of my research on Alauddin Khalji which led to the completion of the *History of the Khaljis*, the emphasis was on learning the Persian language. Muslim chronicles, which formed our main source material, were available in that language mainly. The study of Quran, Hadis and other Muslim scriptural literature was not recommended. At this stage there never was even a suggestion to read these and acquaint ourselves with the salient features of the religion of Islam. On the other hand it was often emphasised that the actions of omission and commission of Muslim rulers and nobles had nothing to do with the religion of Islam. We thought as we were told in Professors' lectures and published books - that the tirade of the Muslim ulema like Ziyauddin Barani against the Hindus were the fulminations of a sick mind and the actions of invaders and rulers like Mahmud Ghaznavi and Alauddin Khalji had nothing to do with Islam as such.
c11.s3.10
But the source materials threw a different hint. The Quran was often quoted by the chroniclers during their spate of abuse against the Hindus. Barani was learned in Islamic scriptures. Mahmud of Ghazni was a scholar of the Quran and Amir Timur prostrated himself before God after he had achieved the great objective of massacring the people of Delhi. Connection between the actions of Muslim rulers and Islamic scriptures was unmistakable. In later years, when I had become acquainted with the fundamentals of Islam through the study of the Quran and Hadis I realized that whatever the Maulanas (and most sufis) had said was not the product of a sick or unbalanced mind but was based on Islamic religious scriptures, and that historical truth could become clearer by discovering the links between the actions of Muslim invaders and rulers, the writings of chroniclers, and the teaching of Islamic scriptures instead of clamping the entire blame on the ulema section of the sultan's court.
c11.s3.11
In 1945 I left Allahabad and joined the Madhya Pradesh (then known as Central Provinces and Berar) Educational Service and for the next eighteen years or so taught at Government Colleges in Nagpur, Jabalpur and Bhopal. My *Twilight of the Sultanate* was published in 1963 when I was at Bhopal. it deals with the history of the Afghan rulers of the Lodi clan. Sikandar Lodi was an anti-Hindu fanatic, and consequently a true Muslim in the eyes of Muslim chroniclers. I have not failed to write about his bigotry, which was enjoined by his creed, on pp. 192-94 and 287-88 of the *Twilight of the Sultanate*. Else, but for the speciality of his religion, the son of a Hindu mother could not have become so fanatically anti-Hindu. Similar had been the case with Sultan Firoz Tughlaq.
c11.s3.12
In July, 1963, I joined the University of Delhi as Reader in (Medieval) Indian history A seminar on "Ideas motivating Social and Cultural Movements and Economic and Political policies during the 15th, 16th and 17th centuries in India" was organised by the History Department of the Delhi University in November, 1965. I presented a paper on "Ideas leading to the impoverishment of the Indian peasantry in medieval times". It had been dinned into our ears that the extreme poverty of the Indian peasant was due to the administrative policies and exploitation of the British rule. I had often wondered if this execrable poverty was the result of a century or so only of British rule, or whether this poverty was of remote past and its origins could be traced back to the medieval period. I found enough evidence to arrive at the conclusion that there was systematic impoverishment of the agriculturists under Muslim rule; to blame the British alone was not right. But such a conclusion was against the current fashion. To find fault with Muslim rule was not in conformity with secular history. After I had presented the paper many delegates spoke to express their views, as is usual in seminars. But Professor Saiyyad Nurul Hasan indulged in "trenchant criticism" of the paper. He was a Marxist, a secularist, and a progressive historian. Such was the clout of this group of historians that they would not brook any disagreement with their mental fixture of only appreciation and praise for Muslim rule in India. I became convinced that until this "gagging of others" was not challenged, their brand of history would go unchecked. Since then I have challenged them in my books.
c11.s3.13
Later on Nurul Hasan became the Education Minister in the Government of India. Nurul Hasan possessed great qualities of head and heart. He was also a great administrator. Early in his career as Professor at Aligarh he had organized the History Department on a stable footing. When he became the Education Minister he continued the traditions of Maulana Abul Kalam Azad. He had a kind heart and like the great Mughals loved being surrounded by yes-men. Prospective professors thronged round him. Professors of history throughout the country began to be appointed with his consent and approval. He founded the Indian Council of Historical Research. He established the Jawaharlal Nehru University. His proteges took control of the Institute of Advanced Study at Simla and the University Grants Commission at Delhi. The situation is best sketched by Swapan Dasgupta in an excellent article in the *Indian Express* of July 23, 1995:
c11.s3.14
"Many of those who read history at Delhi in the mid-1970s and later, still bear the ugly scars inflicted by the thought police of *sarkari* Marxism. 'There are two interpretations of history', a leading representative of the Red Cretin Brigade used to inform his students casually, 'the bourgeois interpretation and the Marxist interpretation, and the Marxist interpretation is the correct one.' The sense of certitude was terribly contagious and ambitious students readily accepted the prevailing dictum: if you read Marx, you will score more marks... The leftists were neither sartorially wild, sexually adventurous nor fanatically anti-establishment. They were boring time, servers who lived off the patronage provided by a 'progressive' education minister. They dominated the committees, regulated appointments, set the curriculum, issued monotonously predictable 'anti-fascist' proclamations, hobnobbed with visiting academic dignitaries and travelled on the international seminar circuit. With little original research under their belt, they thrived above all on reflected glory.
