The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c10.6
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c10.6
- Language
- English
c10.6
The Urdu sources quoted in this work agree that Bābar ordered destruction of the Rāma temple and construction of the mosque on its site at the instance of Sayyid Mūsā 'Āshiqān. Professor A.R. Khan doubts the Sayyid's historicity. He contends that 'two of my research scholars (Dr. Yograj Malhotra and Tej Ram) and I have worked out the biographies from the contemporary and near-contemporary sources of all the persons in Bābur's service. No person by the name of Mūsā 'Ashiqān or Sayyid Mīr 'Āshiqān under whose "patronage" the mosque in question was supposed to have been built is traceable in Bābur's times.¹ The learned professor is too solicitous about contemporaneity of evidence. Mawlawiyy 'Abdu 'l-Karīm (1235 A.H./ 1820A.D.-1308 A.H./1891 A.D.), author of the *Gumgashtah Hālāt-i Ajodhyā Ya'nī Tārīkh-i Parīnah-i Madīnatu 'l-Awliyā* (original, Persian version), refers to one Sayyid Sulṭān 'Alī alias Sayyid Sulṭān Bakhsh whom he knew personally and as belonging to the line of Sayyid Mūsā 'Āshiqān.² Now, it appears that Bābar's vandalism at Ayodhya was a passing episode, like the invasion of Alexander, for it was totally forgotten not only by the Hindus but also by Muslim authors and foreign travellers for some 275 years. Let alone Abu 'l-Faḍi and Sujān Rāi Bhaṇḍarī, author of the *Khulāṣatu 't-Tawārīkh* (completed in 1695-96), even William Finch, who visited Ayodhya during 1608-11, makes no mention of the mosque, even though he describes Ayodhya including Ramkot at some length. He is aware of the popular belief in the *Avatāra*-hood of Rāma and his birth-place in the ruins of Ramkot, and describes these ruins as an abode of *Paṇḍā*-s. He observes, 'In these ruines remayne certaine Bramenes, who record the names of all such Indians as wash themselves in the river running thereby.' He does not miss 'a cave of his with a narrow entrance, but so spacious and full of turnings within that a man may well loose himselfe there if he takes not better heed; where it is thought his ashes were buried. Hither resort many from all parts of India, which carry from thence in remembrance certain granes of rice as blacke as gun-powder which they say have been reserved ever since.' The cave is said to be 'some two miles on the further side of the river'.