Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Early Buddhist Theory of Knowledge c8.217

Early Buddhist Theory of Knowledge c8.217

Language
English

c8.217

(230) We find this usage substantiated in the Jain Canonical texts, which sometimes speak of something having the characteristic q from one standpoint, the characteristic not-q from another and the characteristics q and not-q from both standpoints The Trairāśika usage was, therefore, probably not different from this. It also shows that though the Jains did not actually posit a separate dual standpoint they made use of the substantial-cum-modal standpoint in principle. We may illustrate this by an example in the Bhagavatī Sūtra,¹ where the question is asked of Mahāvīra, 'Are souls...eternal or non-eternal?' (Jīvā... kiṁ sāsayā asāsayā?) and it is replied that 'souls would be both eternal and non-eternal' (jīvā siya sāsayā, siya asāsayā) and this is further explained by saying that 'they are eternal in respect of their substance and non-eternal in respect of their states' (davvaṭṭhayāe sāsayā, bhāvaṭṭhayāe asāsayā).

Cites (1)