c11.s3.15
"Indeed, being a part of an international Marxist fraternity was central to their existence. If Christopher Hill published an incisive study on the English Civil War, if E.P. Thompson completed a monumental work on 18th century deviancy and if the Ruskin College-based History Workshop undertook a seminar on popular culture, some of the glory would rub off on their progressive counterparts in India. The British Marxists set the standards of history in Britain and this enhanced the reputation of their counterparts in India...
c11.s3.16
"Whereas the British Marxists established their reputation by crafting their radical concerns their Indian counterparts took cheeky short cuts. it may also explain why substantive research on Indian history has increasingly become the prerogative of British, and a few American and Australian universities. The presiding deities of Indian historiography have meanwhile devoted themselves to writing politically correct text books that present history as chapters of received wisdom. They have also drafted resolutions for the Indian History Congress and written articles in the press on the Ayodhya issue."
c11.s3.17
The story of their resolutions for the Indian History Congress and their articles on the Ayodhya issue may be briefly recapitulated. A pamphlet entitled "The Political Abuse of History: Babri Masjid - Ram Janmabhumi Dispute" was issued by the Faculty members of the Centre of Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University (INU). It was authored by Professors S. Gopal, Romila Thapar and Bipan Chandra, among others. This "group history", if it was meant to decide the issue of Babri Masjid-Ramjanmabhumi once for all through sheer weight of numbers, failed miserably. Many articles and books appeared to challenge the contention of JNU professors. These were written not only by Hindus but also by Christians (Koenraad Elst) and Muslims (A.R. Khan). Professor A.R. Khan, Department of History, Himachal Pradesh University, Simla, wrote a long rejoinder to the pamphlet. The eminent historians from JNU had repeatedly asserted that Lord Rama's association with Ayodhya was based not on historical evidence but on belief. Dr. Khan asked: "The belief of the Hindus in Rama as an *avtar*, or god, is as strong as the belief of the Muslims in the Quran as a revealed work, as word of God. Can the said exponents of reason dare talk on evidence on the latter?"27
c11.s3.18
Of course, they dare not. But at many sessions of the Indian History Congress they continued to make noise about the Babri Masjid-Ramjanmabhumi. I had stopped attending the Annual sessions of the Indian History Congress a long time back because it had become a propaganda forum for Aligarhian and JNU secularist historians. I enjoyed reading in the newspaper about the goings on at the Congress of 1993 session held at Mysore.28 The newspaper on 18th December quoted a Professor from Aligarh as exclaiming that "it is to the credit of the History Congress that not a single 'outstanding' historian joined the ranks of the Vishva Hindu Parishad on the Babri Masjid issue". A noted history scholar, on the other hand "alleged that the forum of the Congress was being used as a political platform" (20th December). This is the level to which the Indian History Congress has been reduced by Marxist historians. They have gone by many fancy names like Marxists, secularists, amnestists, progressives etc. Their secular history only means hiding away Muslim fundamentalism or presenting its sanitized version.
c11.s3.19
In short, the Marxist historians in India derive strength and reputation from works done by foreigners. On their own they have little academic distinction. Their nearness to the establishment has made them academic snobs. They have made the Indian History Congress sessions their propaganda forum. They feel they possess the monopoly of interpreting medieval Indian history. I had a personal experience of this attitude at a U.G.C. seminar on "Urban Rural Relations in Medieval India" held in the History and Culture Department of Jamia Millia Islamia on 7 to 9 March, 1979. Many scholars were invited to this seminar including K.A. Nizami, Irfan Habib, H.S. Srivastava, Lallanji Gopal, Raghuvir Singh, Mushirul Hasan, Iqtidar Alam Khan, Harbans Mukhia, A.B.M. Habibullah, myself etc. etc. At this seminar the junior cadre were more vocal and intemperate. They thought no end of themselves and looked upon others with deep disdain. Once again I became convinced that this group was incapable of doing any substantial research. Irfan Habib is an exception. It must be said to his credit that he continues to work. It is another matter that he and his admirers think that only his secular and pro-Muslim views are the last word on Medieval Indian history.
