Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Purva-Mimamsa in its Sources c28.8

Pūrva-Mīmāṃsā in its Sources c28.8

Language
English

c28.8

Two answers have been provided to this question. (1) That the *Sūtras* under Discourse II have taken note of Acts only, and those also, only such as are actually found to fulfil only visible ends; while the present Discourse III takes up not only all *Acts* serving visible and invisible ends, but also such details as *Substances*, *Mantras* and so forth. This answer has been rejected by Kumārila (*Tantra-Vā.*, Trs., p. 670), on the ground that under the said explanation, the subject-matter of Discourse II would be only a part of what is dealt with under Discourse III. The explanation that he suggests is that—(2) the fact that the *Acts* dealt with under Discourse II—Threshing of the Corn, for instance,—are ‘subservient’ to others can be ascertained only from what the *Sūtras* set forth under Discourse III;—what has been said under Discourse II therefore is only this—that these acts cannot be regarded as bringing about an *Apūrva* by themselves, for the simple reason that they are found to fulfil purely visible purposes in connection with some other acts;—‘and under the circumstances, if they were to produce their own *Apūrva*,—there would be several *Apūrvas* produced by the Act’—adds the *Ṛijuvimalā* (MS., Vol. III, p. 11). (See p. 265)

Cites (1)