Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.68

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.68

Language
English

c25.68

(1) that the Babari mosque is the Janmasthan mosque, (2) that its courtyard is the Janmasthan, (3) that the Janmasthan had been lying unkept or in disorder for hundreds of years, and (4) that the Hindus had been carrying on their worship there from long before the year 1858. The upshot of all these facts taken together is that the tradition of the Ramajanmasthan temple displaced by the Babari mosque is an age-old one, much older than the British records thereof. Instead of taking these facts together, Syed Shahabuddin has singled out the name Janmasthan mosque. In so doing, however, he has had to acknowledge that the locality of the mosque came to be received as the Ramajanmasthan thanks to the work of Tulasidas and patronage of the Muslim rulers, and, let me add on his behalf, not to the craftiness of the British. Does it stand to reason that the locality became popular as Janmasthan after it or much of it had been occupied by the Babari mosque? And what inspired the Muslim rulers to contribute to the popularity of the name Janmasthan? Such questions are far from answerable on Syed Shahabuddin's thesis.