c11.s3.20
My *Growth of Muslim Population in Medieval India* was published in 1973. It annoyed some secularist historians in Aligarh. According to them some dark spots of Muslim rule had been brought into focus. But a detailed analysis had to be given bearing on the demographic behaviour of the times. But if Irfan Habib rushed with an adverse review of the book, there were many others who praised it for marshalling such a vast array of evidence in support of my conclusions . During the twenty-three years or so, between the publication of my *History of the Khaljis* (1950) and the *Growth of Muslim Population in Medieval India* (1973), I had not been vegetating. I had been constantly working and growing through learning and experience. I had published the *Twilight of the Sultanate* in 1963 and *Studies in Medieval Indian History* in 1966. I had edited the volume containing papers presented at the First Asian History Congress held at Azad Bhavan, New Delhi, in 1961. It was published by the Indian Council of Cultural Relations as *Studies in Asian History* (1969). Because of constant pursuit of learning, I had shed many old ideas which had been the product of an impressionable if not very mature mind.
c11.s3.21
Of this I shall give only one instance. In my *Studies in Medieval Indian History*, I had discussed about the "Factors underlying the loss of Indian independence in the Twelfth-Thirteenth centuries". In this I had repeatedly said that only Kshatriyas or Rajputs fought against foreign invaders. This is what I had said: "A nation exploited by the priestly class ... with only one caste set aside for the country's defence ... could never be gathered under one banner of a slogan like 'Hindustan in danger'." Again, "... the Rajputs alone fought against the foreign invaders, since the other castes had no obligation to defend the land..." And once again, "Only one caste - the Kshatriyas - was set aside for the purpose of defence against foreign invasions and protection of life and property from internal dissensions."²⁹
c11.s3.22
Equally funny (as they look now) were my observations on the state of Hindu society. "Inside the cities and towns under Hindu rule lived people only of the higher castes. The lower caste people like servants and untouchables like scavengers had their quarters outside the walled city. They came to serve in the city, but could not reside there. The Brahmin cook and Thakur watchman were the only servants who could stay on the premises of the master or go inside his house. It was a very satisfactory arrangement so long as it worked. But when district after district passed into the hands of the Muslims, and Muslims in large numbers began to reside in cities and towns, the shape and form of the latter were completely changed. Not that they treated the menial classes in any way better than the Hindus, but the stigma of untouchability was gradually lost in a Muslim-ruled city. The untouchables served in the cities as before, but now they also lived there. Although the Hindus continued to treat the menials as untouchables and the menial classes continued to remain Hindu, yet in a city under Muslim control the stigma of untouchability was gradually gone and the lower-class people felt better under Muslim rule. The Hindu system had been distasteful to them."³⁰
c11.s3.23
These views had been pressed into my mind by long oral discussions with Professor Mohammad Habib and the writings of Mohammad Habib and K.A. Nizami. The caste system has been considered by these scholars as a very major, if not the sole, cause of the defeat of the Hindus at the hands of the Turks. Professor Mohammad Habib writes, "The conquest of northern India (by Muhammadans), when all factors are kept in mind, can be explained only by one fact the caste system ... the division of the people into smaller water-tight sub-caste groups resulting in the total annihilation of any sense of common citizenship or of loyalty to the country as a whole."³¹ Professor K.A. Nizami arrives at a similar conclusion when he says: "The real cause of the defeat of the Indians lay in their ... invidious caste distinctions which weakened their military organization. That patriotic fervour in which every citizen instinctively lays his hand on the sword-hilt in moments of national crisis was killed by these caste distinctions. The bulk of the Indian population was apathetic towards the fortunes of the ruling dynasties. No appeal from the Rajput governing classes could possibly receive sympathetic response from the vast mass of Indian population..."³² I too began to share this view, but later on, on a re-evaluation of facts thought to be unimportant earlier, critical analysis and deeper reflection which grow with age, it appeared to me that the role of caste in the defeat of the Hindus has been given undue importance and emphasis. So that ten years later in my *Early Muslims in India* published in 1984, I wrote as follows: "There is no doubt that caste meant varied interests and divided opinions, but caste after all was a social evil, not a military disadvantage. The Kshatriyas never suffered on account of shortage of numbers on the fields of battle." The mention in the *Shastras* that it was the duty of the Kshatriyas to defend the land, should not lead to the misconception that all others were debarred or disinterested in the defence of their religion and country. Muslim chroniclers do not talk of the Kshatriyas alone participating in battles. They always speak of the 'Hindus', meaning thereby the people as such, fighting in wars. The huge casualties in wars as detailed by the chroniclers also point to the people's resistance to the invaders and conquerors and not only of a small section of the warriors.³³ Indeed Jats, Khokhars and Gakkars, who were not high in the Hindu caste hierarchy, enthusiastically fought against Mahmud on many occasions.
