Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.102

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.102

Language
English

c25.102

I do not deny the existence of the structure. I demur to the name and its misleading implications. Its name, as it appears on the marble 2 plate of its gate, is 'Janmasthan Sita Rasoi', or, to follow the *Ayodhyamahatmya*, 'Pakasthan'. The adjectival expression 'Janmasthan' suggests that it formed part of the Rama Janmasthan/Janmahbhoomi temple displaced by the Babari mosque. In fact, the entire mound called Ramkot is divided by a road, on one side of which stands the Babari mosque and on the other the Janmasthan Sita Rasoi. It appears to have originally been covered with a big block called Rama Janmabhoomi temple. The Janmasthan Sita Rasoi formed part of it and yet escaped destruction, without ever usurping the right of the destroyed part to be the birth-place of Rama. Not being the Janmasthan/Janmabhoomi proper, it has never figured in the dispute between the Babari mosque and the Janmabhoomi temple. It is, therefore, not the Janmasthan Sita Rasoi but the Janmabhoomi temple from which the Babri mosque derives its second name 'Masjid-i Janmasthan'. Indeed, as it is, the Janmasthan Sita Rasoi presupposes the existence of the Janmabhoomi temple.

Cites (1)