Early Buddhist Theory of Knowledge c8.232
Early Buddhist Theory of Knowledge c8.232
- Language
- English
c8.232
(238) These nayas are classified as seven in number ranging from the most general (naigama²) to the most specific (evambhūta). But there seems to have been a school, which believed only in four nayas, called the Catuskanayikas. Dr Basham is of the opinion that this is a 'small sub-sect of the Jainas with a somewhat unorthodox epistemology' (*op. cit*, 327). Abhayadeva says in considering their origin that this school 'in considering standpoints believes that naigama is two-fold, being both general and specific, and that the general falls into the general and the specific into the specific—thus there are the general (saṁgraha-), the specific (vyavahāra-) and the existential (ṛjusūtra) standpoints; the verbal standpoints are all the same and thus there are four standpoints'.³ This seems to suggest that the Catuskanayikas simplified the Jain schema, but it is by no means conclusive that this simplicity is due to the simplication of the complex rather than to the priority (in time) of the simpler. The passage that Weber⁴ has quoted from a Nandī commentary contrasts the Ājīvikas, the Catuskanayikas and the Trairāśikas from each other as well as from the Jains, viz 'Cha...sasamaīyāṇi, satta ājīviyāṇi, cha caükkanaiyāṇi satta terāsyāṇi'. They are all considered alien to 'one's own religion' (sva-samaya-, *v*. sasamaīyāṇi) so that the Catuskanayikas could not strictly have been a sub-sect tolerated by the Jains.