The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c26.6
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c26.6
- Language
- English
c26.6
4. But the Qur'ān and the Prophet do not sanction or envisage it. The Qur'ān speaks of two kinds of mosques — a mosque founded on piety (*assasa bunyāna-hū 'alā taqwā*) on the one hand and a mosque founded on the brink of a crumbling, over-hanging precipice (*assasa bunyānu-hū 'alā shafā jurufin hārin*) on the other,¹ the latter chosen with a view to evil-doing and disloyalty (*attakhadhū masjidan dirāram wa kufran*)² and bound to topple into the hell-fire along with its builders (*fa anhāra bi-hī fī nār-i jahannama*).³ This second kind has come to be designated as the mosque of evil (*masjidu 'd-dirār*). The Qur'ān prohibits prayer in this kind of mosque: Never stand (to pray) therein (*Lā taqum fī-hi abadan*).⁴ As a matter of fact, these Qur'ānic commands were occasioned by a real mosque of evil built by some Muslims on the outskirts of Medina. They invited the Prophet to inaugurate it by offering prayer, but the Prophet, though agreeable in the first instance, set fire to it and smashed it to pieces.¹ Does it not cut the ground from under the feet of the ‘once a mosque, always a mosque’ thesis?