Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.60

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.60

Language
English

c25.60

Sir : The "four-fold documentary evidence" produced by Dr Harsh Narain in support of Ramjanmabhoomi Temple in his article titled "Muslim testimony" (IE,. Feb. 26) is as weak as the evidence advanced to the contrary by the JNU historians which I have contested in my article "In the name of history" (IE, Feb. 25). Apart from the fact that not every written or printed word is an evidence of its authenticity, the four works cited by Dr Harsh Narain in support of his thesis were written and published in 1855-56, 1869, 1986 and 1987, the earliest 327-28 years after the construction of the controversial mosque. Yet Dr Harsh Narain treats the above works as "primary sources of medieval Indian history" which leaves no scope for discussion on his "incontrovertible conclusions". However, in recognition of his researches it may be pointed out that two of my research scholars (Dr Yogrj Malhotra and Dr Tej Ram) and I have worked out the biographies from the contemporary and near contemporary sources of all the persons in Babur's service. No person by the name of Musa Ashiqan or Sayyid Mir Ashiqan under whose "patronage" the mosque in question was supposed to have been built is traceable in Babur's times. Therefore, it is time we gave up the battle of evidence, before it passes into the hands of amateurs, and look for a solution to the problem in a sphere outside the domain of history. History in the hands of amateurs can be as dangerous as in the service of the nation by the courtesy of professionals.