The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.12
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.12
- Language
- English
c25.12
First, an indirect evidence. In an application dated November 30, 1858, filed by one Muhammad Asghar, Khatib and Mu‘azzin, Babari Masjid, to initiate legal proceeding against ‘Bairagiyan-i Janmasthan’, the Babari mosque has been called ‘masjid-i Janmasthan’ and the courtyard near the arch and the pulpit within the boundary of the mosque, ‘maqam Janmasthan ka’. The Bairagis had raised a platform in the courtyard which the applicant wanted to be dismantled. He has mentioned that the place of Janmasthan had been lying unkempt/in disorder (*parishan*) for hundreds of years and that the Hindus performed worship there (*maqam Janmasthan ka sad-ha baras se parishan para rahta tha. Ahl-i Hunud puja karte they*). See Sayyid Sabahuddin Abdur Rahman, *op.cit.*, pp. 29-30. Well, if the Babari mosque is the Janmasthan mosque, its courtyard is the Janmasthan, and the Hindus had all along been carrying out their worship and all that it implies there, there must have been some construction there as part of a (Janmasthan) temple, which Mīr Bāqī partly demolished and partly converted into the existing Babari mosque, with or without Babar's approval. And the Hindus had no alternative but to make do with the temple-less courtyard. Otherwise, it is simply unthinkable that they might have been performing worhsip for such a long time and on such a sacred place without a proper temple.