The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c3.12
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c3.12
- Language
- English
c3.12
It appears that after Bābar the mosque came to be deserted by Muslims and continued to be used by Hindus till, say, the turn of the 17th century. That is why William Finch (1608-11) found neither Muslims nor the mosque but only *Paṇḍā-s* in the Ramkot, where the ‘castle and houses’ connected with Rāma were in ruins; Abu ’l-Faḍl speaks of Ayodhya as the place of Rāma’s incarnation and of the great Rāmanavamī fair held there annually; Sant Lāladāsa, author of the *Avadhavilāsa* (1675), gives details about the birth-place of Rāma without referring to any mosque; Sujān Rāi Bhaṇḍārī, author of the *Khulāṣatu’t-Tawārīkh* (1695-96), mentions the replacement by a mosque of the Keśava Rāi temple at Mathura on the orders of Aurangzīb but is silent about the similar incident at Ayodhya, though he does mention Ayodhya as the birth-place of Rāma and thereby as ‘one of the holiest places’. It appears that the Rāma temple fell a victim soon after to the forces of temple destruction let loose by Aurangzīb, which is why it is as late as circa 1707 that the mosque came to be remembered in the *Ṣaḥīfah-i Chihal Naṣā’ih-i Bahādurshāhī* after a gap of 275 years, without, however, any reference to the name of the destroyer. No wonder that, according to Joseph Tieffenthaler (1710-1785), who toured Avadh during 1766-1771, it was widely acknowledged that the replacement of the temple by the mosque was effected by Bābar or Aurangzīb. Even during Aurangzīb’s time, however, the mosque could not attain the shape of a full-fledged mosque. The map of Ayodhya found in the Kapad-Dwār Collection of the City Palace Musuem, Jaipur, shows that, in 1717, the superstructure of the ‘mosque’ comprised of three *Śikhara-s* (temple-spires) had no domes but only corbelled ceilings originally. The domes owe their existence to someone else than Bābar and Aurangzīb, who came after them.