Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India c11.s3.12

Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India c11.s3.12

Language
English

c11.s3.12

In July, 1963, I joined the University of Delhi as Reader in (Medieval) Indian history A seminar on "Ideas motivating Social and Cultural Movements and Economic and Political policies during the 15th, 16th and 17th centuries in India" was organised by the History Department of the Delhi University in November, 1965. I presented a paper on "Ideas leading to the impoverishment of the Indian peasantry in medieval times". It had been dinned into our ears that the extreme poverty of the Indian peasant was due to the administrative policies and exploitation of the British rule. I had often wondered if this execrable poverty was the result of a century or so only of British rule, or whether this poverty was of remote past and its origins could be traced back to the medieval period. I found enough evidence to arrive at the conclusion that there was systematic impoverishment of the agriculturists under Muslim rule; to blame the British alone was not right. But such a conclusion was against the current fashion. To find fault with Muslim rule was not in conformity with secular history. After I had presented the paper many delegates spoke to express their views, as is usual in seminars. But Professor Saiyyad Nurul Hasan indulged in "trenchant criticism" of the paper. He was a Marxist, a secularist, and a progressive historian. Such was the clout of this group of historians that they would not brook any disagreement with their mental fixture of only appreciation and praise for Muslim rule in India. I became convinced that until this "gagging of others" was not challenged, their brand of history would go unchecked. Since then I have challenged them in my books.