Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India c11.s3.23
Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India c11.s3.23
- Language
- English
c11.s3.23
These views had been pressed into my mind by long oral discussions with Professor Mohammad Habib and the writings of Mohammad Habib and K.A. Nizami. The caste system has been considered by these scholars as a very major, if not the sole, cause of the defeat of the Hindus at the hands of the Turks. Professor Mohammad Habib writes, "The conquest of northern India (by Muhammadans), when all factors are kept in mind, can be explained only by one fact the caste system ... the division of the people into smaller water-tight sub-caste groups resulting in the total annihilation of any sense of common citizenship or of loyalty to the country as a whole."³¹ Professor K.A. Nizami arrives at a similar conclusion when he says: "The real cause of the defeat of the Indians lay in their ... invidious caste distinctions which weakened their military organization. That patriotic fervour in which every citizen instinctively lays his hand on the sword-hilt in moments of national crisis was killed by these caste distinctions. The bulk of the Indian population was apathetic towards the fortunes of the ruling dynasties. No appeal from the Rajput governing classes could possibly receive sympathetic response from the vast mass of Indian population..."³² I too began to share this view, but later on, on a re-evaluation of facts thought to be unimportant earlier, critical analysis and deeper reflection which grow with age, it appeared to me that the role of caste in the defeat of the Hindus has been given undue importance and emphasis. So that ten years later in my *Early Muslims in India* published in 1984, I wrote as follows: "There is no doubt that caste meant varied interests and divided opinions, but caste after all was a social evil, not a military disadvantage. The Kshatriyas never suffered on account of shortage of numbers on the fields of battle." The mention in the *Shastras* that it was the duty of the Kshatriyas to defend the land, should not lead to the misconception that all others were debarred or disinterested in the defence of their religion and country. Muslim chroniclers do not talk of the Kshatriyas alone participating in battles. They always speak of the 'Hindus', meaning thereby the people as such, fighting in wars. The huge casualties in wars as detailed by the chroniclers also point to the people's resistance to the invaders and conquerors and not only of a small section of the warriors.³³ Indeed Jats, Khokhars and Gakkars, who were not high in the Hindu caste hierarchy, enthusiastically fought against Mahmud on many occasions.