c11.s3.24
And now, another ten years later, as a result of continuous study, I have arrived at the conclusion in my *Growth of Scheduled Tribes and Castes in Medieval India* (1995) that all castes, all classes of people, resisted foreign invaders and rulers, the lower classes as much as the higher, if not more. How else was this vast country saved from Islamization? How else, among the countries of the East, which experienced the visitation of Islamic armies, India alone could successfully repulse Muslim onslaughts and ultimately do away with Muslim rule slowly but surely? It is because all people, and not only Kshatriyas, put up a perennial resistance to Muslim invaders and rulers to the best of their capabilities.
c11.s3.25
My studies in the course of years did not remain confined to Persian chronicles; they were supplemented by indigenous source materials like the Rajput chronicles, the vast Bhakti or Vaishnav literature, as well as the plethora of historical works produced by modern scholars on medieval Indian history But the most effective influence was created on my mind by the study of the Quran, the Hadis, the *Hidayah* and other original works on Islamic law. I saw a clear relationship between Islamic scriptures and the actions and policies of Muslim invaders and rulers as faithfully recorded by Medieval Muslim historians. I became convinced that Muslim rule in India derived its inspiration from the dictates of Islamic religion. And in my writings in the nineties I began to quote extensively from these original sources of Islamic law and history instead of only citing from medieval Muslim chronicles. That is how a difference is seen between the *History of the Khaljis* and *Twilight of the Sultanate* on the one hand and the *Legacy of Muslim Rule in India* and other books written by me in the eighties and nineties, on the other. One does grow during the course of half a century if one continues with his studies and I have surely grown. And since I do no believe that "Muslim rule should not attract any criticism. Destruction of temples by Muslim invaders and rulers should not be mentioned and forcible conversions to Islam should be ignored and deleted, etc. etc.", my books are free from such restrictions. I now also apply the same yardstick to medieval Indian history as is done with respect to modem Indian history. If British imperialism was bad for the Indian people so also was Muslim imperialism. Both these sought sustenance from cooperation of indigenous elements but neither of them became indigenous in nature. We in India write the history of British rule not from the point of view of European imperialism but from that of the victims of colonization. I apply the same methodology to the history of Muslim rule. I write about it from the people's point of view rather than from the view of Islamic imperialists. We cannot apply different standards of approach and methodology to different periods of Indian history.
c11.s3.26
¹ This is what B.N. Pandey stressed in many seminars and in conversation with S. Kalidas as reported in *The Times of India*, August 22, 1993, on the occasion of his receiving the Khudabakhsh Award for communal harmony from the President of India. "Once Aurangzeb was on his way to Bengal with a retinue of Hindu kings and their wives. When the caravan was about five miles from Banaras, the kings requested a day's halt so that they could bathe in the Ganges and pray at the Kashi Vishwanath temple. Aurangzeb acceded and the kings and their queens went to Banaras. When they returned the maharani of Kutch was missing from the group. A search was mounted and when she was not found, the temple was searched. This revealed a secret flight of steps which led to an underground vault. There the rani was, in a state of shock, her jewellery missing, her clothes torn off... She had obviously been raped. When Aurangzeb learnt this he was very angry. He thought if this can happen to the queen of the maharana of Kutch, who is under my protection, what must be the fate of lesser women! This was not a place of worship, he said, but a den of evil. It was in this context that he ordered the temple to be razed."
c11.s3.27
This cock and bull story has not been swallowed even by die-hard secularists because of the overwhelming evidence available in the Muslim chronicles about the motives of the Emperor. Aurangzeb was prompted to destroy this and similar other temples in important centres of Hindu pilgrimage to suppress Hindu learning and their practising "idolatry".
c11.s3.28
² Mazumdar, *Socio-Economic History of Northern India*, pp. 153-156.
c11.s3.29
³ Afif, pp. 302-315. Also Carr Stephen, *Archaeology of Delhi*, pp. 292-293 and Thomas, Chronicles of the Pathan Kings of Delhi. pp. 292-93.
