The Positive Background of Hindu Sociology c11.s1.t6.4

c11.s1.t6.4

In the third edition it was possible for Smith to utilize also the lecture of Hillebrandt at Breslau (1908) as well as the lecture of Jolly at Heidelberg (1911). Jolly's paper on "*Arthaśāstra* und Dharmaśāstra" in the *Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft* (1913) was also acknowledged. It is interesting that Smith mentions Hillebrandt and Jolly who doubted the Maurya antiquity of the *Arthaśāstra* but ignores Jacobi whose paper (1912) was emphatically and aggressively in favour of the Indian tradition.