The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c3.11
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c3.11
- Language
- English
c3.11
In his *Hadīqah-ī Shuhadā* (1956), Mirzā Jān quotes a passage from a work entitled *Sahīfah-ī Chihal Naṣā'ih-i Bahādurshāhī*, a copy of which, made in 1816, was found by him in the library of Mirzā Ḥaydar Shukoh s/o Mirzā Sulaymān Shukoh s/o Prince Dārā Shukoh, which says that the mosque in question has displaced the temple in question. The work he attributes to Aurangzīb's grand-daughter. It seems to have been composed in 1707 circa. Instead of trying to find it out, the pro-mosque historians dismiss it as either spurious or non-existent. But Mirzā Jān is not the only author to refer to it. Mirzā Rajab 'Alī Beg Surūr, author of the *Fasānah-ī 'Ibrat* and a contemporary of Mirzā Jān, refers to it as telling the tale of the temple-demolition and also as a work easily available in his time. Besides, there are about a dozen nineteenth-century records from Muslim pen which contain similar information 'gathered from past records and books of history.' How can they all be belied ? Especially when the information had the potentiality of jeopardizing their case for recovery of the alleged Hanumangadhi mosque pending in the royal court and at any rate by implication bolstering up the Bairagī-s' case for recovery of the Rāma temple. It is indeed significant that prior to the present controversy the fact of the temple-demolition was not called in question even once.