c11.s3.30
⁴ *Maasir-i-Alamgiri*, pp. 51-52.
c11.s3.31
⁵ Afif, pp. 379-82: *Zunnardaran kalid-i-hujra-i-kufrund wa kafiran bar eshan muatqid und*. Barani, p. 42, calls the Brahmans as
c11.s3.32
Imams of Hindus and recommends their systematic liquidation. Also Dom, I, p. 65; Farishtah, I, p. 182 and *Maasir-i-Alamgiri*, pp. 51-52.
c11.s3.33
6 Barani, p. 273-74; *History of the Khaljis*, p. 87.
c11.s3.34
7 *History of the Khaljis*, p. 288.
c11.s3.35
8 Afif, pp. 205-206, 232-233; Barani, pp. 446-450.
c11.s3.36
9 *Tuzuk*, vol. I, pp. 162-63.
c11.s3.37
10 *Ibid*., p. 182.
c11.s3.38
11 T.P. Hughes, *Dictionary of Islam*, p. 382.
c11.s3.39
12 *The Times of India*, May 12, 1995. Editorial in the same paper, May 25, 1995. Apology in Indian Express, July 25, 1995.
c11.s3.40
13 *The Times of India*, July 24, 1995.
c11.s3.41
14 *The Times of India*, Viewpoint, May 1, 1996.
c11.s3.42
15 *Indian Express*, New Delhi, May 21, 1995.
c11.s3.43
16 Muzaffar Hussain, 'Lynch law in Iran', article in *Organiser*, New Delhi, May 26,1996.
c11.s3.44
17 *The Times of India*, New Delhi, April 22, 1996.
c11.s3.45
18 This has been done by many colonizers and imperialists. Later in the day European imperialists and colonizers just wiped out major sections of indigenous population in America, Africa and Australia. The "aboriginals" in these continents were reduced to microscopic numbers so that the colonizers began to claim that they were the main inhabitants of America and Australia in particular. So also was tried to be done by Muslims in India who began to claim Hindustan as a country of Islam. Indian resistance, however, did not let any such situation develop in India.
c11.s3.46
19 K.S. Lal, *Growth of Muslim Population in Medieval India*, pp. 39-42. For copious references to support these figures, the book itself may be consulted.
c11.s3.47
20 Lal, *Growth of Muslim Population*, pp. 42-44, 217.
c11.s3.48
21 As Lawrance Stone has pointed out, "The unfounded hypotheses about the beneficent results of early Spanish colonization of Mexico based on purely literary evidence and supported because of national or personal prejudice, collapsed utterly when it was discovered by the demographic quantifiers that the (American) Indian population fell from about 25 million to about 2 million in less than 50 years after Hernando Cortes had first landed." Lawrance Stone in C.F. Delzell (ed.), *The Future of History*, Nashville, Tennessee, 1977, p. 17.
c11.s3.49
22 Industrial Commission Report, p. 295.
c11.s3.50
23 For this statement Habib quotes Lynn White Jr. from his article in the *American Historical Review* of April 1960.
c11.s3.51
24 Probably referred to in the *Mrichchhakatika* (The Little Clay Cart) of Sudraka who lived in Gupta times.
c11.s3.52
²⁵ K.S. Lal, "The Striking Power of the Army of the Sultanate", *Journal of Indian History*, vol. LV, part 3, December 1977, pp. 85-110 esp. p. 86.
c11.s3.53
²⁶ K.S. Lal, *Twilight of the Sultanate*, Bombay, 1963, p. 295.
c11.s3.54
²⁷ *Express Magazine*, February 25, 1990.
c11.s3.55
²⁸ *Times of India*, New Delhi, December 18-20, 1993.
c11.s3.56
²⁹ Lal, *Studies*, pp. 117, 119, 120.
c11.s3.57
31 M. Habib, *Indian Culture and Social Life at the Time of Turkish Invasions*, published by Aligarh Historical Institute, Lahore (n.d.), p. 6.
c11.s3.58
32 K.A. Nizami, *Some Aspects of Religion and Politics in India during the Thirteenth Century*, Aligarh, 1961, p. 79.
c11.s3.59
33 Lal, *Early Muslims in India*, New Delhi, 1984, pp. 39-40.
Cites (3)
- Tārīkh-i Firishta — Muḥammad Qāsim Hindū Shāh Firishta 1606, Persian
- Mṛcchakaṭika — Śūdraka, Sanskrit
- Tārīkh-i Fīrūzshāhī — Shams-i Sirāj ʿAfīf, Persian