Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.81

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c25.81

Language
English

c25.81

Sir: I refer to Dr Harsh Narain’s letter (IE, March 22). I do not question the textual authenticity of Dr Narain’s sources but I question his conclusions as to the ‘facts’ yielded by them. The only fact yielded by his first source is that at a certain period Babari Masjid was also called the Janmasthan Masjid which may well be due to the fact that the Ram Janmasthan Mandir is situated next to it. It does not yield the conclusion that the courtyard which is part of the structure or the outer courtyard (within the compound wall) is the birthsite of Lord Rama. Neither does it yield the conclusion that the site 'lying in disorder for hundreds of years' is the site occupied by the Babari Masjid or its compound because since the Masjid's construction in 1528 or even since Ayodhya's occupation by the Afghans in 1192, the site has never been uninhabited or desolate. Nor does it lead to the conclusion that the Hindus had been carrying on their worship on the site of Masjid or within its compound from long before 1858.