The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c9.3
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c9.3
- Language
- English
c9.3
1. Application dated November 30, 1858, filed by Muḥammad Aṣghar, Khaṭīb & Mu'adhhin, ‘Bābarī Masjid’, for initiation of judicial proceedings against the ‘*Bairāgīyān-i Janmasthān*’, calling the mosque ‘*masjid-i Janmasthān*’ and the courtyard near the arch and the pulpit within the boundary of the mosque ‘*maqām Janmasthān kā*’. The Bairāgī-s had raised a platform in the courtyard which the applicant wanted dismantled. He mentions that the Janmasthān area had been lying unkempt/in disorder (*parīshān*) for hundreds of years and that the Hindus carried on worship there (*maqām Janmasthān kā ṣad-hā baras se parīshān parā rahtā thā. Ahl-i Hunūd pūjā karte the*.)¹ Well, if the mosque (once described by the applicant as ‘masjid-ī Bābarī’) is the Janmasthān mosque, its courtyard is the Janmasthān, and the Hindus had all along been carrying on their worship (and all that it implies) there, it can safely be presumed that there used to be some construction there as part of a (Janmasthān) temple, which came partly to be destroyed and partly converted into the existing mosque. And the Hindus had no alternative to making do with the templeless courtyard. It is indeed unthinkable that they might have been carrying on worship without a proper temple at such a sacred place and for such a long time.